Compare best Airbnb in Sag Harbor, NY from 100+ providers!
185 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Sag Harbor, NY
9.8 49 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1275/nighttotal: $7650 (6 )
Our Peaceful, Beach Escape From The City
1 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor house rental is located half a block from a private beach and within walking distance of Sag Harbor Village's shops and restaurants. This six-bedroom, four-bathroom home offers two living areas, two decks, a patio, a large backyard with a horseshoe pit, a ping pong table, and accommodates up to twelve guests, with amenities including a full kitchen, air conditioning, and parking.
10 141 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$5980/nighttotal: $11960 (2 )
9 Acre Luxury Compound In Sag Harbor Ny
7 1
apartment , Bridgehampton
This luxurious 9-acre estate is located in Sagaponack, just a short drive from South Hampton, East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Sag Harbor. The property boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. This spacious home features 7 bedrooms and 8 bathrooms, accommodating up to 16 guests. Enjoy a range of amenities including a heated pool, jacuzzi, fitness center, game room, and a private chef service.
9.8 18 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$686/nighttotal: $4116 (6 )
Private House, Close To Beach
1 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor vacation home is minutes from the ocean, with private beach access and Havens Beach less than half a mile away, offering easy access to restaurants and shops. The 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom house sleeps 8, features a heated pool, large yard with gas and charcoal grills, high-end kitchen, and includes weekly cleaning services—book by April 1st, 2025, for early bird specials.
10 145 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$780/nighttotal: $4680 (6 )
Sag Harbor Village Gem
3 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor vacation home is just a 10-minute walk from Eastville Heritage House and the Hamptons Beaches, putting you right in the heart of the town's historic charm and beautiful coastline. Guests have consistently rated this property excellent for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The house has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests in its 1,800 square feet of space. Enjoy modern amenities like free Wi-Fi, a fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchen, as well as outdoor grilling and a terrace or balcony for relaxing.
8.6 4 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$643/nighttotal: $3858 (6 )
Modern Sag Harbor Escape, Moments From The Water And Long Beach To View...
3 1
apartment , Noyack
This three-bedroom, three-bathroom Sag Harbor rental is centrally located in the village, steps from the water and a short drive to Long Beach. The modern home features an open floor plan, a private backyard, high-speed WiFi, central AC, and sleeps six guests comfortably, with proximity to Sag Harbor's restaurants, boutiques, and art galleries.
10 222 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$312/nighttotal: $1872 (6 )
Updated Apartment In Historic Village Home
1 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment in Sag Harbor is an excellent choice for travelers seeking a comfortable and convenient stay. The apartment boasts a prime location, offering easy access to the town's charming shops, restaurants, and attractions. The apartment features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, and parking. It has received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and amenities, ensuring a pleasant and memorable stay for guests.
10 57 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$660/nighttotal: $3960 (6 )
Chic Cottage On Lush, Secluded Acre By The Beach.
1 1
apartment , Northwest Harbor
This charming cottage is located in Northwest Harbor, a short walk from a secluded beach and a quick drive to both East Hampton and Sag Harbor. It consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The cottage comfortably accommodates up to six guests in three bedrooms and two bathrooms. It features a modern kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, plus a garden, air conditioning, and parking. Enjoy the privacy of a secluded lawn and the convenience of being close to local amenities and activities.
9.9 37 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1107/nighttotal: $6642 (6 )
Sag Harbor Pearl
4 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor house, located in a family-friendly neighborhood a short walk from a bayside beach and close to Sag Harbor Village's shops and restaurants, offers easy access to all that this Long Island town has to offer. This four-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps eight guests and features a microwave, air conditioning, a garden, parking, and Wi-Fi; enjoy its spacious interior, large yard, deck, and stunning views.
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$314/nighttotal: $628 (2 )
Afforable 1 Bed, 1 Bath Aparment In The Hamptons
1 1
apartment , Northwest Harbor
This private apartment is located in Northwest Harbor, offering convenient access to Sag Harbor and East Hampton, with ocean beaches, farm stands, restaurants, and shopping within easy reach. This pet-friendly accommodation for two features air conditioning, internet, a queen bed, and access to shared outdoor areas and a pool, serving as an ideal base for weekend getaways or beach escapes.
10 1 review
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$8357/nighttotal: $16714 (2 )
Traditional-style Home With Private Pool, Sweeping Back Deck, Grand Lawn,...
