Compare Vacation Rentals & Airbnb in New Buffalo, MI
258 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
258 Rentals and Airbnb in New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$537/nighttotal: $1074 (2 )
The Firefly | Cabin | Firepit | Pet-friendly
2 5
cabin , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
This woodland lodge is situated in Sawyer, a mere 3.2 kilometres from Warren Dunes State Park and conveniently close to local orchards, breweries, and the attractions of Harbor Country. This 145 square metre cabin accommodates up to five guests with two bedrooms and one bathroom, offering a pet-friendly environment with amenities including Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and parking, alongside a charcoal grill and shared fire pit for outdoor enjoyment.
9.4 10 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$987/nighttotal: $1974 (2 )
2 Mi To Beach! Hot Tub Haven In Michigan City
3 8
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City flat is positioned conveniently within 3.2 kilometres of Indiana Dunes National Park and a mere 2 kilometres from Washington Park Beach, Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets, and the Old Lighthouse Museum. This spacious 372 square metre residence accommodates up to 11 guests, featuring three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a hot tub, a wet bar, two decks for outdoor enjoyment, and a streaming-capable television, all with central air conditioning and internet access.
New Buffalo, MI
18/07 – 25/07
$1529/nighttotal: $10703 (7 )
Indigo Pines | Modern Retreat | Pool, Spa, Firepit
1 10
apartment , Grand Beach
This holiday flat is located in the Grand Beach district, surrounded by pine trees, and is a short distance from the beach. This property offers accommodation for 10 guests, featuring a heated swimming pool, hot tub, fire pit, indoor cold plunge, and a screened porch, with the entire home accessible to visitors.
8.0 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$1919/nighttotal: $3838 (2 )
Lake Life Livin- Beach House
3 8
apartment , Michigan City
This three-bedroom, three-bathroom holiday home in Michigan City is a 0.4km walk from Lake Michigan and a short drive from Washington Park and its zoo, offering easy access to Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore. The 272 square metre property sleeps six, includes Wi-Fi, air conditioning, linens, and amenities such as soap and a hairdryer, providing comfortable accommodation for exploring Michigan City's attractions.
9.7 108 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 09/08
$439/nighttotal: $878 (2 )
Cheerful Home With Free Covered Parking Onsite.
1 4
apartment , Three Oaks
This Three Oaks apartment, ideally located in the heart of Harbor Country, offers convenient access to beaches, wineries, and hiking/biking trails. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom flat sleeps four guests and includes a fridge, air conditioning, parking, and internet access; nearby attractions include fine dining and art galleries.
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$681/nighttotal: $1362 (2 )
Maudlin Meadows -A New Buffalo Retreat
1 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This secluded three-bedroom flat sits on 3.5 acres of meadow and woodland, bordering a historic farm, and is just a five-minute drive from New Buffalo town centre, the beach, and Four Winds Casino. This comfortable flat, accommodating up to six guests, offers air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and a kitchen, all within a peaceful setting providing access to walking trails and a tranquil escape.
10 2 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
26/06 – 28/06
$2393/nighttotal: $4786 (2 )
Lakehouse Escape @Greydome- Beach Hot Tub Firepit
1 2
apartment , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
This Lake Michigan holiday flat in Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert is located a mere 20 metres from deeded beach access, placing you within easy reach of Harbor Country's notable dining and entertainment venues. This spacious 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom flat accommodates up to 6 guests and features a screened porch, a private hot tub, a firepit area, and a spa-like bathroom, all offering modern comfort with an elegant design and a bright, open layout.
New Buffalo, MI
10/10 – 13/10
$1157/nighttotal: $3471 (3 )
A Wave From It All
5 10
house , New Buffalo
This five-bedroom New Buffalo holiday home is situated approximately 47 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport, offering convenient access to the area. Sleeping up to 19 guests, this property boasts a private swimming pool, tennis court, fully equipped kitchen, and three bathrooms; enjoy self-catering in this spacious dwelling with ample outdoor space including a terrace or balcony.
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
26/06 – 28/06
$997/nighttotal: $1994 (2 )
Cedar & Rye: Open Spaces And Cottage Charm
4 2
apartment , Three Oaks
This rural farmhouse, located just outside Three Oaks' centre, offers peaceful farmland views and is a short drive to Lake Michigan beaches, local wineries, distilleries, and the antique shops and cafes of downtown Three Oaks. This spacious property accommodates up to eight guests with four bedrooms and two bathrooms, featuring a large farmhouse table, a back porch with a grill, a fire pit, a dedicated workspace with Wi-Fi, and a laundry room, with ample driveway space for six cars.
