Search the best hotels in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!

45 available hotel offers

2 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fire Island, NY hotels
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

45 Cheap hotels in Fire Island, NY

Traveler-Approved Luxury Hotels in Fire Island, NY

Comfort and a prime location define these luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY, each hand-selected with your relaxation in mind.

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1378 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$688/nighttotal: $4128 (6 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

3 10
hotel , Ronkonkoma
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport is located near MacArthur Airport in Islip, just a short drive from Ronkonkoma and its train station, making it convenient for travelers arriving by air or those wanting to explore the town and surrounding areas. The hotel is a 3-star property that consistently receives very good user ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable guest rooms with modern amenities, including free high-speed internet, MP3 compatible radios, microwaves, and refrigerators. Guests can enjoy dining at the Great American Grill or relax in the lounge, and the hotel also features a swimming pool, fitness center, and a terrace where they can unwind.

Choose the Right Hotels with Swimming Pool in Fire Island, NY

These hotels in Fire Island, NY feature swimming pools, offering a refreshing dip to complement your stay.

Grove Hotel - Fire Island, NY
9.2 919 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$752/nighttotal: $2256 (3 )

Grove Hotel

2 6
hotel , Fire Island
The Grove Hotel is located in Cherry Grove, a lively district on Fire Island, just a short walk from the beach. It's a 3-star hotel with a "very good" user rating. Guests appreciate the convenient location and the hotel's clean and comfortable rooms.
The hotel offers a range of amenities including a seasonal outdoor pool, a bar, and free Wi-Fi. You can enjoy a refreshing dip in the pool, relax with a drink at the bar, or stay connected with friends and family.
Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$433/nighttotal: $1299 (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
The Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is located in Seaford, about 17 miles from Central Islip, making it a convenient option for those exploring the area. This 3-star hotel offers a comfortable and relaxing stay with modern amenities.
The hotel features a spacious layout with a garden, pool, and fitness center. Guests can enjoy on-site dining at the restaurant and bar, as well as relax in the sauna and spa.
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1378 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$688/nighttotal: $4128 (6 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

3 10
hotel , Ronkonkoma
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport is located near MacArthur Airport in Islip, just a short drive from Ronkonkoma and its train station, making it convenient for travelers arriving by air or those wanting to explore the town and surrounding areas. The hotel is a 3-star property that consistently receives very good user ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable guest rooms with modern amenities, including free high-speed internet, MP3 compatible radios, microwaves, and refrigerators. Guests can enjoy dining at the Great American Grill or relax in the lounge, and the hotel also features a swimming pool, fitness center, and a terrace where they can unwind.
Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
8.6 1833 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$361/nighttotal: $1083 (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
The Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is conveniently located in Central Islip, just a short drive from the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Jones Beach, and the Nikon Theater. This 3-star hotel has consistently received very good user ratings for its comfortable accommodations and friendly service.
The hotel features modern amenities like an indoor pool, a fitness center, and a restaurant. Guests can enjoy free parking and WiFi, as well as continental and American breakfast options.

Frequently Asked Questions about hotels in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the best landmarks to visit in Fire Island, NY and around?

    Fire Island is known for its beautiful beaches, but if you're looking for landmarks, you'll want to check out the Fire Island Lighthouse. It's a historic landmark that offers breathtaking views of the island and the surrounding area. You could also visit the Robert Moses State Park, which has a variety of amenities like beaches, walking trails, and a playground. If you're looking for something a bit more off the beaten path, check out the Sunken Forest, a unique ecosystem that's home to a variety of plant and animal life.
  • What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • Which area in Fire Island, NY is a good option for staying in a hotel?

    The best area for hotels depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be close to the action, Ocean Beach is a good choice. It's known for its nightlife and restaurants. If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, try staying in Cherry Grove. It's a bit quieter and has a more laid-back vibe.
  • What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Among 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg, Hampton Inn Long Island/commack and Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville are the most popular ones.

  • What are the most affordable attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    The best thing about Fire Island is its natural beauty, and that's free! You can spend your days swimming, sunbathing, and exploring the beaches and dunes. If you want to do something a little more active, you can rent a bike and explore the island's bike paths. There are also a number of free concerts and events held throughout the summer.
  • What are the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Hyatt Regency Long Island is among the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY.

  • How can travelers relax during a week in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is all about relaxing and enjoying the simple things in life. Spend your days swimming, sunbathing, reading a book, and enjoying the fresh air. In the evenings, you can enjoy a delicious meal at one of the many restaurants or bars on the island. And if you're feeling adventurous, you can take a ferry to the mainland for a day trip to explore the surrounding area.
  • What are the best family friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • Where can you find the best traditional local cuisine in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its fresh seafood, so you'll want to try some of the local favorites. The Clam Bar in Ocean Beach is a popular spot for seafood and cocktails. You could also try the Fire Island Restaurant in Ocean Beach, which has a more upscale menu. And if you're looking for something casual, try the Lobster Roll at the Fire Island Pines.
  • What are the best pet friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • What hotel chains can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    There are no major hotel chains on Fire Island. Most of the accommodations are small, independently owned hotels, motels, and guesthouses.
  • What are the best hotels with jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What type of hotels can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    You can find a variety of hotels on Fire Island, from budget-friendly motels to more upscale guesthouses. There are also a few bed and breakfasts and vacation rentals available.
  • When is the best time to book a hotel in Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to book a hotel in Fire Island is during the off-season, which is typically from September to May. You'll find the best deals and fewer crowds during this time. If you're planning on visiting during the summer, book your hotel well in advance, as rooms tend to fill up quickly.
  • What amenities do hotel rooms typically offer in Fire Island, NY?