4 1
apartment , Water Mill
This four-bedroom, three-bathroom Water Mill house rental is located just outside Bridgehampton, a short drive from the Parrish Art Museum and South Fork Natural History Museum. The 8-guest property boasts a private pool, expansive deck, well-equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, Wi-Fi, a washer/dryer, and ample parking, perfect for summer barbecues and relaxing after exploring the area.
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$1406/nighttotal: $2812 (2 )
Charming Accommodations In The Hamptons
1 1
apartment , Noyack
This Sag Harbor apartment is located less than 3 miles from downtown Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton, providing convenient access to The Hamptons Beaches, Cooper's Beach, the Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, and Bay Street Theatre. This 950 square feet rental offers a private entrance, a living room with a sectional sofa that converts to a king-sized bed, air conditioning, parking, and allows pets, accommodating up to 4 guests.
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$5770/nighttotal: $11540 (2 )
Spacious 5-bedroom House With Water Views And 2 Houses From The Bay.
5 1
apartment , North Haven
This Sag Harbor vacation home, near Bay Street Theatre and the Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, offers easy access to Eastville Heritage House and Havens House. This five-bedroom, six-bathroom house sleeps ten guests, boasting a private guest area, smart TVs in all bedrooms, a pool, and proximity to Sag Harbor attractions like BookHampton and Shelter Island.
Best Sag Harbor, NY vacation rentals with a balcony
10 29 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$2984/nighttotal: $17904 (6 )
Prime Location! Walk To Beach! Wainscott Family House & Cottage. Pool & Hot Tub!
5 1
apartment , Wainscott
This charming cottage sits in the heart of Wainscott, a quiet, rural area just a short walk from one of the most beautiful Hamptons beaches. It's rated excellent by previous guests, making it a popular choice for families and groups seeking a relaxing getaway. The 3,500 square foot cottage comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests with 5 bedrooms and pull-out couches. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private pool and jacuzzi, spacious outdoor areas, and a host of other amenities, including a Sonos sound system, three decks, and a fully enclosed courtyard.
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$2174/nighttotal: $13044 (6 )
Hamptons 9bd Mega Compound W Pool Tennis Bball Nightclub
9 1
house , Noyack
This 9-bedroom villa is located in Noyack, 48 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport. This spacious residence offers 5010 square feet of living space, accommodating up to 60 guests with amenities including a private pool, hot tub, and a well-equipped kitchen.
9.6 13 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1349/nighttotal: $8094 (6 )
Waterfront Home On Beautiful Shelter Island W/large Deep Water Dock
5 1
apartment , Shelter Island Heights
This oceanfront Shelter Island Heights home offers stunning views and easy beach access, located within two miles of Havens House, the Shelter Island Historical Society, and Sylvester Manor. This 4,700-square-foot vacation rental boasts six bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps twelve guests, and includes a full kitchen, spa, fireplace, game room, and private parking.
9.7 7 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1713/nighttotal: $10278 (6 )
Summer East Hampton Retreat- Heated Pool, Tennis, Hot Tub
5 1
apartment , Wainscott
This Wainscott home is conveniently located just a short drive from both Sag Harbor Village and East Hampton Village, offering easy access to the beaches, restaurants, and cultural attractions of both towns. The property boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers. This 5-bedroom, 6-bathroom house provides 4,000 square feet of living space. Guests can enjoy a private pool, hot tub, tennis court, and a variety of other amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a Sonos entertainment system, and a gym.
Search Family Vacation Rentals in Sag Harbor, NY
Plan the perfect family beach trip to Sag Harbor, NY with spacious rentals that offer plenty of room to spread out.
10 17 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1071/nighttotal: $6426 (6 )
Shelter Island Retreat With Pool ...Close To Beach & Pet Friendly
3 1
apartment , Shelter Island Heights
This family-friendly vacation home is located in Shelter Island Heights, just a short distance from Crescent Beach, Sunset Beach, and Shelter Island Country Club. This rental has received excellent reviews from previous guests. The house has 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 7 guests. The home features a private pool, barbecue grills, a garden, a fireplace, and a game room for entertainment.
