Search cheap accommodations in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!

1296 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fire Island, NY accommodations
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

1296 Lodgings in Fire Island, NY

Search Coastal Lodgings near Fire Island, NY

Enjoy a relaxing coastal vacation at these seaside accommodations in Fire Island, NY, located near the shoreline for easy beach-town exploration.

The Surfcomber Unit 2 - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

The Surfcomber Unit 2

house, Fire Island
Surfcomber Unit 2 is located in Ocean Bay Park, a 3-minute walk from Ocean Beach.
This 360-square-foot condo accommodates up to 7 guests and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, a walk-in shower, and is just a 3-minute walk to a restaurant.

Best family friendly Fire Island, NY lodging

Among the 1296 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best for families

Cozy Modern Ranch Near Bellport & Hamptons Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.5 33 reviews

Cozy Modern Ranch Near Bellport & Hamptons Retreat

apartment, Brookhaven
This Brookhaven home is located just a short drive from the ocean, bay, and the ferry to Fire Island, as well as the train station and Bellport village. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This spacious house features three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and a large living room, comfortably accommodating up to five guests. The home offers a modern kitchen, a private outdoor space with a deck, BBQ grill, and fire pit, and entertainment options like a TV with Apple TV.
Bellport Tranquility - Fire Island, NY
10 6 reviews

Bellport Tranquility

apartment, Bellport
This home is located in Bellport Village, just a short walk from the charming downtown area with its shops and restaurants, and a few minutes' drive from Bellport Bay and the Long Island Sound. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom house comfortably sleeps 7 guests and includes a king bed, queen bed, full bed with bunk beds, and a couch with a blow-up mattress. The home features a private, fenced backyard, a heated saltwater pool and spa, an outdoor shower, a Peloton bike and weights, wood-burning indoor and outdoor fireplaces, central AC, and off-street parking for 2-3 cars.
Fire Island Beach House Sleeps 10. Newly Renovated - Fire Island, NY
10 12 reviews

Fire Island Beach House Sleeps 10. Newly Renovated

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island rental house in the Stephens area is a short 2-3 minute walk from the beach.
The three-bedroom house, sleeping up to ten guests, offers a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, a terrace, a garden, and a fitness center; midweek and weekend rental options are available from early May to October.
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, 3 Bedroom, Close To Ferry, Village And All Beaches! - Fire Island, NY
9.0 56 reviews

Ocean Beach, Fire Island, 3 Bedroom, Close To Ferry, Village And All Beaches!

apartment, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach vacation rental is centrally located on Bay Walk, steps from Ocean Beach's Main Street and a short walk to the beach.
The 870-square-foot apartment sleeps eight comfortably in three bedrooms and two bathrooms, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, private outdoor shower, laundry facilities, Verizon WiFi, a 31" Smart Roku TV, and air conditioning.

Frequently Asked Questions about accommodations in Fire Island, NY

Popular destinations

Our Favorite Lodgings with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

Choosing a lodging in Fire Island, NY with a pool means you’ll always have a swimming option to complement a day by the water.

Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem On Fire Island - Pines - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem On Fire Island - Pines

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island vacation home is situated in Sayville, a short drive from Patchogue and its attractions, offering easy access to Fire Island National Seashore and Connetquot River State Park.
This three-bedroom, three-bathroom house features a fully equipped kitchen, a private hot tub, and accommodates up to six guests, providing convenient access to nearby beaches, theaters, and parks.
Private Fire Island Pines Private Retreat Pool/spa - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Private Fire Island Pines Private Retreat Pool/spa

apartment, Fire Island
This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental unit in Fire Island offers a peaceful retreat, located a short distance from its famed beaches and central villages.
This apartment accommodates up to 6 guests and features a kitchen with a fridge, air conditioning, a swimming pool, and a jacuzzi, providing a comfortable base for exploring Fire Island's diverse landscapes and recreational activities.
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

house, Fire Island
Vacation house. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.
Facilities and services include a dish washer, a washing machine and a fridge. Take advantage of the pool in this house.
Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews

Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool

apartment, Bellport
This Bellport home is conveniently located near Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts and William Floyd Estate, making it easy to explore the area's cultural and historical attractions. The surrounding area offers a mix of charming shops, restaurants, and serene natural landscapes.
This spacious 5-bedroom rental can comfortably accommodate up to 10 guests, offering ample room for families or groups of friends. The property features a full-size pool, hot tub, gym, and dedicated workspaces, ensuring a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Best Fire Island, NY accommodation with a kitchen

Fire Island Pines Paradise. - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews

Fire Island Pines Paradise.

