Best Short term and Weekly rentals in Fire Island, NY
10 9 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$193/nighttotal: $1158 (6 )
Charming Secluded Waterfront Retreat
1 2
apartment , Great River
This waterfront studio apartment in Great River is located on a secluded, tree-lined road, offering privacy via a private bridge and proximity to the airport and ferries. This apartment features a fully equipped kitchen, a full bathroom, and accommodates up to 2 guests, with water views from every window and easy access to a state park for kayaking and fishing.
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$1050/nighttotal: $3150 (3 )
The Surfcomber Unit 2
1 1
apartment , Fire Island
This one-bedroom rental is located in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, just 240 feet from the beach and the Atlantic Ocean, offering convenient access to watersports at Fire Island SUP Co. and a short walk to Seaview and dining options like Schooner's Inn. This pet-friendly apartment accommodates up to four guests and features a rooftop deck with outdoor dining, a well-equipped kitchen with a fridge and microwave, and air conditioning, making it ideal for a Fire Island getaway.
9.7 119 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/18 – 07/25
$128/nighttotal: $896 (7 )
Phils Cool Comfy Newly Renovated Spacious 1br Apt
1 2
apartment , North Great River
This North Great River apartment is conveniently located near the Long Island Rail Road station and a short drive to the South Shore's beautiful beaches. The apartment consistently receives excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall guest experience. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom rental comfortably accommodates two guests. The apartment features a spacious kitchen, a cozy living area, a private garden, and a side entrance through the garage, providing easy access and privacy.
9.8 42 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$293/nighttotal: $1172 (4 )
Lovely 1 Bedroom Apartment In West Islip
1 2
apartment , West Islip
This apartment is located in West Islip, just a short drive from Robert Moses Beach and the Babylon train station, making it easy to explore the area. The apartment has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. This cozy dwelling features a private entrance and backyard access, comfortably sleeping up to four guests. Enjoy amenities like air conditioning, parking, internet access, and a fully equipped kitchen, making your stay in West Islip convenient and relaxing.
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$1634/nighttotal: $9804 (6 )
Private Oasis Near The Hamptons
1 10
apartment , East Patchogue
This East Patchogue rental is a pet-friendly, 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom house offering 2000 sq ft of living space and accommodating up to 8 guests, featuring a spacious, fully fenced yard with a fire pit, a wraparound porch, a finished basement with a bar, and a dedicated office with a Tonal fitness system, all within close proximity to Long Island attractions like beaches, wineries, and Tanger Outlets. The property boasts amenities including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, garden, fitness center, and parking, with integrated Sonos wireless speakers for indoor and outdoor entertainment.
9.7 25 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/09
$1971/nighttotal: $13797 (7 )
Charming 4 Bed/4 Bath Home In The Pines With Pool!
4 4
apartment , Fire Island
This 3-bedroom residence is situated in Fire Island's Pines district, only steps from the beach, offering a prime location for a classic Fire Island vacation. This newly-renovated rental accommodates up to 8 guests and features a private pool, a detached pool house, an outdoor shower, a fully equipped kitchen with a SodaStream, on-site Peloton and weights, and provided beach gear.
9.9 190 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$541/nighttotal: $3787 (7 )
Fire Island Pines Mid-century Beach Cottage
1 3
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines beach house is a 10-minute walk from the dock and just 150 steps from the beach. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The cottage has two bedrooms and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge and microwave, high-speed internet, and multiple decks for enjoying the sun and views.
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$2215/nighttotal: $6645 (3 )
Spacious 5-bedroom House With Ac In Amazing Bay Shore
5 8
apartment , Bay Shore
This 5-bedroom house in Bay Shore is located near the YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts and the Bay Shore Historical Society, with Bay Shore Mini Golf and the Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal also a short distance away. This rental accommodates up to 12 guests and features air conditioning, internet, and an on-site fitness room, offering a serene atmosphere with an excellent layout for relaxation.
9.9 196 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$345/nighttotal: $2070 (6 )
Elevated House With Stunning Views Of Narrow Bay💙
1 2
apartment , Mastic Beach
This Mastic Beach apartment is just minutes from Smith Point Beach, one of Long Island's most popular beaches, offering a peaceful escape from the city. The apartment has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The apartment has an open floor plan, ideal for couples, with a capacity for four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, parking, and stunning bay views from the outdoor deck, perfect for relaxing or hosting small gatherings.
