Cottages in Fire Island, NY

25 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fire Island, NY cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

25 Best cottages in Fire Island, NY

Our Favorite Family-Friendly Cottages in Fire Island, NY

Finding the perfect cottage makes all the difference for a comfortable and memorable family trip to Fire Island, NY.

Historic 1932 Cherry Grove Beach House - Gardens, Sun And Steps To The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Historic 1932 Cherry Grove Beach House - Gardens, Sun And Steps To The Beach.

cottage, Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom cottage is located in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, near the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and 89 North Music Venue.
This family-friendly beach house offers air conditioning, a newly renovated kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, and two large decks with a gas BBQ, plus an outdoor shower and parking.
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore

cottage, West Bay Shore
This family-friendly cottage in West Bay Shore is located within 1 mile of Great South Bay and Gilgo State Park, and within 2 miles of the YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts and Bay Shore Manor Park.
This rental property offers a microwave oven, dishwasher, air conditioning, a garden, parking, an arcade/game room, free WiFi in public areas, and barbecue grills, with a fireplace for a cozy ambiance.

Best Fire Island, NY cottages with a garden

The Salted Bungalow: A Boutique Fire Island Beach Retreat. - Fire Island, NY
8.0 1 review

The Salted Bungalow: A Boutique Fire Island Beach Retreat.

cottage, Fire Island
This non-smoking cottage is located in Ocean Beach, a 5-minute drive from Ocean Beach and within walking distance of Great South Bay.
This accommodation offers 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and sleeps 11 guests, with amenities including a BBQ, air conditioning, workspace, full kitchen, and in-unit washer and dryer, plus a private deck for outdoor relaxation.
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore

cottage, West Bay Shore
This family-friendly cottage in West Bay Shore is located within 1 mile of Great South Bay and Gilgo State Park, and within 2 miles of the YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts and Bay Shore Manor Park.
This rental property offers a microwave oven, dishwasher, air conditioning, a garden, parking, an arcade/game room, free WiFi in public areas, and barbecue grills, with a fireplace for a cozy ambiance.
Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 10 reviews

Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated!

cottage, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach cottage, located nine houses from the beach and a five-minute walk from shops and restaurants, offers easy access to the coastline and local amenities.
The 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom house sleeps six, features a loft bedroom, a spacious deck with a Weber grill, griddle, and air fryer, plus four bikes, a washer/dryer, and an outdoor shower; recent renovations (2022 & 2024) ensure updated appliances and supplies.
Historic 1932 Cherry Grove Beach House - Gardens, Sun And Steps To The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Historic 1932 Cherry Grove Beach House - Gardens, Sun And Steps To The Beach.

cottage, Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom cottage is located in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, near the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and 89 North Music Venue.
This family-friendly beach house offers air conditioning, a newly renovated kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, and two large decks with a gas BBQ, plus an outdoor shower and parking.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Fire Island, NY

Popular destinations

Top-Rated Cottages with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY

A private hot tub at your cottage makes every trip to Fire Island, NY truly unforgettable after a day by the water.

Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 10 reviews

Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated!

cottage, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach cottage, located nine houses from the beach and a five-minute walk from shops and restaurants, offers easy access to the coastline and local amenities.
The 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom house sleeps six, features a loft bedroom, a spacious deck with a Weber grill, griddle, and air fryer, plus four bikes, a washer/dryer, and an outdoor shower; recent renovations (2022 & 2024) ensure updated appliances and supplies.

Explore Dog-Friendly Cottages in Fire Island, NY

Each Fire Island, NY cottage on this list provides dog-friendly amenities and easy access to the water.

Idyllic Cozy Cottage In Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available! - Fire Island, NY
8.8 3 reviews

Idyllic Cozy Cottage In Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available!

cottage, Fire Island
This Davis Park, Fire Island rental is located on Spindrift Walk, a short walk from both the Atlantic Ocean and Great South Bay beaches, and conveniently close to the Watch Hill National Seashore and The Casino.
This 800-square-foot house features three bedrooms, one bathroom, and sleeps seven guests comfortably, boasting a wraparound deck, a fully equipped kitchen with granite countertops, and modern amenities including Wi-Fi, a washer/dryer, and an outdoor gas grill.
Island Retreat In Lonelyville - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Island Retreat In Lonelyville

cottage, Fire Island
This Fire Island cottage in Bay Shore is located 0.3 miles from the Dunewood ferry dock and 0.6 miles from Fair Harbor, offering immediate bay and ocean beach access.
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom rental accommodates up to 9 guests and features a separate guest house bedroom, an outdoor shower, ramp entry, and a well-equipped kitchen, with proximity to Robert Moses State Park and Captree State Park.
Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac

cottage, Mastic Beach
This Mastic Beach bungalow is located near the William Floyd Estate and the TWA Flight 800 International Memorial, offering 620 square feet of living space.
This one-bedroom retreat accommodates up to three guests and includes internet, air conditioning, and is pet-friendly, with nearby attractions like Bellport Country Club and Waterdrinker Family Farm & Garden.
Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 10 reviews

Cottage Steps From Beach-newly Renovated!

cottage, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach cottage, located nine houses from the beach and a five-minute walk from shops and restaurants, offers easy access to the coastline and local amenities.
The 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom house sleeps six, features a loft bedroom, a spacious deck with a Weber grill, griddle, and air fryer, plus four bikes, a washer/dryer, and an outdoor shower; recent renovations (2022 & 2024) ensure updated appliances and supplies.
©2026 cozycozy.com