9.4 14 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
10/10 – 13/10
$1202/nighttotal: $3606 (3 )
Spacious Downtown Nb Home, Great For Groups!
4 10
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home is conveniently located less than 1.6km from Lake Michigan, an 8-minute walk from New Buffalo Station, and a short drive from the New Buffalo Township Public Library and City Hall. This five-bedroom, four-bathroom property boasts 251 square metres of space, sleeping up to 14 guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, patio, garden, parking, and in-unit laundry facilities.
New Buffalo, MI
27/06 – 04/07
$550/nighttotal: $3850 (7 )
The Cottage At Historic 33 Acre Berrywood Farm
1 2
apartment , Three Oaks
Berrywood Cottage, a refurbished 1890s grain house, offers a private retreat on a 33-hectare farm overlooking a pond, situated approximately 1.6 kilometres from Three Oaks village and within easy reach of Harbor Country's amenities. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom flat accommodates up to four guests and features a vaulted loft bedroom, a wood-burning fireplace, a secluded deck, a full kitchen, and shared access to orchards, trails, ponds, and outdoor activities such as canoeing and fishing.
9.9 230 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
28/06 – 02/07
$657/nighttotal: $2628 (4 )
Downtown Bungalow Near Beach
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This renovated brick bungalow is located just 200 metres from the bars, restaurants, and shops on Whittaker Avenue, and less than 8 kilometres from New Buffalo Beach. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience. The property offers five bedrooms, including one in the basement without a door, and a large recreation room in the basement with two single beds, accommodating up to 14 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace, a garden, a spa, parking, high-speed internet, a 50-inch TV, and a fire pit for relaxing evenings.
Best family friendly New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals
Among the 258 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals
8.4 58 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$2199/nighttotal: $8796 (4 )
Perfect Home For All Seasons
5 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home enjoys a prime location directly opposite beach access, offering stunning lake views and proximity to New Buffalo's shops and restaurants, within a 16km radius, and the New Buffalo Railroad Museum (distance unspecified). Sleeping up to 14 guests in five bedrooms and three bathrooms, the property boasts a heated pool, jacuzzi, large fenced garden with bonfire pit, fully remodelled kitchen, games room with table football and Pac-Man, and modern amenities including Wi-Fi and cable TV.
8.9 15 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
18/07 – 23/07
$702/nighttotal: $3510 (5 )
Hot Fun In The Summertime! Close To The Lake
2 3
apartment , Michiana Shores
This charming cottage is located in Michiana Shores, a peaceful residential area just 70km from downtown Chicago and a short drive from Lake Michigan beaches, New Buffalo and Michigan City. The cottage has received very good user ratings, with excellent location and cleanliness ratings. The two-bedroom, two-bathroom cottage comfortably sleeps six guests and features a finished basement with a bathroom, a finished attic with multiple beds, and a croquet set for added fun. Guests can enjoy a well-equipped kitchen, a spacious backyard, and a peaceful garden.
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
12/07 – 15/07
$1229/nighttotal: $3687 (3 )
Union Pier Condo With Heated Pool!
3 1
apartment , New Buffalo
This Union Pier apartment, a five-minute walk from Lake Michigan beach and near Union Pier's amenities including the Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room, offers a convenient base for exploring New Buffalo, Michigan. Sleeping up to eight guests across two queen bedrooms and a bunk room, this two-bathroom second-floor flat boasts a sunny deck overlooking a shared heated pool, a fully equipped kitchen, and family-friendly features such as blackout curtains, baby monitors, and pool toys.
9.0 19 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
04/09 – 07/09
$557/nighttotal: $1671 (3 )
Beautiful Woodsy Setting A 10 Minute Walk To The Beach!
3 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This holiday home is situated a short 1.6km drive from Union Pier Beach, offering easy access to the beautiful shores of Lake Michigan, and within a 24km drive of Gordon Beach and Townline Beach. The property has received very good ratings from previous guests. The home has three bedrooms and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests. The property boasts a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden with a barbecue, and a terrace for enjoying the fresh air and sunshine.
