Villas and Holiday homes in Fire Island, NY

241 available villa offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Fire Island, NY holiday homes
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

241 Villa rentals in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY villas and holiday homes with air conditioning

Prime Locale: Ideal Guesthouse - Fire Island, NY
9.4 82 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£140/nighttotal: Â£700 (5 )

Prime Locale: Ideal Guesthouse

1 2
house , Bay Shore
This charming guest house is located in a peaceful neighbourhood in Bay Shore, just a short walk from the beach and the town centre. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall guest experience.
The one-bedroom property is ideal for couples or solo travellers seeking a cosy retreat. The house comes equipped with all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay, including air conditioning, a kitchen, and a swimming pool. You can also enjoy free parking and access to the internet.
Over The Moon - Fire Island, NY
9.9 40 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
£179/nighttotal: Â£537 (3 )

Over The Moon

1 2
house , Islip
This Islip studio apartment offers convenient street parking and is ideally located, though its precise address within Islip is not provided.
The self-contained unit sleeps two guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, high-speed Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a private entrance.
Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach! - Fire Island, NY
8.5 4 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
£663/nighttotal: Â£1989 (3 )

Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach!

3 2
house , Shirley
This Shirley waterfront property, a short 5-minute drive from the beach and 27 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport, offers stunning sunset views.
The 116 square metre house boasts three bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps nine guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, private parking, and complimentary Wi-Fi.
Pristine Queen Ensuite Walk Out To Deck &  Pool - Shared Kitchen Lr Dr Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
£1354/nighttotal: Â£4062 (3 )

Pristine Queen Ensuite Walk Out To Deck & Pool - Shared Kitchen Lr Dr Pool

1 2
house , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines villa, located in Sayville, offers convenient access to the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, approximately 3.8 kilometres away, and is also within 4.7 kilometres of Bowlero Sayville.
This one-bedroom property provides essential amenities including WiFi, heating, air conditioning, and a washing machine, with a queen bed ensuring a comfortable stay for guests exploring the local recreational activities.

Find the Best Holiday Homes with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY

Returning to a private hot tub after a day outdoors adds a touch of luxury to these holiday homes in Fire Island, NY.

Classic Pines Bungalow With Every Amenity - Fire Island, NY
10 17 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
£1502/nighttotal: Â£4506 (3 )

Classic Pines Bungalow With Every Amenity

3 2
bungalow , Fire Island
This Pines bungalow in Fire Island offers a prime location, just a 0.16 km stroll from the ferry terminal, shops, restaurants, and the beach.
Sleeping up to six guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom house boasts a heated pool, hot tub, Sonos sound system, and a rooftop sun deck; the third bedroom is even equipped for remote working.
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion With Hot Tub - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
£2312/nighttotal: Â£6936 (3 )

Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion With Hot Tub

1 2
house , West Bay Shore
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion is a detached house situated in West Bay Shore, offering proximity to Benjamin's Memorial Beach, 2.9 kilometres away, and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, 29 kilometres distant.
This expansive 743-square-metre property accommodates up to 55 guests across 7 bedrooms, featuring a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, spa, fitness centre, garden, and parking, with WiFi included.
2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen - Fire Island, NY
10 28 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
£944/nighttotal: Â£2832 (3 )

2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen

1 2
house , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines suite, a three-minute walk from both the harbour and beach, offers a luxurious escape in a prime location.
The property comprises two bedrooms sleeping four guests, boasting a private poolside suite with living room, kitchen, and shared access to a heated pool, hot tub, roof deck, and small gym; modern amenities include air conditioning, a dishwasher, and a Jacuzzi.

Frequently asked questions about villa rentals in Fire Island, NY

Destinations nearby

Best Fire Island, NY villas and holiday homes with a kitchen

Guest House Retreat 
With Amazing Pool !!! - Fire Island, NY
10 38 reviews
Fire Island, NY
01/08 – 03/08
£451/nighttotal: Â£902 (2 )

Guest House Retreat With Amazing Pool !!!