    Hotel rooms in Fire Island typically offer basic amenities, such as air conditioning, heating, and a private bathroom. Some hotels may also offer amenities like a swimming pool, a restaurant, or a bar. It's always a good idea to check the hotel's website or call ahead to confirm what amenities are available.
  • What pet-friendly activities are available in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a very dog-friendly destination. You can bring your furry friend to the beach, go for a walk on the many trails, and even enjoy a meal at some of the restaurants. There are also a few pet-friendly accommodations available on the island.

Destinations nearby

Search Coastal Hotels near Fire Island, NY

Soak up the coastal lifestyle at these seaside hotels in Fire Island, NY, offering comfortable accommodations just moments from the beach and shore.

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$354/nighttotal: $1062 (3 )

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
The Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex in Central Islip offers a 3-star stay with proximity to Bethpage Ballpark, SUSA Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex, and Cohalan Court Complex.
This extended-stay hotel provides guests with a swimming pool, garden, fitness center, and barbeque area, along with convenient Wi-Fi and laundry services.

Search Hotels with Parking in Fire Island, NY

Driving to Fire Island, NY? Each hotel here includes parking, making it easy to reach the coast the moment you arrive.

Seashore Condo Hotel Two Bedroom Suite, Spacious Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$1418/nighttotal: $2836 (2 )

Seashore Condo Hotel Two Bedroom Suite, Spacious Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

2 3
hotel , Fire Island
The Seashore Condo Hotel offers a Spacious Fire Island Escape with bay views and is located steps from the beach in Ocean Beach, Fire Island, placing you near the Bay Shore Mini Golf and Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal, with easy access to Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park. This two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo hotel features 600 square feet of living space, accommodating up to six guests with air conditioning, complimentary Wi-Fi, a full kitchen, and on-site barbecue facilities.
The Palms Hotel Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$821/nighttotal: $3284 (4 )

The Palms Hotel Fire Island

1 2
hotel , Ocean Beach
Book a hotel room in a 3-star hotel. This accommodation is located in Ocean Beach.
Facilities and services include a concierge, a wheelchair friendly access and a kitchen. Take advantage of the garden in this hotel in Ocean Beach.
Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$619/nighttotal: $1857 (3 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 1
hotel , Fire Island
The Seashore Condo Hotel #19, a cozy Fire Island escape offering bay views and beach proximity, is located in Ocean Beach, within walking distance of Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and Bay Shore Historical Society, and a short distance to Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This 170 square feet, 1-bedroom condo accommodates up to 2 guests and features air conditioning, complimentary wireless internet, a private patio, and on-site barbecue facilities, with Smart TVs and coffee/tea makers, refrigerators, and microwaves in the rooms.
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1378 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$688/nighttotal: $4128 (6 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

3 10
hotel , Ronkonkoma
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport is located near MacArthur Airport in Islip, just a short drive from Ronkonkoma and its train station, making it convenient for travelers arriving by air or those wanting to explore the town and surrounding areas. The hotel is a 3-star property that consistently receives very good user ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable guest rooms with modern amenities, including free high-speed internet, MP3 compatible radios, microwaves, and refrigerators. Guests can enjoy dining at the Great American Grill or relax in the lounge, and the hotel also features a swimming pool, fitness center, and a terrace where they can unwind.

Our Favorite Pet-Friendly Hotels in Fire Island, NY

A quality pet-friendly stay in Fire Island, NY means dog-friendly beaches and outdoor washing facilities with no compromise on your comfort.

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$433/nighttotal: $1299 (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip

Check Out Hotels with Breakfast Included in Fire Island, NY

No need to hunt for a cafe in the morning, as breakfast is included with these hotels in Fire Island, NY.

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$354/nighttotal: $1062 (3 )

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
8.6 1833 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$361/nighttotal: $1083 (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
The Palms Hotel Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$821/nighttotal: $3284 (4 )

The Palms Hotel Fire Island

1 2
hotel , Ocean Beach
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1378 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$688/nighttotal: $4128 (6 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

3 10
hotel , Ronkonkoma

Best Fire Island, NY hotels with air conditioning

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
8.9 1262 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$383/nighttotal: $1149 (3 )

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
Grove Hotel - Fire Island, NY
9.2 919 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$752/nighttotal: $2256 (3 )

Grove Hotel

2 6
hotel , Fire Island
Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$433/nighttotal: $1299 (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
Clegg's Hotel - Fire Island, NY
8.1 242 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1028/nighttotal: $3084 (3 )

Clegg's Hotel

2 6
hotel , Ocean Beach

Best Fire Island, NY hotels with a balcony

Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$619/nighttotal: $1857 (3 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 1
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel Two Bedroom Suite, Spacious Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$1418/nighttotal: $2836 (2 )

Seashore Condo Hotel Two Bedroom Suite, Spacious Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

2 3
hotel , Fire Island
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1378 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$688/nighttotal: $4128 (6 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

3 10
hotel , Ronkonkoma
Clegg's Hotel - Fire Island, NY
8.1 242 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1028/nighttotal: $3084 (3 )

Clegg's Hotel

2 6
hotel , Ocean Beach
©2026 cozycozy.com