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with a pool
Among the 258 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best rentals with a pool
9.6 23 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
28/06 – 02/07
$775/nighttotal: $3100 (4 )
Condo In The Heart Of New Buffalo With Heated Pool!
2 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This two-bedroom apartment is situated just a short walk from New Buffalo Station and a short drive from New Buffalo Public Beach and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to both transportation and the area's main attractions. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The apartment is ideal for families or groups of up to six people and features a fully equipped kitchen, two bathrooms, a fireplace, and a balcony. Guests can enjoy the convenience of an indoor pool, fitness centre, and parking, as well as the option of taking advantage of the nearby beach, lake, and local attractions.
New Buffalo, MI
16/07 – 23/07
$1022/nighttotal: $7154 (7 )
Blue Creek Pool House
1 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This Blue Creek holiday home is located in a peaceful, tree-lined area, 1.2 kilometres from the beaches of Stops 37-41 and a short drive from downtown New Buffalo. This family-friendly apartment accommodates up to 8 guests and features a private indoor heated pool, a wood-burning fire pit, and a spacious open-concept kitchen and living area, with concierge services provided by Third Coast Vacations.
9.0 3 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
04/09 – 07/09
$2286/nighttotal: $6858 (3 )
Hidden Haven
4 3
house , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home, situated in Union Pier, Michigan, is 47 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport and offers convenient access to New Buffalo's attractions. Sleeping up to 17 guests, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom property boasts a well-equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a balcony, a tennis court, free Wi-Fi, and free private parking; skiing in Union Pier is also nearby.
10 2 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
$1939/nighttotal: $5817 (3 )
Luxe By The Lake | Pool Access | Near Downtown And Lake
3 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This upscale townhome, located in the Union Green neighbourhood, offers a prime position just 100 metres from Lake Michigan's beaches and is a short distance from Union Pier's attractions, including Union Pier Social and Black Currant Bakery. Spanning 193 square metres, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom residence accommodates up to eight guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a shared heated swimming pool open until October, and parking for two vehicles.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI
What are some interesting places to visit in or near New Buffalo, MI?
There's plenty to see in New Buffalo! The New Buffalo Railroad Museum is a must-see for history buffs, and you can't miss the stunning views from the top of the New Buffalo Lighthouse. If you're looking for a bit of nature, head to the Warren Dunes State Park, where you can hike, bike, or even go sandboarding.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Which walking or cycling routes are the best in New Buffalo, MI?
The paved bike path along the lakefront is perfect for a leisurely cycle, and the Warren Dunes State Park has some great hiking trails. You can even walk or cycle along the beach, it's a real treat.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in New Buffalo, MI?
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around New Buffalo, MI?
You can go swimming, sunbathing, fishing, and kayaking on the lake, and the Warren Dunes State Park is great for hiking, sandboarding, and even horseback riding.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in New Buffalo, MI?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from New Buffalo, MI?
You can easily get to Chicago, which is about a 1.5 hour drive, or head to the charming town of South Haven, about 45 minutes away. There's also the beautiful city of St. Joseph, a short drive to the north.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in New Buffalo, MI?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Most vacation rentals in New Buffalo have things like Wi-Fi, a TV, a washing machine and dryer, and a fully equipped kitchen. Many also have a barbecue, a patio, and access to a swimming pool.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in New Buffalo, MI?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental New Buffalo, MI?
Summer is the most popular time to visit, but it gets quite busy. Spring and autumn are lovely for a quieter trip, with pleasant temperatures and beautiful scenery.
What are the local dishes in New Buffalo, MI region?
You've got to try the whitefish, it's a local speciality. There are lots of great seafood restaurants in New Buffalo. And of course, you can't go wrong with a classic Chicago-style deep dish pizza!
Destinations nearby
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with a balcony
9.6 21 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$2042/nighttotal: $8168 (4 )
Spacious Family Villa Near Beaches With Private Pool, Wifi, Firepit & Central Ac
4 2
apartment , New Buffalo
Harbor Country Family Lodge is a spacious holiday home located east of the Galien River, approximately 3.2 kilometres from both the beaches at New Buffalo and Townline Beach, and a short drive to local wineries and shops. This family-friendly lodge offers 4 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms across 412 square metres, accommodating up to 16 guests with amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, media room, sunroom with a double-sided fireplace, a heated above-ground pool, volleyball court, and a firepit, with cribs and high chairs available on request.