1 3
house , North Bellport
This charming cottage is located in Bellport Village, a picturesque seaside town on Long Island's South Shore, just 145 kilometres from New York City. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The cottage has one bedroom and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. Enjoy the amenities including air conditioning, a swimming pool, a garden, and a kitchen with a fridge, perfect for a relaxing seaside getaway.
A-frame Cabin With Private Beach & Epic Sunsets - Fire Island, NY
9.7 200 reviews
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£512/nighttotal: Â£2048 (4 )

A-frame Cabin With Private Beach & Epic Sunsets

1 2
cabin , Shirley
This A-frame lodge is located in Shirley, a 1.5-hour drive from New York City, with direct access to a private beach on the Great South Bay. The cabin has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The lodge has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. The property offers a range of modern amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a dedicated workspace, and access to a private beach with opportunities for swimming, kayaking, and fishing.
Beautiful 3 Br Near Town & Beach W King Bed - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
19/07 – 20/07
£541/nightfor 1 night

Beautiful 3 Br Near Town & Beach W King Bed

2 2
house , North Patchogue
This family-friendly house in North Patchogue is situated 5.96 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport, offering convenient access to Patchogue town and its beach.
This property boasts 111 square metres of living space, accommodating up to 11 guests with two bedrooms, one bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, air conditioning, and barbecue facilities, making it ideal for exploring the local area.
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.4 23 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£1460/nighttotal: Â£7300 (5 )

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

5 2
house , Fire Island
The Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat is situated in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, just a 6.4 kilometre walk from Ocean Beach and 32 kilometres from Jones Beach.
This spacious five-bedroom house, measuring 445 square metres, offers a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden and a swimming pool, making it ideal for families or groups seeking a relaxing retreat.

Compare Holiday Houses with a Swimming Pool in Fire Island, NY

Take a dip whenever you fancy; these holiday homes near the water in Fire Island, NY feature excellent on-site swimming pools for your enjoyment.

Stylish Private Mid Century Modern 3 Bedroom House - Fire Island, NY
10 23 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
£1409/nighttotal: Â£9863 (7 )

Stylish Private Mid Century Modern 3 Bedroom House

3 2
house , Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house is located on Fire Island, a short walk from the beach and close to the town centre; the precise distance isn't specified.
The property, boasting a private pool, pool house, and extensive deck, comfortably sleeps six guests and features mid-century modern décor, air conditioning, and a fully equipped kitchen including a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher.

Discover Holiday Homes by the Sea in Fire Island, NY

Walk along beautiful coastal trails from comfortable shoreside holiday homes in Fire Island, NY near the shore.

10 Cayuga - Fire Island, NY
9.0 59 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£1212/nighttotal: Â£6060 (5 )

10 Cayuga

4 2
house , Fire Island

Popular 5-Star Holiday Houses in Fire Island, NY

Enjoying a luxury holiday home in Fire Island, NY means every detail is handled, offering sophisticated interiors and a prime setting for your break.

The Pelican's Nest - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£912/nighttotal: Â£3648 (4 )

The Pelican's Nest

1 2
house , Fire Island

Our Favourite Family-Friendly Holiday Houses in Fire Island, NY

Choosing the right holiday home makes all the difference for a family trip to Fire Island, NY, offering ample room.

The Sunshine House - Fire Island, NY
10 141 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
£216/nighttotal: Â£1080 (5 )

The Sunshine House

1 2
house , Islip Terrace

Explore Dog-Friendly Holiday Houses in Fire Island, NY

Your dog-friendly holiday home in Fire Island, NY ensures stress-free beach days with dedicated pet-washing areas.

Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£210/nighttotal: Â£840 (4 )

Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac

1 2
cottage , Mastic Beach
Nice Family House - Fire Island, NY
9.3 45 reviews
Fire Island, NY
01/08 – 03/08
£182/nighttotal: Â£364 (2 )

Nice Family House

1 3
house , Bay Shore
Chalet-famille-espace Sanitaire-vue Sur Le Bois-do - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
19/07 – 20/07
£229/nightfor 1 night

Chalet-famille-espace Sanitaire-vue Sur Le Bois-do

1 2
chalet , Fire Island

Guest-Favourite Holiday Homes with Parking in Fire Island, NY

Parking is effortless, as these holiday homes in Fire Island, NY include free on-site spaces to make your arrival stress-free.

Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 69 reviews
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£465/nighttotal: Â£1860 (4 )

Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay

3 2
house , Mastic Beach
Bayfront Home In Patchogue With Deck And Fishing Dock - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
18/07 – 20/07
£689/nighttotal: Â£1378 (2 )

Bayfront Home In Patchogue With Deck And Fishing Dock

3 2
house , East Patchogue
Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
£132/nighttotal: Â£528 (4 )

Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital

1 2
house , Islip
©2026 cozycozy.com