Places to stay in Fire Island, NY

824 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Fire Island, NY place to stay
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

824 Best places to stay in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a balcony

Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc - Fire Island, NY
9.6 28 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£447/nighttotal: £894 (2 )

Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc

3 3
apartment , Islip
This Islip holiday home is situated within 3.2km of Cohalan Court Complex, the Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Bethpage Ballpark, and within 4.8km of Bay Shore Mini Golf and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This 151 square metre property offers four bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six guests, and boasts a swimming pool, terrace, garden, free Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen; nearby attractions include a water park and family-friendly activities.
Luxury Waterfront Retreat  Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville - Fire Island, NY
10 92 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£644/nighttotal: £3220 (5 )

Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville

4 2
apartment , Bayport
This Bayport holiday home is situated just 700 metres from a sandy beach and within a 3-kilometre drive of two Fire Island Ferry terminals. It enjoys an excellent user rating and is a great base for exploring the area.
The property offers 195 square metres of space, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests in its three bedrooms and two bathrooms. It boasts a range of amenities including a swimming pool, Jacuzzi, sauna, and a fully equipped kitchen, as well as a private garden and terrace, making it ideal for relaxing and enjoying the outdoors.
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion With Hot Tub - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 06/07
£2300/nighttotal: £6900 (3 )

Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion With Hot Tub

7 2
house , West Bay Shore
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion is a detached house situated in West Bay Shore, offering proximity to Benjamin's Memorial Beach, 2.9 kilometres away, and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, 29 kilometres distant.
This expansive 743-square-metre property accommodates up to 55 guests across 7 bedrooms, featuring a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, spa, fitness centre, garden, and parking, with WiFi included.
Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 69 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£324/nighttotal: £1620 (5 )

Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay

3 2
house , Mastic Beach
This waterfront property is located in Mastic Beach, just 38km from the Long Island Railroad and 32km from Splish Splash waterpark, offering a peaceful escape from the bustling city life. The property boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
This spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home can accommodate up to 6 guests and spans 167 square metres. The house offers direct waterfront access with a large deck and dock, perfect for enjoying the bay, along with a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, a garden, parking, and a peaceful atmosphere.

Best family friendly Fire Island, NY lodging

Among the 824 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best for families

Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str - Fire Island, NY
9.7 381 reviews
Fire Island, NY
01/08 – 03/08
£356/nighttotal: £712 (2 )

Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str

3 3
apartment , North Bay Shore
This apartment is conveniently located in North Bay Shore, just a short distance from Brentwood State Park and within easy reach of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a comfortable living space with a dining area and a TV for entertainment. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and a fireplace, as well as a fully equipped kitchenette, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Fire Island 4br; Bay Views; Big Deck (No Cars!) - Fire Island, NY
9.7 69 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£855/nighttotal: £4275 (5 )

Fire Island 4br; Bay Views; Big Deck (No Cars!)

4 2
apartment , Fire Island
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home on Fire Island is located less than 1.6km from Ocean Beach's shops, restaurants, and lifeguarded beaches.
The property, boasting a private deck and ocean views from three bedrooms, comfortably accommodates eight guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and modern amenities such as a Smart TV.
Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway! - Fire Island, NY
8.4 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
18/07 – 20/07
£219/nighttotal: £438 (2 )

Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway!

1 2
apartment , Bohemia
This Bohemia apartment, in Suffolk County, Long Island, is situated 0.8km from Connetquot River State Park, 4.8km from the Bohemia Historical Society Museum, and 4km from Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, with Oakdale railway station a 20-minute walk away.
The self-catering flat offers one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeping two guests, and includes a microwave, stovetop, washing machine, Smart TV, air conditioning, and private garden parking; nearby activities include nature walks, historical exploration, and easy access to public transport.
Relaxing Patchogue Retreat Near The Bay - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 04/07
£1553/nightfor 1 night

Relaxing Patchogue Retreat Near The Bay

1 3
apartment , Patchogue
This family-friendly apartment in Patchogue offers a comfortable and secure base for exploration, located in a district with convenient access to the surrounding area.
This four-bedroom dwelling accommodates up to eight guests and features a kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, alongside air conditioning, garden access, and parking.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the top attractions and must-see sites in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its beautiful beaches, so spending a day at Ocean Beach or the famous Fire Island Lighthouse is a must. You should also check out the historic Fire Island Pines, a popular gay resort area.
  • What are the best places to stay in Fire Island, NY?