Fire Island, NY
06/20 – 06/27
$1111/nighttotal: $7777 (7 )
Charming, Freshly Updated 3-bedroom House In Superb Ocean Beach
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Ocean Beach house rental, north of Midway on Fire Island, offers easy access to the Fire Island Lighthouse and attractions in the Bay Shore area. The three-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps six, features new split AC/heating units in each room, WiFi, a washer/dryer, and an outdoor shower, and is close to Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, as well as Bay Shore Mini Golf and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$477/nighttotal: $1431 (3 )
1 Block To Bellport Bay! Scenic Hamptons Hideaway
3 2
apartment , Shirley
This Hamptons apartment is located 0.7 miles from Shirley Beach and features direct access to a nature trail leading to the waterfront. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom dwelling accommodates up to 6 guests and offers a private deck and patio, a fully equipped kitchen, Smart TVs, and in-unit laundry.
9.8 9 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1617/nighttotal: $4851 (3 )
Updated Beach Cottage
1 8
apartment , Fire Island
This pet-friendly Fire Island cottage, steps from both the Atlantic Ocean and a bay beach, offers easy access to swimming and sunbathing. The three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and features a large wrap-around deck, BBQ grill, beach chairs, bicycles, and umbrellas, plus a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge and dishwasher, air conditioning, and Wi-Fi.
Compare Family-Friendly Lodgings in Fire Island, NY
Waterfront family vacations in Fire Island, NY work best with proximity to the beach and plenty of room for everyone to spread out.
Fire Island, NY
07/20 – 07/24
$402/nighttotal: $1608 (4 )
Fire Island Escape, Steps To The Beach!
1 2
B&B , Fire Island
This Fire Island B&B, Unit 22 in Ocean Bay Park, offers a prime location steps from the beach and Great South Bay, and minutes from Ocean Beach. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom guesthouse sleeps two, features a private bathroom with walk-in shower, a refrigerator and microwave, and access to Seashore Condo Hotel amenities including free beach gear and grills.
9.9 122 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/20 – 07/24
$349/nighttotal: $1396 (4 )
Stay Downtown & Walk To Fire Island Ferries
1 2
apartment , Bay Shore
This ground-floor apartment rental in Bay Shore's historic Bay District is steps from restaurants, a spray park, the beach, the Bay Shore Ferry, and a 10-minute walk from the Long Island Rail Road. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit sleeps two, features a kitchen with a refrigerator, freezer, and microwave, private parking, and backyard access, plus it's located in a 150-year-old Mansard Victorian.
10 114 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/20 – 07/24
$899/nighttotal: $3596 (4 )
Hamptons Style Cottage
3 2
apartment , Patchogue
This waterfront vacation home is located in Patchogue, a short walk from Fire Island National Seashore, Bowl Long Island, and Shorefront Park. The home has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house features a fully equipped kitchen, a private yard, and a terrace or balcony. Amenities include air conditioning, internet access, parking, and a barbecue grill, making it ideal for families and groups looking for a comfortable and convenient stay.
10 21 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$1084/nighttotal: $3252 (3 )
Ny Waterfront Home With Private Beach Access
1 2
apartment , East Patchogue
This waterfront rental is located in East Patchogue, just a short distance from the Fire Island Ferry, Patchogue train station, and the charming restaurants of Bellport and Patchogue Village. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience. The apartment is spacious and can accommodate up to six guests. Enjoy amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, and a bar, all while taking in breathtaking views of the Great South Bay and Fire Island from the expansive deck.
Best Fire Island, NY lodging with a balcony
9.9 49 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$1306/nighttotal: $9142 (7 )
Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach
4 3
apartment , Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach vacation home is a short walk from the beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the area's natural beauty. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall guest experience. This 4-bedroom rental sleeps up to 10 guests and features a spacious 2500 square foot layout. Enjoy amenities like a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining during your stay.
9.9 275 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/20 – 07/24
$276/nighttotal: $1104 (4 )
Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit!
1 2
apartment , Islip Terrace
This Islip Terrace apartment is situated by the sea, offering scenic views from its balcony. It is within 2 miles of major attractions like Cohalan Court Complex and Bethpage Ballpark. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this apartment is a top choice for travelers. The apartment features a 400-square-foot layout with one bedroom, one bathroom, and a sofa bed for additional sleeping space. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, free WiFi, air conditioning, and access to a garden with barbecue grills. The smoke-free environment ensures a comfortable stay for all guests.
10 14 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/09
$1451/nighttotal: $10157 (7 )
Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course
4 4
apartment , East Patchogue
This beachfront vacation rental in East Patchogue offers direct access to outdoor activities and is a 5-minute walk to Great South Bay and a 4-minute drive to Bellport Country Club. This 3200 sq ft, 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home accommodates up to 8 guests and features a full kitchen, air conditioning, a swimming pool, hot tub, and a terrace.
10 24 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/20 – 06/27
$998/nighttotal: $6986 (7 )
Air Conditioned 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House
4 2
apartment , Fire Island
This charming beach house is located on Davis Park in the Fire Island Community, a short 20-minute ferry ride from Patchogue and just steps away from the beach, the ferry, and the Casino restaurant. This Fire Island rental is rated excellent by previous guests. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 8 guests in its 1190 square feet of space. Enjoy modern amenities, including air conditioning, a spacious kitchen, and a private outdoor shower, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach.
