Places to stay in Fire Island, NY

824 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Fire Island, NY place to stay
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

824 Best places to stay in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY lodgings with a pool

Among the 824 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best ones with a pool

The Legendary Pyramid House - Fire Island, NY
9.7 86 reviews
Fire Island, NY
03/07 – 06/07
4080 €/nighttotal: 12240 € (3 )

The Legendary Pyramid House

3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This charming Fire Island apartment is located in the Pines district, just a short distance from the Fire Island National Seashore, offering stunning views of the dunes, ocean, and bay. The apartment has received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The property offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Amenities include a private heated saltwater pool, a hot tub, an outdoor kitchen, and multiple dining areas, ensuring a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Modern Fire Island House Steps From The Beach - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
4648 €/nighttotal: 13944 € (3 )

Modern Fire Island House Steps From The Beach

5 8
apartment , Fire Island
This newly constructed five-bedroom, six-bathroom residence is located one house back from the beach near the Point O' Woods border on Fire Island, offering exclusive beach access.
This spacious 334 square meter holiday home accommodates up to ten guests and boasts a private heated saltwater pool, an ocean view roof deck with a wet bar, extensive mahogany decking with outdoor dining and bar areas, a gym, and direct access to Ocean Bay Park Beach, The Pantry grocery store, and Fire Island Beach House restaurant.
Oceanfront Renovated Home In Fi Pines, Stunning Views & Spacious Outdoor Oasis - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/10 – 15/10
2030 €/nighttotal: 18270 € (9 )

Oceanfront Renovated Home In Fi Pines, Stunning Views & Spacious Outdoor Oasis

4 1
apartment , Fire Island
This Sayville holiday home, less than 2km from the Great South Bay and within 5km of the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and Sailors' Haven, offers a convenient base for exploring Fire Island.
Sleeping eight guests, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom property boasts a fully equipped kitchen, private garden with barbecue, swimming pool, Jacuzzi, and free Wi-Fi; enjoy the terrace and relax in the smoke-free environment.
2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen - Fire Island, NY
10 28 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/07 – 02/08
1167 €/nighttotal: 7002 € (6 )

2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen

1 2
house , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines suite, a three-minute walk from both the harbour and beach, offers a luxurious escape in a prime location.
The property comprises two bedrooms sleeping four guests, boasting a private poolside suite with living room, kitchen, and shared access to a heated pool, hot tub, roof deck, and small gym; modern amenities include air conditioning, a dishwasher, and a Jacuzzi.

Best family friendly Fire Island, NY lodging

Among the 824 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best for families

Breathtaking Secluded Resort Property One Block From Ocean - Fire Island, NY
9.4 19 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/10 – 15/10
1150 €/nighttotal: 10350 € (9 )

Breathtaking Secluded Resort Property One Block From Ocean

4 1
resort , Fire Island
This spacious holiday home, named "Breathtaking Secluded Resort Property One Block From Ocean," is located in Fire Island Pines, a mere 100 metres from the Atlantic Ocean beaches and a 7-minute walk to the harbour's shops, eateries, and nightlife.
The property offers a high-end, renovated layout with 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and a loft sleeping 8 guests, complemented by a solar-heated swimming pool, a 7-person hot tub, and an outdoor kitchen/bar area, all set within extensive grounds featuring multiple decks and a private compound feel.
Sandy Toes - Fire Island, NY
9.9 35 reviews
Fire Island, NY
22/06 – 25/06
892 €/nighttotal: 2676 € (3 )

Sandy Toes

3 4
apartment , Ocean Beach
Sandy Toes, a newly renovated bungalow in Ocean Beach, is situated a short 0.8 kilometre walk from the ferry dock, providing easy access to local shops and other Fire Island communities.
This three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps six guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, a large deck, outdoor shower, plus complimentary bicycles, beach chairs and a welcome wine and cheese platter.
Classic Beach Bungalow - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
22/06 – 29/06
621 €/nighttotal: 4347 € (7 )

Classic Beach Bungalow

1 3
apartment , Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach bungalow, situated in the historic district, is within walking distance of the beach and numerous shops and restaurants.
The four-bedroom, two-bathroom property sleeps eight guests and offers a recently renovated open-plan kitchen, a private deck, and individual air conditioning/heating units; enjoy nearby Ocean Beach attractions.
Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway! - Fire Island, NY
8.4 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/07 – 02/08
251 €/nighttotal: 1506 € (6 )

Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway!

1 2
apartment , Bohemia
This Bohemia apartment, in Suffolk County, Long Island, is situated 0.8km from Connetquot River State Park, 4.8km from the Bohemia Historical Society Museum, and 4km from Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, with Oakdale railway station a 20-minute walk away.
The self-catering flat offers one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeping two guests, and includes a microwave, stovetop, washing machine, Smart TV, air conditioning, and private garden parking; nearby activities include nature walks, historical exploration, and easy access to public transport.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the most convenient modes of transportation within Fire Island, NY?

    The most convenient way to get around Fire Island is by bicycle. There are also ferries that run between the mainland and the island, and taxis are available in some of the villages. You can also walk or rent a golf cart.
  • What are the best accommodations in Fire Island, NY?

    Among the accommodations in Fire Island, NY, Comfortable Private Room, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the most popular ones.

  • What outdoor activities and adventures are popular in and around Fire Island, NY?

    Swimming, sunbathing, and kayaking are popular activities on the island. You can also go fishing, birdwatching, or hiking in the Fire Island National Seashore. The island is also a great place for whale watching.
  • What are the best accommodations with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

    My Happy Place, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg and Hampton Inn Long Island/commack are the best accommodations with a pool in Fire Island, NY.