9.8 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
$820/nighttotal: $2460 (3 )
Quiet Remodeled Cottage Near Downtown Sawyer - Private Deck, Gas Grill, Firepit
2 3
apartment , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
This recently remodelled flat is located in Sawyer, offering a secluded setting surrounded by trees, just 965 meters from Warren Dunes State Park and within easy reach of local shops, a coffee shop, and a brewery. This 86 square meter cottage accommodates up to six guests with two bedrooms and one bathroom, featuring a modern kitchen, air conditioning, a sunroom, and an outdoor deck with a grill, seating, and a firepit, perfect for enjoying the expansive gardens.
8.0 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 09/08
$1316/nighttotal: $2632 (2 )
Fowl Play Hideaway
5 7
house , Michigan City
Fowl Play Hideaway, a single-bedroom house in Michigan City, Indiana, is conveniently located approximately 32 kilometres from Valparaiso University and its Brauer Museum of Art, and 47 kilometres from Deep River Waterpark. This self-catering property sleeps up to 31 guests, boasting three bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a Jacuzzi, a terrace with garden views, free Wi-Fi, and free private parking; it’s also only 55 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport.
10 11 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
04/09 – 07/09
$1560/nighttotal: $4680 (3 )
Main Home & Cozy Guest House W/ Two Full Kitchens & Free Wifi - Walk To Beach
4 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This Union Pier holiday home is located just 240 metres from Lake Michigan beach access points and offers convenient proximity to local shops, restaurants, and wineries in the Harbor Country region. This spacious property, spanning 232 square metres, features a main house and a separate guest house accommodating up to eight guests, with four bedrooms, four bathrooms, two fully equipped kitchens, multiple living areas, and amenities including two washer/dryers and free WiFi.
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with parking
New Buffalo, MI
18/07 – 19/07
$880/nightfor 1 night
Cozy 2 Bed - Steps To Journeyman - Pets Ok - Fast Wi-fi
2 2
apartment , Three Oaks
This flat in Three Oaks, Michigan, is situated just 100 metres from Elm Street, the town's main road, and a short drive from Lake Michigan beaches, placing it within walking distance of the Vickers Theatre and Acorn Theater, and a brief journey from Journeyman Distillery. This 62 square metre apartment accommodates up to four guests, offering two bedrooms, one bathroom, air conditioning, a garden, a spa, parking, a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, and an in-unit washer and dryer, with high-speed internet available for remote workers.
New Buffalo, MI
19/09 – 20/09
$1023/nightfor 1 night
Welcome To This Beautiful Home Tucked Into A Little Neighborhood, Near Lake Michigan. Come And Stay In This Lovely "Hideaway"!
3 2
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City holiday home is situated less than 1.6km from Washington Park Beach and Zoo, and approximately 5km from the South Shore Train Station, offering easy access to Lake Michigan's beaches. This three-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment boasts a 1300 square metre floor area, including a fully equipped kitchen, large bonus room, fenced backyard with grill, and sleeps up to eight guests, making it ideal for families or groups.
9.7 27 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
10/10 – 13/10
$1058/nighttotal: $3174 (3 )
Beautiful Union Pier Home Steps To Private Beach!
4 10
apartment , New Buffalo
This four-bedroom house is located in Harbor Country, a short walk from Gowdy Shores private beach and close to New Buffalo's downtown area. The property has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness. This spacious holiday home, covering 130 square metres, comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious living area, a screened-in porch, a large garden, a private beach, parking for three cars, and a host of modern conveniences.
New Buffalo, MI
27/06 – 04/07
$535/nighttotal: $3745 (7 )
The Loft At Historic 33 Acre Berrywood Farm
1 2
apartment , Three Oaks
This elegant studio apartment, located on thirty-three acres of Berrywood Farm, offers a historic retreat just a short drive from Three Oaks and other Harbor Country destinations like Union Pier and New Buffalo, providing convenient access to dining, shopping, and shoreline attractions. Guests can enjoy a private garden patio with a firepit, access to extensive farm landscapes with ponds and trails, and shared amenities including a bocce court, with accommodation for four people featuring a Queen bed and a double pullout sofa.