Frequently Asked Questions about short term rentals in Fire Island, NY
Which top landmarks you shouldn't miss in Fire Island, NY?
You definitely want to check out the Fire Island Lighthouse. It's a classic landmark, and the views from the top are incredible! Also, make sure to visit the Robert Moses State Park, a huge park with beaches and a boardwalk. It's a great place to spend a day.
What are the best short term rentals in Fire Island, NY?
What kind of weather can travelers expect in Fire Island, NY?
Fire Island has warm, humid summers with average highs in the 80s. The winters are mild, with average highs in the 40s. You should be prepared for some rain throughout the year, especially in the spring and fall.
What are the best short term rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?
Are there any famous stadiums or sports arenas in Fire Island, NY?
There aren't any stadiums or sports arenas on Fire Island. It's a pretty laid-back place, focused on beaches and relaxation. You can find some great sports bars, though, if you're looking for a game.
What are the best short term rentals with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?
What notable natural landmarks are near Fire Island, NY?
Fire Island is part of the Fire Island National Seashore, which is a beautiful area with lots of natural beauty. There are also some great beaches on the mainland, like Robert Moses State Park and Jones Beach State Park, that are easy to get to from Fire Island.
What are the best short term rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?
What part of Fire Island, NY is ideal for finding lodging?
The most popular places to stay are in Ocean Beach, Fire Island Pines, and Cherry Grove. These areas have a good mix of hotels, motels, and rental houses.
Destinations nearby
Best Fire Island, NY lodging with a kitchen
9.6 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$585/nighttotal: $2340 (4 )
Cozy Patchogue Escape
1 2
apartment , East Patchogue
This East Patchogue rental offers direct access to Patchogue Village's dining, drinking, and entertainment, with clubs open until 4 AM, placing you at the center of the village's nightlife. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom flat accommodates two guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen and air conditioning, ideal for travelers seeking proximity to Patchogue's active entertainment scene.
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/20 – 06/27
$943/nighttotal: $6601 (7 )
Sandy Beaches
1 2
apartment , Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach rental is steps from the beach and a three-minute walk from the town center's restaurants. The three-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment sleeps five to seven guests and offers a large patio, bikes, and full kitchen access.
8.7 17 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$610/nighttotal: $2440 (4 )
Sunny 2 Bedroom Cottage By The Bay
1 2
apartment , Patchogue
This Patchogue cottage, 450 feet from the bay and walking distance to Davis Park's Fire Island Ferry and LIRR, offers easy access to Patchogue's village and Long Island destinations. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps two guests and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, a private porch, back deck with grill, free parking, and Wi-Fi; enjoy nearby restaurants, running/biking paths, and the peaceful bay.
Best Fire Island, NY lodging with laundry available
10 9 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$1007/nighttotal: $3021 (3 )
Fire Island Pines, Rm #5 - Exclusive For Gay Men
1 2
apartment , Fire Island
This gay-male-exclusive guesthouse is located near Fire Island's beach, an eight-minute walk from the ferry and a two-minute walk from the ocean. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit offers a king-size bed, private garden entrance, saltwater pool, fitness center, and in-room amenities including a refrigerator, microwave, and coffee maker; it comfortably sleeps two guests.
9.8 12 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/20 – 06/27
$1050/nighttotal: $7350 (7 )
Beautiful And Private Cherry Grove, Ny Beach House
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island rental is located in the quiet east end, just a short walk from the ferry landing and the lighthouse. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The apartment has three bedrooms and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, outdoor shower, private deck, washer and dryer, and a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach.
Fire Island, NY
06/20 – 06/27
$625/nighttotal: $4375 (7 )
Fire Island Pines Getaway
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island rental home is located a 2-minute walk from the beach and a 5-minute walk from the Pines ferry dock, bars, restaurants, and a market. This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom house accommodates up to 7 guests and features a private deck, a Jacuzzi hot tub, an outdoor shower, and a 55” 4K smart TV with high-speed FIOS internet.
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$243/nighttotal: $1458 (6 )
Amildean Family Oasis: 10 Minutes From Connequot Park, The Golf Course And The Beach!
2 2
apartment , Central Islip
This Central Islip dwelling offers a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental ideal for up to 2 guests, featuring a family-friendly atmosphere with a relaxing backyard and proximity to Connetquot River State Park and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, all within easy driving distance of Long Island beaches. This accommodation includes a modern convection oven, a fully equipped kitchen, and blackout curtains in the bedrooms for a comfortable stay, with internet and air conditioning provided.