Search All Cottages in Fire Island, NY

This West Islip bed and breakfast offers private accommodation with garden access, situated 19 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport and 27 kilometres from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom guest house accommodates two people and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, complimentary Wi-Fi, and private parking.

Come As You Are Inn LLC is a recently renovated, adults-only guesthouse located in Sayville, 6.9 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport, with Splish Splash 43.5 kilometres away and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum 49.9 kilometres distant.
This establishment offers guest rooms with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and mini-bars, alongside a saltwater pool, hot tub, and garden, accommodating up to two guests with a floor area of 14 square metres.

This newly appointed modernist home is located directly on the bay, just three blocks east of Fire Island’s town centre and a five-minute walk from shops and nightlife. The apartment has been highly rated by previous guests for its cleanliness, location and overall experience.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom property sleeps up to six guests, offering plenty of space and privacy for all. It comes with a range of amenities including a private hot tub, outdoor showers, a spacious cedar deck, and access to kayaks, fishing poles and other water sports equipment.

This two-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday cottage offers prime access to Fire Island's amenities, situated just 100 metres from the ferry terminal, market, eateries, and nightlife, and a mere stone's throw from the beach.
This centrally located holiday home sleeps up to four guests and features a newly installed saltwater swimming pool, expansive wraparound sun decks, an outdoor shower, and a thoughtfully redesigned open-concept interior with high-end finishes and preserved original woodwork.