Compare best cottages in Kelleys Island, OH from 100+ sites!

12 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Kelleys Island, OH cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

12 Best cottages in Kelleys Island, OH

Best family friendly Kelleys Island, OH cottages

Among the 10 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 3 best family friendly cottages

Lovely Lakeside Chautauqua Cottage Rental - Kelleys Island, OH
10 35 reviews

Lovely Lakeside Chautauqua Cottage Rental

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside, Ohio cottage, located three miles from Marblehead Lighthouse State Park and six miles from Caddy Shack Square, offers easy access to Lake Erie's shores.
The 1230-square-foot vacation home features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps ten guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, swimming pool, fitness center, tennis court, and a private garden.
Cottage Custom Built By Owner Plus 4 Person Golf Cart Included - Kelleys Island, OH
9.6 101 reviews

Cottage Custom Built By Owner Plus 4 Person Golf Cart Included

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside cottage is located in Marblehead, just a short walk from the tennis complex, the new pool complex, and the pickleball courts. It has received excellent user ratings.
This spacious vacation rental has 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and sleeps up to 12 guests. It offers a fully equipped kitchen, a private pool, a spa, and a golf cart for easy access to Lakeside's many amenities and activities.
Cheeky Cherry Cottage - Kelleys Island, OH
9.8 25 reviews

Cheeky Cherry Cottage

cottage, Lakeside
Located in the Lakeside Chautauqua community, directly across from Cherry Park, the Cheeky Cherry Cottage offers a unique Lakeside experience. With an excellent user rating, this historic cottage sleeps six and features modern amenities such as central air, new appliances, high-speed Wi-Fi, and a smart TV.
The cottage offers a queen bed, adult-size bunk beds, and a daybed with a trundle. Guests can enjoy the community's daily programming, nightly entertainment, and the historic Hoover Auditorium. The cottage also features a back deck with seating and a charcoal grill, and ample parking across the street.

Best Kelleys Island, OH cottages with a garden

660 Walnut Cottage In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
10 1 review

660 Walnut Cottage In Lakeside

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside Chautauqua cottage rental in Marblehead, Ohio, is a short drive from Lake Erie and popular attractions like Cedar Point and Sports Force Parks.
The 2200-square-foot house features four bedrooms, two bathrooms, and accommodates up to ten guests, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, in-ground swimming pool, and private parking.
Modern A-frame + Backyard + Firepit + Bbq - Kelleys Island, OH
10 13 reviews

Modern A-frame + Backyard + Firepit + Bbq

cottage, Kelleys Island
This Kelleys Island cottage, a short walk from Lake Erie, provides easy access to Kelleys Island's natural beauty and attractions like Catawba Island State Park.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom vacation home sleeps seven, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, air conditioning, a terrace, and a garden with barbecue grills; nearby family-friendly options include The Watering Hole Safari and Waterpark.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Kelleys Island, OH

  • What are the top must-see attractions on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island boasts some fantastic attractions! For natural beauty, Glacial Grooves are a must-see; these ancient carvings are truly impressive. The Kelleys Island State Park offers stunning Lake Erie views and hiking trails. Don't miss the chance to visit the Kelleys Island Lighthouse, a historic landmark with a rich history. Finally, a trip to the International Dark-Sky Park is a must for stargazing.
  • What are the best cottages in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • How to spend a 5-day holiday on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Five days on Kelleys Island gives you plenty of time! Day one could be exploring the Glacial Grooves and the state park. Day two, take a ferry to Put-in-Bay and explore South Bass Island. Day three, relax on the beach, rent bikes and explore the island's quieter roads, and visit the lighthouse. Day four, dedicate to kayaking or boating around the island's shoreline, maybe even try fishing. On the fifth day, enjoy a leisurely morning, revisit your favorite spot, and catch the ferry back.
  • What are the best cottages with a pool in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • Is Kelleys Island, Ohio a good destination to rent a cottage?

    Absolutely! Kelleys Island has many charming cottages available for rent, offering a peaceful and relaxing getaway. Many are located near the waterfront or within walking distance of amenities. Booking in advance, especially during peak season, is recommended.
  • What are the best cottages with a jacuzzi in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • What weather, wildlife, or natural hazards might affect travelers on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Lake Erie's weather can be unpredictable. Pack layers as temperatures can change quickly. Be aware of strong winds, especially near the lake. You might encounter various bird species, and deer are common. Be mindful of the water's temperature and currents if swimming or boating. Check the forecast before heading out.
  • What are the best cottages for families and kids in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • Is Kelleys Island, Ohio pedestrian and cyclist-friendly?

    Kelleys Island is quite pedestrian and cyclist-friendly. The island is relatively small, and many areas are easily walkable or bikeable. There are paved roads and paths suitable for both walking and cycling. However, be aware of vehicle traffic, especially during peak season.
  • What are the best pet friendly cottages in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • Are there any unusual or hidden places to explore on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    While not exactly hidden, exploring the less-traveled trails within Kelleys Island State Park can lead to some secluded and peaceful spots. The northernmost tip of the island offers beautiful, quieter views of Lake Erie. Checking out some of the less-frequented beaches can also be rewarding.
  • What are the best cottages with parking in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • What are some of the best cultural experiences that allow you to meet locals on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    The best way to meet locals is often by striking up conversations at the local businesses. The general store and restaurants are great places to chat with residents. Attending any community events or festivals, if scheduled, provides another opportunity to interact with the locals. The island's small size fosters a friendly atmosphere.
  • What are the best authentic dishes to taste on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island doesn't have a unique, signature dish, but many restaurants offer fresh seafood dishes featuring Lake Erie perch or walleye. Many establishments also serve classic American fare, such as burgers and sandwiches, using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Check out the local restaurants' menus for seasonal options.
  • Are there any recommended items to pack for a stay on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Pack comfortable walking shoes, as you'll likely be doing a lot of walking. Bring layers of clothing, as the weather can change. Sunscreen, insect repellent, and a hat are essential, especially during the warmer months. Don't forget swimwear if you plan on swimming in Lake Erie. A camera is a must to capture the beautiful scenery.

Nearby regions

Best Kelleys Island, OH cottages with jacuzzi

Among the 10 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 1 best cottages with a jacuzzi

645 Sycamore In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
10 1 review

645 Sycamore In Lakeside

cottage, Lakeside
KEPT Cottage, located in Lakeside Chautauqua, Ohio, offers easy access to the pool and pickleball courts.
This Lakeside rental boasts 2,550 square feet, seven bedrooms, four bathrooms, and can comfortably accommodate up to 22 guests, featuring two kitchens, two laundry rooms, a large porch, and parking for four cars.

Neighborhoods and points of interest in Kelleys Island, OH

Best pet friendly Kelleys Island, OH cottages

Among the 10 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 1 best pet friendly cottages

443 Lynn Avenue Charming Two Bedroom In Lakeside! - Kelleys Island, OH
8.4 5 reviews

443 Lynn Avenue Charming Two Bedroom In Lakeside!

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside, Ohio cottage near the 5th Avenue gate offers easy walking access to Lake Erie's scenic walkway and the Erie Food Market.
This 600-square-foot vacation home features two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a swimming pool, and a screened-in porch with a grill.
©2026 cozycozy.com