Hotels in Fire Island, NY

45 available hotel offers

2 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Fire Island, NY hotels
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

45 Cheap hotels in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY luxury hotels (4 and 5 stars)

Among the 45 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 1 best luxury hotels

Grove Hotel - Fire Island, NY
9.2 919 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
674 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2022 â‚¬ (3 )

Grove Hotel

2 8
hotel , Fire Island
The Grove Hotel is situated in Cherry Grove, a lively district on Fire Island, just a short walk from the Fire Island Lighthouse. This 3-star hotel enjoys very good user ratings for its cleanliness and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and flat-screen TVs. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a seasonal outdoor pool, a bar, and free Wi-Fi.

Best Fire Island, NY hotels with a pool

Among the 45 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best hotels with a pool

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 06/07
306 â‚¬/nighttotal: 918 â‚¬ (3 )

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

1 2
hotel , Central Islip
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is situated in Seaford, 27 kilometres from the city centre, offering convenient access to Bethpage Ballpark, SUSA Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex, and Cohalan Court Complex.
This 3-star hotel provides guests with a swimming pool, garden, on-site Wi-Fi, a fitness centre, and barbecue facilities, with check-out at 12:00.
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
8.3 1377 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
199 â‚¬/nighttotal: 1393 â‚¬ (7 )

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport

1 2
hotel , Ronkonkoma
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport is located near MacArthur Airport in Islip, just a short drive from Ronkonkoma train station and within easy reach of shopping centres, vineyards, and restaurants. This 3-star hotel has received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The hotel offers contemporary rooms with modern furnishings, creating a comfortable and stylish stay. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, fitness centre, restaurant, bar, and room service.
Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
8.9 1260 reviews
Fire Island, NY
26/06 – 28/06
1423 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2846 â‚¬ (2 )

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

5 6
hotel , Central Islip
The Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex is conveniently located just off Heckscher State Parkway, a short walk from Bethpage Ballpark and a 5-minute drive from Central Islip Recreation Village Park. This 3-star hotel enjoys very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The property offers a range of modern amenities and features, including a full kitchen in each room, an indoor pool, fitness centre, and a nightly cocktail hour. Guests can also enjoy the convenience of a market, barbecue facilities, and free Wi-Fi throughout the hotel.
Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex - Fire Island, NY
8.6 1833 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
1046 â‚¬/nighttotal: 3138 â‚¬ (3 )

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex

3 6
hotel , Central Islip
The Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/courthouse Complex is conveniently located in Central Islip, just 25 miles from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and 27 miles from Jones Beach and the Nikon Theater. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable and modern rooms with a single bedroom and bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, garden, sauna, spa, restaurant, bar, fitness centre, and free parking.

Frequently asked questions about hotels in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the best landmarks to visit in Fire Island, NY and around?

    Fire Island is a long, narrow barrier island with many beautiful beaches and nature preserves. The Fire Island Lighthouse is a popular landmark, offering stunning views of the island and the surrounding area. The Robert Moses State Park is also a great spot to visit, with its vast beaches, picnic areas, and fishing spots.
  • What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • Which area in Fire Island, NY is a good option for staying in a hotel?

    The most popular area to stay is Ocean Beach, which has a wide selection of hotels, restaurants, and shops. It's also a good spot to enjoy the nightlife. If you're looking for a more laid-back atmosphere, you might prefer to stay in Ocean Bay Park or Seaview.
  • What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Among 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg, Hampton Inn Long Island/commack and Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville are the most popular ones.

  • What are the most affordable attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a beautiful place, but it's not known for its cheap attractions. One of the most affordable activities is simply enjoying the beaches, which are free and accessible to everyone. You can also enjoy a walk along the Fire Island Lighthouse Trail or visit the Fire Island National Seashore.
  • What are the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Hyatt Regency Long Island is among the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY.

  • How can travelers relax during a week in Fire Island, NY?

    There are many ways to relax on Fire Island. You can spend your days swimming, sunbathing, and reading on the beach. You can also rent a bike and explore the island's many trails. In the evenings, you can enjoy the peaceful sounds of the ocean or catch a live music performance at one of the local bars.
  • What are the best family friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • Where can you find the best traditional local cuisine in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island doesn't have a specific local cuisine. However, many restaurants offer fresh seafood dishes, which are popular with visitors. You can also find classic American dishes, such as burgers and fries, as well as Italian and Mexican food.
  • What are the best pet friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • What hotel chains can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    There are no major hotel chains on Fire Island. The island is mostly made up of small, independent hotels and guesthouses. You can also find some vacation rentals, but these can be expensive.
  • What are the best hotels with jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What type of hotels can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    You'll find a variety of hotels on Fire Island, ranging from simple guesthouses to more luxurious options. Some hotels have swimming pools, while others offer amenities such as free Wi-Fi and complimentary breakfast.
  • When is the best time to book a hotel in Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to book a hotel in Fire Island is during the off-season, which runs from September to May. You'll find the best deals and fewer crowds during this time. If you're planning to visit during the summer, it's best to book your hotel in advance, as rooms can fill up quickly.
  • What amenities do hotel rooms typically offer in Fire Island, NY?