    Among the places to stay in Fire Island, NY, Comfortable Private Room, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the most popular ones.

  • Which cultural festivals and seasonal events should visitors attend in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse hosts a Summer Solstice celebration every year, and the Fire Island Pines has a Pride Weekend in June that's a big deal.
  • What are the best places to stay with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

    My Happy Place, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg and Hampton Inn Long Island/commack are the best places to stay with a pool in Fire Island, NY.

  • What are the most convenient modes of transportation within Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Ferry is the most convenient way to get around, and once you're on the island, you can rent a bike or walk. There are also golf carts available for hire.
  • What are the best places to stay with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What outdoor activities and adventures are popular in and around Fire Island, NY?

    Of course, swimming and sunbathing are big on Fire Island. Kayaking and paddleboarding are also popular. If you're feeling adventurous, you can even try surfing at Ocean Beach.
  • What are the best places to stay for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

    The best places to stay for families and kids in Fire Island, NY are Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville, Hampton Inn Long Island-brookhaven and Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport.

  • What types of accommodations are available in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island has a range of accommodation options, from luxury beach houses to more budget-friendly motels and campsites.
  • What are the best pet friendly places to stay in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to visit Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to visit Fire Island is in the summer, from June to August, when the weather is warm and sunny. It can get crowded though, so if you prefer a quieter experience, you might consider visiting in the shoulder season, in May or September.
  • What are the best places to stay with parking in Fire Island, NY?

    Comfortable Private Room, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the best places to stay with parking in Fire Island, NY.

  • What local dishes and culinary experiences are a must-try in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its fresh seafood and casual beachside restaurants. Try the clams or lobster rolls at The Lobster Roll in Ocean Beach, or grab some pizza from The Pizza Place in Cherry Grove.

Destinations nearby

Find the Best Seaside Lodgings in Fire Island, NY

Base your next maritime holiday at coastal lodging in Fire Island, NY, located short distances from local shorelines.

Studio In Architectual Prominent 1960's Beachhouse - Fire Island, NY
8.8 15 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
£577/nighttotal: £1731 (3 )

Studio In Architectual Prominent 1960's Beachhouse

1 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines apartment is just a minute's walk from the ocean beach, offering a tranquil escape in a renowned modernist architectural setting. The property has received excellent ratings for cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The apartment is a completely rebuilt 1961 Andrew Geller masterpiece, comprising a main house and a separate artist studio. Guests can enjoy a heated pool, a roof deck, central air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and a range of personalized services including a chef, yoga teacher, and massage therapist.

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a kitchen

Gatsbys Main Level. Ocean Bay Park.  Heated Saltwater Pool + Hot Tub. Sleeps 14 - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£1935/nighttotal: £3870 (2 )

Gatsbys Main Level. Ocean Bay Park. Heated Saltwater Pool + Hot Tub. Sleeps 14

3 3
apartment , Fire Island
This Ocean Bay Park flat offers direct access to the beach via a ramped walkway, situated just 200-300 metres from the ferry terminal, with the Village of Ocean Beach a 10-minute cycle or 20-minute walk away.
This property accommodates up to 12 guests and features a private heated saltwater plunge pool and hot tub on its main-level deck, alongside essential beach gear and high-speed Wi-Fi.
Bayfront Home In Patchogue W/ Deck & Fishing Dock - Fire Island, NY
10 10 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
£594/nighttotal: £1782 (3 )

Bayfront Home In Patchogue W/ Deck & Fishing Dock

3 2
apartment , East Patchogue
This East Patchogue holiday home, situated on Patchogue Bay, is 1.6km from the Davis Park Ferry to Fire Island and within a few kilometres of Shorefront Park, the Patchogue Theatre, and Corey Beach.
This spacious single-storey property offers 167 square metres of living space, sleeping up to six guests in three bedrooms, and boasts a private dock, tennis court, and numerous amenities including a ping-pong table, gas fireplaces, and an outdoor shower.
In Ob, Sleeps 16+ With Enormous Deck Space And Hot Tub - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£1958/nighttotal: £3916 (2 )