10 5 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$962/nighttotal: $5772 (6 )
Sag Harbor Village 3 Bedroom Gem
3 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor Village residence is a historic landmark reimagined, located steps from Sag Harbor's boutiques, dining, and waterfront, with the Sag Harbor Jitney stop a 10-minute walk away. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom apartment accommodates up to 5 guests and features a gourmet eat-in kitchen, a library/dining room, an outdoor patio, and a private backyard, offering a quintessential Sag Harbor village experience.
9.7 136 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$2114/nighttotal: $12684 (6 )
Designer Retreat In The Village - Sag Lighthouse
1 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This midcentury-style home is located in Sag Harbor's historic district, a short walk from the village center's shops and restaurants. The property has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom house accommodates up to 6 guests. The house offers a spacious layout, a swimming pool, a fitness center, a garden, and a gourmet kitchen, perfect for enjoying the beautiful Sag Harbor weather.
10 90 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$2121/nighttotal: $12726 (6 )
Summer 2026 Now Available! Grab An Amazing Property In The Heart Of The Hamptons
7 1
apartment , Bridgehampton
This 7-bedroom, 5-bathroom luxury home is located just two miles from Bridgehampton village, harbor, and beaches, offering a secluded setting in a private wooded area. It has received excellent user ratings for its amenities and location. The 4,500-square-foot home can accommodate up to 14 guests and features a gourmet kitchen, a home theater system, a finished basement with games, a gym, and a large DVD collection. Amenities include a heated saltwater pool, a hot tub, an outdoor BBQ grill, a spacious deck with a pergola, a fire pit, and an outdoor TV.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, NY
Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Sag Harbor, NY?
There are some great walking and cycling routes in Sag Harbor. You can walk or bike along the waterfront, or take a scenic ride through the historic streets. The Long Wharf is a popular spot for walking and enjoying the views, and the Sag Harbor Bike Path is a great way to explore the area on two wheels.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, NY?
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Sag Harbor, NY?
Sag Harbor is a great place for outdoor activities. You can go swimming, fishing, kayaking, or paddleboarding in the harbor. There are also several golf courses in the area, and you can even go horseback riding on the beach. If you're looking for a more challenging activity, there's also great hiking and biking in the surrounding area.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Sag Harbor, NY?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Sag Harbor, NY?
Sag Harbor is a great base for exploring the East End of Long Island. You can easily drive to nearby towns like Southampton, East Hampton, and Montauk. If you're looking for a bigger city, you can take a train or bus to New York City, which is about a 2-hour drive from Sag Harbor.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Sag Harbor, NY?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, NY?
Vacation rentals in Sag Harbor usually offer a wide range of amenities, including kitchens, laundry facilities, and outdoor spaces like patios or decks. Many rentals also offer amenities like swimming pools, hot tubs, and fireplaces.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Sag Harbor, NY?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Sag Harbor, NY?
The best time to visit Sag Harbor depends on what you're looking for. The summer months are the most popular time to visit, but it can get crowded and expensive. If you're looking for a more relaxed experience, you might consider visiting in the shoulder seasons, like spring or fall.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Sag Harbor, NY?
What are the local dishes in Sag Harbor, NY region?
Sag Harbor is known for its fresh seafood, so be sure to try some of the local catches like lobster, clams, and oysters. You can also find delicious Italian food, as well as classic American dishes like burgers and fries.
Destinations nearby
Best Sag Harbor, NY vacation rentals with parking
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$537/nighttotal: $3222 (6 )
Dreamy Cottage
1 1
house , Noyack
This Sag Harbor cottage is located an 11-minute walk from Foster Memorial Beach and a considerable distance from Montauk Point Lighthouse. This 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom accommodation sleeps up to 3 guests and offers complimentary WiFi, private parking, air conditioning, a full kitchen, and a garden.
10 18 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$344/nighttotal: $2064 (6 )
Peaceful Cottage
1 1
house , Northwest Harbor
This Northwest Harbor cottage, situated midway between East Hampton and Sag Harbor, provides easy access to ocean and bay beaches and nearby hiking trails. The 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom house features a full kitchen, spacious living room with a smart TV, a queen-size bed, garage parking, laundry facilities, and accommodates up to 2 guests.
10 55 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1307/nighttotal: $7842 (6 )
Escape To Sag Harbor
3 1
apartment , Noyack
This spacious 2400-square-foot house in Sag Harbor, a five-minute drive from downtown and two minutes from Long Beach on the Bay, offers easy access to Sag Harbor's art galleries, restaurants, and museums. The three-bedroom, four-bathroom rental boasts a private saltwater pool, separate guest house, and ample outdoor space with hammocks and swings, comfortably accommodating up to seven guests and featuring a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher.