  • What types of accommodations are available in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island offers a variety of accommodation options, including hotels, motels, guesthouses, and vacation rentals. There are also campgrounds available for those who want to experience the island in a more rustic way.
  • What are the best accommodations with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to visit Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to visit Fire Island is during the summer months, from June to August, when the weather is warm and sunny. However, if you're looking for a quieter experience, you can visit during the shoulder seasons, in spring or autumn.
  • What are the best accommodations for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

    The best accommodations for families and kids in Fire Island, NY are Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville, Hampton Inn Long Island-brookhaven and Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport.

  • What local dishes and culinary experiences are a must-try in Fire Island, NY?

    The Lobster Roll is a must-try on Fire Island. Many restaurants serve fresh seafood, including clams, oysters, and crabs. You can also find local breweries and wineries on the island.
  • What are the best pet friendly accommodations in Fire Island, NY?

  • In which part of Fire Island, NY should you consider renting accommodation?

    It depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be near the nightlife and action, consider renting in Fire Island Pines. If you prefer a quieter experience, Ocean Beach or Cherry Grove might be better options. The western end of the island is more remote and offers a more natural experience.
  • What are the best accommodations with parking in Fire Island, NY?

    Comfortable Private Room, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the best accommodations with parking in Fire Island, NY.

Destinations nearby

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a balcony

Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit! - Fire Island, NY
9.9 275 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/10 – 15/10
169 €/nighttotal: 1521 € (9 )

Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit!

1 1
apartment , Islip Terrace
This apartment is located in Islip Terrace, within 3 kilometres of the Cohalan Court Complex, Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Gallery of Shorthand, and within 5 kilometres of SUSA Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex and Bethpage Ballpark. This property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience.
The apartment is a 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom flat with a 37 square metre floor area and a maximum capacity of 3 guests. This property features a garden, a terrace, a spa, parking, and free Wi-Fi, as well as a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave oven, and a stovetop.
Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach - Fire Island, NY
9.9 49 reviews
Fire Island, NY
22/06 – 29/06
1129 €/nighttotal: 7903 € (7 )

Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach

4 3
apartment , Ocean Beach
This house is located in Ocean Beach, just 1 kilometre from the beautiful beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the oceanfront. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This four-bedroom house spans 232 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Enjoy a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining.
Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/10 – 15/10
1062 €/nighttotal: 9558 € (9 )

Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool

5 1
apartment , Bellport
This spacious apartment is located in Bellport, just a short drive from Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts and William Floyd Estate, making it a great base for exploring the area's cultural attractions. It has received excellent user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction from previous guests.
The apartment offers 232 square metres of living space with 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 10 guests. It includes a range of amenities, such as a private pool, a hot tub, a home gym, and two dedicated workspaces, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
14/08 – 20/08
1238 €/nighttotal: 7428 € (6 )

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

1 10
house , Fire Island
This spacious air-conditioned holiday home is located in a quiet district of Fire Island, offering garden views from its terrace and easy access to the beach, just 100 meters away.
This 158 square meter property accommodates up to 19 guests with 2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, a private terrace, and a balcony.

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a kitchen

Ocean Beach Fire Island 3bds/2bth,3 Houses From The Beach! Huge Back&front Yard - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
22/06 – 29/06
738 €/nighttotal: 5166 € (7 )

Ocean Beach Fire Island 3bds/2bth,3 Houses From The Beach! Huge Back&front Yard

1 3
apartment , Ocean Beach
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday cottage in Ocean Beach is located just 270 metres from the ocean, offering a classic beach experience with easy access to the car-free sandy beach and proximity to cultural sites such as the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
This family-friendly rental accommodates up to eight guests and features a large backyard deck with a BBQ grill, an outdoor shower, air conditioning in all bedrooms and the living room, and is fully equipped with linens, towels, and beach gear, with paid parking available at the ferry terminal for convenient access.
Ocean Bay Park - Now Booking 2026 Season! September 19 To 26 Date Available - Fire Island, NY
9.8 102 reviews
Fire Island, NY
21/06 – 22/06
2413 €/nightfor 1 night

Ocean Bay Park - Now Booking 2026 Season! September 19 To 26 Date Available

1 1
apartment , Fire Island
This five-bedroom Fire Island beach house, situated steps from the iconic beach and close to the ferry, restaurants, and tennis courts, offers convenient access to local amenities.
The 186 square metre property boasts a spacious open-plan living/dining/kitchen area, a large wraparound deck with BBQ, sleeps fifteen comfortably, and includes amenities such as Direct TV, Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Bright And Breezy Beach House -
Ocean Bay Park, Ny - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
1165 €/nighttotal: 3495 € (3 )

Bright And Breezy Beach House - Ocean Bay Park, Ny

1 6
apartment , Fire Island
This Ocean Bay Park flat is located in Fire Island, a mere 100 metres from the ocean, and offers convenient access from the ferry with provided luggage transport.
This family-friendly accommodation sleeps up to nine guests and features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, air conditioning, a garden, and provided bicycles, plus an outdoor shower for a classic Fire Island experience.
Prime Locale: Ideal Guesthouse - Fire Island, NY
9.4 82 reviews
Fire Island, NY
31/07 – 03/08
204 €/nighttotal: 612 € (3 )

Prime Locale: Ideal Guesthouse

1 1
house , Bay Shore
This charming guest house is located in a peaceful neighbourhood in Bay Shore, just a short walk from the beach and the town centre. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall guest experience.
The one-bedroom property is ideal for couples or solo travellers seeking a cosy retreat. The house comes equipped with all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay, including air conditioning, a kitchen, and a swimming pool. You can also enjoy free parking and access to the internet.
©2026 cozycozy.com