    Hotel rooms in Fire Island typically offer basic amenities, such as air conditioning, heating, and a private bathroom. Some hotels also offer amenities such as cable TV, Wi-Fi, and a refrigerator.
  • What pet-friendly activities are available in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a great place to bring your furry friend. You can enjoy walks on the beach, explore the many trails, and even take your dog to a local dog park. Some restaurants also allow dogs on their patios.

Destinations nearby

Best Fire Island, NY hotels with air conditioning

Seashore Condo Hotel #15, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
9.0 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
500 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2500 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #15, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #15, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views and steps from the beach, is located in Ocean Beach, a prime Fire Island district, with Bay Shore Mini Golf and Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal within easy reach.
This family-friendly hotel offers air-conditioned accommodation with Wi-Fi, a patio, and in-room amenities such as a refrigerator and microwave, with barbecues available for guest use and capacity for two people within its 16 square meter floor area.
Seashore Condo Hotel #24, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
500 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2500 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #24, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #24, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views, is located in Ocean Beach, just steps from the beach and within 4 kilometres of Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This 16 square meter apartment, suitable for two guests, offers air conditioning, complimentary Wi-Fi, a private patio, and is equipped with a barbecue area for guest use, providing easy access to Great South Bay and Ocean Beach.
Clegg's Hotel - Fire Island, NY
8.1 242 reviews
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 06/07
432 â‚¬/nighttotal: 1296 â‚¬ (3 )

Clegg's Hotel

1 2
hotel , Ocean Beach
Clegg's Hotel is located in Ocean Beach, just 13 kilometres from Nikon Theater and Jones Beach, offering a convenient base for exploring the area. This 3-star hotel enjoys a very good rating from previous guests, with an excellent location score.
The hotel features a range of amenities, including a terrace, garden, and tennis court. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast each morning, relax at the snack bar, or take advantage of the room service and free bikes.
Seashore Condo Hotel #16, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
500 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2500 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #16, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #16, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views and steps from the beach, is located in Ocean Beach, a short distance from Carrington House and Fire Island Lighthouse.
This 16 square meter apartment offers one bedroom and one bathroom, accommodating up to two guests with amenities including air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a private patio, and barbecue facilities, with wildlife walks and bird watching nearby.

Best Fire Island, NY hotels with a balcony

Seashore Condo Hotel #11, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
487 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2435 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #11, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #11, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views and steps from the beach, is located in Ocean Beach, a prime hamlet offering easy access to the beach and close proximity to the Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal, just 300 meters away.
This family-friendly apartment, covering 16 square meters, accommodates two guests and features one bedroom and one bathroom, with air conditioning, complimentary Wi-Fi, a terrace/balcony, garden, parking, and in-room amenities including a coffee maker, refrigerator, and microwave, plus nearby barbecues for outdoor enjoyment.
Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
502 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2008 â‚¬ (4 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #19 offers a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views and steps from the beach, situated in Ocean Beach within easy reach of Ocean Beach and its shoreline, as well as cultural sites like Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and Bay Shore Historical Society, and local attractions including Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park. This 16 square metre apartment provides accommodation for two guests, featuring air conditioning, complimentary wireless internet, a private patio, and on-site barbecue facilities, with check-out at 11:00.
Seashore Condo Hotel #24, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
500 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2500 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #24, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #24, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views, is located in Ocean Beach, just steps from the beach and within 4 kilometres of Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This 16 square meter apartment, suitable for two guests, offers air conditioning, complimentary Wi-Fi, a private patio, and is equipped with a barbecue area for guest use, providing easy access to Great South Bay and Ocean Beach.
Seashore Condo Hotel #16, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach. - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
500 â‚¬/nighttotal: 2500 â‚¬ (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel #16, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views And Steps From The Beach.

1 2
hotel , Fire Island
Seashore Condo Hotel #16, a cosy Fire Island escape near the ferry with bay views and steps from the beach, is located in Ocean Beach, a short distance from Carrington House and Fire Island Lighthouse.
This 16 square meter apartment offers one bedroom and one bathroom, accommodating up to two guests with amenities including air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a private patio, and barbecue facilities, with wildlife walks and bird watching nearby.
©2026 cozycozy.com