10 104 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$2188/nighttotal: $13128 (6 )
East Hampton- Beautiful 4 Bedroom Home, Large Heated Pool, Private Backyard
4 1
apartment , Northwest Harbor
This family-friendly vacation home is located in East Hampton, just 2 miles from the Hamptons Beaches, Three Mile Harbor, and Cedar Point County Park. The house has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. This 4-bedroom house spans 2800 square feet and can comfortably accommodate up to 9 guests. Enjoy a private pool, a fenced yard, a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace, and a bar, all while taking advantage of the free WiFi and the convenience of housekeeping upon request.
Check Out Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Sag Harbor, NY
Enhance your coastal getaway with a Sag Harbor, NY vacation rental featuring a pool.
9.8 36 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1023/nighttotal: $6138 (6 )
Sag Harbor Chic 4 Bedroom Saltwater Pool
1 1
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor house rental is a short walk from Havens Beach and 1.2 miles from Sag Harbor Village, offering easy access to both. The four-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps eight guests and features a saltwater pool (open mid-May), a spacious half-acre property, and a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher.
9.9 134 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$5364/nighttotal: $10728 (2 )
Luxury, Private, Gated Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Fenced In Property! Child Friendly!
6 1
apartment , Wainscott
This six-bedroom house is located in Wainscott, East Hampton, less than half a mile from Montauk Highway and a short distance from the beach. The property has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. This spacious home has a floor area of 2600 square feet and can accommodate up to 13 guests. The home offers a range of amenities, including a heated pool, hot tub, tennis court, fitness center, and a well-equipped kitchen, making it perfect for families and groups.
9.9 14 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1476/nighttotal: $8856 (6 )
Sag Harbor Island View Drive House With Pool
1 1
apartment , Noyack
This Sag Harbor, Noyac Bay house rental is conveniently located near Long Beach and Main Street, offering easy access to local shops and restaurants. The five-bedroom, three-bathroom home includes a heated Gunite pool, Jacuzzi, and a private apartment, accommodating up to ten guests and offering stunning Noyac Bay views from its third-floor deck.
10 14 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1409/nighttotal: $8454 (6 )
Charming Sag Harbor Home W/ Heated Pool
1 1
apartment , Noyack
This Sag Harbor rental is located on a quiet cul-de-sac, a short walk from Sag Harbor village shops and restaurants, and a short drive to Sag Harbor beaches. The newly renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom house features a private pool, accommodates up to 10 guests, and offers stylish mid-century modern and antique furnishings.
Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Sag Harbor, NY
These seaside vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, NY provide an excellent base for exploring the coast. Browse top local properties and plan your beach-town trip.
9.9 253 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$479/nighttotal: $2874 (6 )
Whaling Captain Pierson's Cottage
1 1
cottage , Sag Harbor
10 22 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1040/nighttotal: $6240 (6 )
Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach
3 1
apartment , Shelter Island
9.8 17 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$857/nighttotal: $5142 (6 )
Designer Sag Harbor Home W/ Pool + Fire Pit + Yard
1 1
apartment , Noyack
10 72 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1785/nighttotal: $10710 (6 )
Cove View Manor Of Sag Harbor
3 1
apartment , Noyack
Compare Luxury Vacation Rentals in Sag Harbor, NY
Refined interiors and prime locations make these luxury waterfront vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, NY the ideal choice for your stay.
9.9 163 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
07/17 – 07/19
$466/nighttotal: $932 (2 )
Hamptons Hills Escape
1 1
apartment , Noyack
Discover Vacation Rentals with Saunas in Sag Harbor, NY
Relax in style with an on-site sauna at these premium Sag Harbor, NY vacation rentals near the water.
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$7678/nighttotal: $46068 (6 )
Villa Kimaal - Luxury With Pool
5 1
house , Noyack
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1946/nighttotal: $11676 (6 )
Villa Nostro Palazzo
7 1
house , Wainscott
10 1 review
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$1683/nighttotal: $10098 (6 )
Sag Harbor Summer House
1 1
apartment , Noyack
Sag Harbor, NY
10/13 – 10/19
$873/nighttotal: $5238 (6 )
Modern Resort-style Retreat In The Heart Of East Hampton Seamless...
