Compare best cottages in New Buffalo, MI from 100+ sites!

This Michigan City vacation home is conveniently located within a 10-minute walk of Lake Michigan, Washington Park, and Canada Park, with Stop 2 Beach and Washington Park Beach a short 15-minute walk away.
This pet-friendly, family-friendly two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage sleeps seven, features a fully equipped kitchen, smart TV, air conditioning, on-site barbecue grills, and is a 23-minute walk from Michigan City Station.

This charming cottage is located in Three Oaks, just a short walk from the town center and close to the beautiful beaches of Lake Michigan. The cottage has consistently earned excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This cozy retreat can comfortably accommodate up to six guests in its two bedrooms and one bathroom. Enjoy the fully equipped kitchen, outdoor dining area, and the private fenced-in yard, perfect for relaxing evenings or entertaining friends and family.

This charming cottage is located in Michiana Shores, just a short walk from the beautiful Lake Michigan beach and close to a variety of amenities, including a park, golf course, and horseback riding stables. The cottage has received excellent reviews from previous guests.
The cottage has two bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 10 guests. Enjoy modern comforts like air conditioning, a fully equipped kitchen, a fire pit, a fireplace, and an outdoor shower.

This charming cottage is located just one block from the sandy beaches of Lake Michigan in Union Pier, offering easy access to the water and nearby Warren Dunes State Park. The cottage has consistently received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for families and groups.
The 1640 square foot cottage comfortably sleeps eight guests in its three bedrooms and two bathrooms. Enjoy a spacious backyard with a fire pit, a well-equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and a mudroom with a washer and dryer.

This charming cottage is located just a mile from Burnison Galleries and Lake Michigan, offering a peaceful retreat near the beautiful shores of Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert. It has consistently received excellent ratings from previous guests, highlighting its comfortable and convenient amenities. This vacation home spans 2,000 square feet and comfortably accommodates up to 8 guests in its four bedrooms. The cottage is fully equipped with modern amenities, including a private fenced yard, a cozy fireplace, and a spacious patio perfect for relaxing and enjoying the outdoors.

This family-friendly cottage is located just a mile from Burnison Galleries and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to the beautiful beaches of Union Pier and Gordon. The cottage has received excellent user ratings, indicating a comfortable and enjoyable stay for guests.
The 2-bedroom cottage can accommodate up to 4 guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a private fenced yard, a terrace, a spa, and free Wi-Fi. Guests can enjoy lakefront views, relax in the spa, or grill outdoors in the private yard.

This charming cottage is located in the Union Pier district of New Buffalo, just a short walk from the public beach access at Townline Beach. It has consistently received excellent ratings for cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The cottage offers a spacious bedroom with a king-size bed, perfect for a comfortable stay for up to four guests. Enjoy the cozy atmosphere with two wood fireplaces, a vaulted pine ceiling, skylights, and a sunroom, along with amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden, and a deck with a gas grill.

This charming cottage is located in Union Pier, just a short distance from both Townline Beach and Lake Michigan, providing easy access to the area's natural beauty and attractions. The cottage consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall guest experience.
The cottage offers 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms in a spacious 1280 square feet, comfortably accommodating up to 6 guests. Enjoy a relaxing stay with amenities like a jacuzzi, a fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, and a balcony for outdoor enjoyment.

This Sawyer, Michigan cottage is located 3 miles from Lake Michigan and Warren Dunes State Park, providing easy access to beaches and hiking trails.
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom vacation home sleeps eight guests and features a kitchen with a refrigerator and microwave, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, and a garden.

This charming cottage is located just a short walk from the beach in Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert, close to Burnison Galleries and within easy reach of Union Pier Beach and Gordon Beach. Guests consistently rate this property excellent for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This four-bedroom vacation home, spanning 1580 square feet, comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Enjoy a relaxing stay with amenities like a Jacuzzi, fireplace, barbecue grill, and a fully equipped kitchen.

Copper Top Ridge, a secluded New Buffalo, Michigan cottage on a private ridge, is minutes from downtown, beaches, and wineries.
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps eight, boasting a solar-powered design, private hot tub, fire pit, fully equipped kitchen, high-speed WiFi, and eBike rentals for exploring nearby state parks and attractions.

This charming cottage is situated in Union Pier, a short walk from Union Pier Beach and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to the area's beautiful beaches and scenic lakefront. The cottage boasts excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
The 1030 square foot cottage comfortably accommodates up to six guests in its three bedrooms and two bathrooms. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, private spa tub, fireplace, outdoor grilling area, and access to the internet.

This 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom cottage near Lake Michigan in Grand Beach is located on a quiet, dead-end street, offering easy access to community beaches, a park, and sports courts within walking distance, and is also a short drive to the Indiana Dunes National Park.
This dog-friendly vacation home accommodates up to 11 guests and features a screened porch, air conditioning, internet, and a full kitchen, with nearby attractions including a golf course, breweries, dispensaries, wineries, casinos, and theme parks.

This Grand Beach vacation home is located less than a mile from Lake Michigan, a five-minute drive from downtown New Buffalo, and near Indiana Dunes National Park and Warren Dunes State Park.
This pet-friendly 1,500-square-foot house features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps four, and includes a full kitchen with dishwasher, air conditioning, a terrace, and access to nearby tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts.

This 1940s Michiana Shores cottage, a short walk from Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Park, offers a serene wooded setting with lake views.
The 900-square-foot house features two bedrooms, one bathroom, and accommodates up to five guests, complete with a knotty pine interior, fieldstone fireplace, screened patio, backyard fire pit, and a fully equipped kitchen including a washer/dryer and central air conditioning.

This Union Pier cottage is a two-minute walk to two Lake Michigan public beaches and within walking distance of local eateries and shops including Whistle Stop, Red Arrow Roadhouse, and Blackcurrant Bakehouse.
This pet-friendly, two-bedroom, one-bathroom dwelling accommodates up to four guests and features internet, air conditioning, a full kitchen, and a shared outdoor grilling area, with the option to rent all three cottages on the property for larger groups.