Compare best cottages in New Buffalo, MI from 100+ sites!

This cottage in New Buffalo is located a few houses from a Lake Michigan overlook and community beach access points, with a park and golf course nearby.
This family-friendly rental accommodates up to 8 guests with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering air conditioning, internet, a full kitchen, and a screened porch, with proximity to Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Park.

This 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom cottage near Lake Michigan in Grand Beach is located on a quiet, dead-end street, offering easy access to community beaches, a park, and sports courts within walking distance, and is also a short drive to the Indiana Dunes National Park.
This dog-friendly vacation home accommodates up to 11 guests and features a screened porch, air conditioning, internet, and a full kitchen, with nearby attractions including a golf course, breweries, dispensaries, wineries, casinos, and theme parks.

This charming cottage is situated in Union Pier, a desirable beachside district on Lakeshore Road, just steps away from the sandy shores of Lake Michigan. It boasts excellent guest reviews, making it a popular choice for travelers seeking a relaxing getaway. The 1400 square foot cottage comfortably accommodates up to 5 guests, offering two bedrooms and three bathrooms. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private patio, a pergola-covered deck, a firepit, and a weekly cleaning service, providing everything you need for a memorable stay.
This family-friendly cottage offers direct beach access, making it perfect for families with children. Enjoy a variety of outdoor activities, including swimming, sunbathing, and exploring the nearby attractions like Vickers Theatre and Hesston Steam Museum.

This family-friendly lakeside vacation rental is located in Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert, just a short distance from Burnison Galleries and Lake Michigan, and within two miles of Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room and Union Pier Beach. The cottage has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers.
This comfortable home has three bedrooms and can accommodate up to eight guests. The home features a fully equipped kitchen, a cozy fireplace, a private garden, and a hot tub for ultimate relaxation.

This newly built vacation rental is located just minutes from Downtown Union Pier, a short distance from Lake Michigan and Warren Dunes State Park, offering a peaceful retreat in a quiet neighborhood. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers.
The 1800 square foot cottage comfortably accommodates up to 8 guests and features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Enjoy the well-equipped kitchen, living and dining areas, washer and dryer, dishwasher, central heat and air conditioning, cable/satellite television, DVD players, high-speed internet service, and an outdoor gas or charcoal grill.

This Grand Beach vacation home is centrally located, a short drive from New Buffalo and conveniently close to Lake Michigan, offering easy access to Indiana Dunes National Park and other local attractions.
This 1,600-square-foot, three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps six guests and features a great room with a wood-burning fireplace, a high-end kitchen with a large granite island and wine fridge, a six-person hot tub, and a private fire pit.

This charming cottage is located on a lake, just a mile from Lyon Oaks Golf Course and Lake Michigan, with Michiana Beach and Duneland Beach also within a mile. The cottage consistently receives excellent ratings from guests, making it a popular choice for families and groups.
This five-bedroom cottage comfortably sleeps up to eight guests. The cottage provides a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a garden, and a terrace, as well as free Wi-Fi and air conditioning.

This waterfront cottage in Union Pier is a 10-minute walk from Burnison Galleries and 2 miles from Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room. It's an excellent choice for travelers looking for a relaxing getaway with stunning views of Lake Michigan.
The cottage has two bedrooms, one bathroom, and can accommodate up to four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a cozy dining area with a TV, a private garden with barbecue grills, air conditioning, a terrace or balcony, a spa, and parking. The cottage is also pet-friendly and smoke-free.

This Union Pier cottage is located in a wooded area, a short 1500 feet walk to Lake Michigan road-end beaches, and close to cultural sites like Burnison Galleries and Vickers Theatre.
This 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom vacation home accommodates up to 12 guests and features a Jacuzzi, air conditioning, and a full kitchen, with nearby attractions including Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room and Hesston Steam Museum.

This 1940s Michiana Shores cottage, a short walk from Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Park, offers a serene wooded setting with lake views.
The 900-square-foot house features two bedrooms, one bathroom, and accommodates up to five guests, complete with a knotty pine interior, fieldstone fireplace, screened patio, backyard fire pit, and a fully equipped kitchen including a washer/dryer and central air conditioning.

This Grand Beach vacation home is located less than a mile from Lake Michigan, a five-minute drive from downtown New Buffalo, and near Indiana Dunes National Park and Warren Dunes State Park.
This pet-friendly 1,500-square-foot house features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps four, and includes a full kitchen with dishwasher, air conditioning, a terrace, and access to nearby tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts.

This charming cottage is located just ten minutes from Michigan City, close to the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and its stunning natural beauty. The cottage has received excellent ratings from previous guests.
The cottage has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy the private beach access, relax on the deck, grill outdoors, and gather around the fire pit in the evenings.

This Union Pier rental cottage is located a two-minute walk from two Lake Michigan beach access points and within walking distance of Whistle Stop, Red Arrow Roadhouse, Union Social, Blackcurrant Bakehouse, and Barndog.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage accommodates up to four guests and includes internet, air conditioning, a charcoal grill, and a washer/dryer, with the option to rent all three cottages for a total of 13 guests.