In Ob, Sleeps 16+ With Enormous Deck Space And Hot Tub

5 3
apartment , Fire Island
This large holiday home in Ocean Beach, Fire Island, is situated just 100 metres from the beach and a short walk from Ocean Beach's shops, restaurants, and bars, offering a genuine Fire Island experience on car-free streets and boardwalks, with proximity to cultural attractions such as the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
Accommodating up to 20 guests, this property boasts five bedrooms, three bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen ideal for group meals, a massive deck for outdoor entertaining, and a private hot tub, ensuring a comfortable stay with amenities including air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and parking.
Close To Harbor W/ Heated Pool, Ac, Workstations - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£1043/nighttotal: £4172 (4 )

Close To Harbor W/ Heated Pool, Ac, Workstations

1 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island holiday home, a five-minute walk (0.8 km) from the Fire Island ferry terminal, offers convenient access to the island's attractions.
Sleeping eight guests, the property boasts three bedrooms—one with three twin beds and a private bathroom, another with a queen bed, and a third with two twin beds sharing a full bathroom—along with a kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a heated swimming pool, and pet-friendly accommodation.

Best Fire Island, NY lodgings with a pool

Among the 824 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best ones with a pool

Bellport Village Temperance Hall: Bellport Loft - Fire Island, NY
10 20 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£579/nighttotal: £1158 (2 )

Bellport Village Temperance Hall: Bellport Loft

2 3
apartment , Bellport
Fire Island Pines H. Gifford's Famous Tree House - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
£2273/nighttotal: £15911 (7 )

Fire Island Pines H. Gifford's Famous Tree House

3 2
apartment , Fire Island
[Fip] Fallout Shelter | 4 Bedrm | Pool+hot Tub+ac! - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£1300/nighttotal: £2600 (2 )

[Fip] Fallout Shelter | 4 Bedrm | Pool+hot Tub+ac!

1 3
apartment , Fire Island
Bellport Village - Charming Family Cape With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
£728/nighttotal: £5096 (7 )

Bellport Village - Charming Family Cape With Pool

4 2
apartment , Bellport

Top-Rated Places to Stay with On-site Parking in Fire Island, NY

Free on-site parking is included with these accommodations near the water in Fire Island, NY, letting you focus entirely on the coast and local beaches.

4bd 2ba Heated Pool & Ac Fire Island Pines - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£1787/nighttotal: £3574 (2 )

4bd 2ba Heated Pool & Ac Fire Island Pines

4 3
apartment , Fire Island
Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach! - Fire Island, NY
8.5 4 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
£663/nighttotal: £1989 (3 )

Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach!

3 2
house , Shirley
1 Bedroom 1 Bath Private Entrance - Fire Island, NY
8.8 22 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£165/nighttotal: £330 (2 )

1 Bedroom 1 Bath Private Entrance

1 3
apartment , Deer Park

Handpicked Places to Stay with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY

Every accommodation near the water in Fire Island, NY comes with a hot tub or jacuzzi, perfect for a private soak after a day spent outdoors.

Gatsby's -Pool Level-sleeps 14 - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
£1725/nighttotal: £3450 (2 )

Gatsby's -Pool Level-sleeps 14

1 3
apartment , Fire Island
Waterfront Home With Recreational Dock! Great For Rafting, And Close To Beaches - Fire Island, NY
8.6 32 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£320/nighttotal: £1600 (5 )

Waterfront Home With Recreational Dock! Great For Rafting, And Close To Beaches

3 2
apartment , Mastic Beach
The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach - Fire Island, NY
10 12 reviews
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 06/07
£2070/nighttotal: £6210 (3 )

The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach

7 2
apartment , West Bay Shore
Beach Oasis - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
£952/nighttotal: £6664 (7 )

Beach Oasis

4 2
apartment , Fire Island
©2026 cozycozy.com