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island accommodation offers a prime location, just a 2-minute walk to the beach and a 5-minute walk to the Pines ferry dock, dining, and shopping.
This newly refreshed two-bedroom condo accommodates up to 5 guests and features a private deck with an ocean view, a Jacuzzi hot tub, an outdoor shower, and high-speed internet.
Contemporary Beach House - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Contemporary Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
This three-bedroom house is located in Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, a desirable vacation area offering easy access to Fire Island's beaches.
The 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home features a great room with 25-foot vaulted ceilings, a large eat-in kitchen, a new barbecue, and accommodates up to 8 guests, perfect for a summer 2025 getaway.
Industrial Designer Beach House. - Fire Island, NY
10 11 reviews

Industrial Designer Beach House.

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines home is a 3-minute walk from the town and a 1-minute walk from the beach, offering stunning east, south, and west ocean views.
The four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and boasts a heated saltwater pool, chef's kitchen with a large center island, SONOS sound system, and high-speed WiFi.
Beach House Davis Park, Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
10 10 reviews

Beach House Davis Park, Fire Island

apartment, Fire Island
This waterfront vacation home is located on Fire Island, just 1 mile from Great South Bay and within 6 miles of Oak Road Beach and Foster Ave Beach. It has received excellent user ratings for its comfortable and convenient accommodations. This 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom house spans 1190 square feet and can comfortably accommodate up to 10 guests. The house offers amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, free WiFi, barbecue grills, a private fenced yard, and a terrace or balcony.

Best Fire Island, NY accommodation with a balcony

Atlantic Ocean Beach Retreat -Stay 2 Mi From Smiths Point Beach In Mastic Beach - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Atlantic Ocean Beach Retreat -Stay 2 Mi From Smiths Point Beach In Mastic Beach

apartment, Mastic Beach
Air Conditioned 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 25 reviews

Air Conditioned 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
The Bay House Patchogue Bay & Town 15 Minutes Walk - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

The Bay House Patchogue Bay & Town 15 Minutes Walk

apartment, Patchogue
Fire Island Atlantique Beach House Paradise - Fire Island, NY
9.8 24 reviews

Fire Island Atlantique Beach House Paradise

apartment, Fire Island

Popular Luxury Lodgings in Fire Island, NY

Luxury lodging in Fire Island, NY elevates your stay with refined service, premium amenities, and a perfectly situated home base.

Bellport Village Temperance Hall: Bellport Loft - Fire Island, NY
10 22 reviews

Bellport Village Temperance Hall: Bellport Loft

apartment, Bellport

Check Out Pet-Friendly Lodgings in Fire Island, NY

Bringing your dog to Fire Island, NY? Every lodging in this selection features dog-friendly amenities.

Luxury Waterfront Oasis  Modern Retreat For 8 - Fire Island, NY
9.7 179 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Oasis Modern Retreat For 8

apartment, Bayport
Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course - Fire Island, NY
10 17 reviews

Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course

apartment, East Patchogue
Waterview Beach House: 3 Kings + Putting Green - Fire Island, NY
9.9 214 reviews

Waterview Beach House: 3 Kings + Putting Green

apartment, Shirley
Last Minute Deal 7-6 7-12 Ocean Beach Fi House Perfect Distance To Beach & Town - Fire Island, NY
9.8 53 reviews

Last Minute Deal 7-6 7-12 Ocean Beach Fi House Perfect Distance To Beach & Town

apartment, Fire Island

Compare Accommodations with On-Site Dining in Fire Island, NY

On-site dining featuring fresh local food comes with every of these lodgings in Fire Island, NY, so dinner is sorted without leaving the property.

Bayfront Home In Patchogue W/ Deck & Fishing Dock - Fire Island, NY
9.5 13 reviews

Bayfront Home In Patchogue W/ Deck & Fishing Dock

apartment, East Patchogue
©2026 cozycozy.com