Search vacation rental in Buckeye Lake, OH from 100+ sites!
76 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Buckeye Lake, OH
10 3 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/26 – 06/28
$298/nighttotal: $596 (2 )
New Listing The Float House At Buckeye Lake
2 4
house , Fairfield Beach
This Thornville rental, known as 'The Float House', is a waterfront house located 20 miles from the Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum and 29 miles from John Glenn Columbus International Airport. This 900 square foot house offers a private balcony, a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, internet, and parking for up to 11 guests, with a check-out time of 11:00 AM.
10 18 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$607/nighttotal: $3642 (6 )
The View At Buckeye Lake - The Ultimate Lakefront Retreat For 12.
5 10
apartment , Harbor Hills
This five-bedroom Harbor Hills vacation home is located in Thornville, Ohio, approximately 3 miles from Bope, Sherman, and Peterson Islands, and 2.8 miles from Hickory Island. This 3,600-square-foot residence boasts a fully equipped kitchen, a Jacuzzi, a private balcony, and can comfortably accommodate up to 12 guests, offering free Wi-Fi and concierge services.
9.7 104 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
07/24 – 07/26
$306/nighttotal: $612 (2 )
Cheerful 3-bed Vacay Home W/free Car &Boat Parking
3 4
apartment , Buckeye Lake
The Buckeye Bungalow is a duplex located near Buckeye Lake, just a short walk from the lake's edge. This rental has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The home is a spacious three-bedroom duplex that can comfortably accommodate up to six guests. The bungalow features modern amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and access to a private garden, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable vacation.
9.7 41 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/26 – 06/28
$285/nighttotal: $570 (2 )
Gone Fishin'
1 4
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This charming cottage is located in Cranberry Bay, just under a mile from the Buckeye Lake boat launch and within walking distance of the town center. The cottage is newly remodeled, offering a modern and fresh experience with all new interiors and exteriors. The home features a spacious open floor plan, perfect for families or groups of friends, with a capacity of 6 guests. The cottage offers a fully equipped kitchen, comfortable memory foam mattresses, smart TVs, a private garden, and parking, making it a perfect base for exploring Buckeye Lake.
Buckeye Lake, OH
09/18 – 09/19
$172/nightfor 1 night
Lost Lands Camping #31
1 4
apartment , Harbor Hills
This apartment is located near Legend Valley, less than a mile from the concert venue, in a wide open area with scenic views. It's perfect for travelers looking to enjoy the convenience of being close to the action while still having access to the natural beauty of Harbor Hills. This rental offers a comfortable and convenient stay for up to four guests. It includes amenities like a bathroom and access to a wide open area perfect for camping. Enjoy the tranquility of the surrounding landscape, explore the area, and take advantage of the all-inclusive package, which includes transportation.
10 2 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/23 – 06/24
$384/nightfor 1 night
King Bed • Firepit • Buckeye Lake • Hebron 18 Mins
1 2
apartment , Fairfield Beach
This apartment offers a private duplex setting in the Buckeye Lake area, providing a convenient getaway approximately 1 mile from Buckeye Lake. This two-bedroom, one-bathroom condo accommodates up to six guests and features a fully stocked kitchen, air conditioning, parking, and internet, with a king suite and a queen over queen bunk room.
Buckeye Lake, OH
09/18 – 09/19
$172/nightfor 1 night
Lost Lands Camping #4
1 4
apartment , Harbor Hills
This apartment in Harbor Hills is located less than a mile from Legend Valley music venue, offering unbeatable proximity for concertgoers. This accommodation can host up to 4 guests and includes a spacious camping area with scenic views, transportation, and bathroom facilities for an all-inclusive stay.
9.8 7 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/17 – 10/19
$327/nighttotal: $654 (2 )
Cottage @ Buckeye Lake W/ Huge Private Fenced Yard
2 5
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This Buckeye Lake vacation rental is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom house located within a 15-minute walk of Buckeye Lake Brewery, Crane Island, and the Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, with Watkins Island and Evans Park less than 3 miles away. This pet-friendly home sleeps six, features on-site laundry, air conditioning, internet access, and offers easy access to Buckeye Lake's attractions.
9.7 48 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
07/24 – 07/26
$389/nighttotal: $778 (2 )
Shoreline Shadows Buckeye Lake|hot Tub
3 4
cabin , Fairfield Beach
This cozy cottage sits just a 2-minute walk from the Buckeye Lake shoreline in Fairfield Beach, offering a peaceful retreat with stunning water views. Guests consistently rate this property excellent for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The cottage features 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to 6 guests. Guests can enjoy modern amenities like high-speed Wi-Fi, a smart TV, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for preparing meals. The large wraparound porch provides a relaxing space to enjoy the outdoors, while the cabin's proximity to various activities like boat rentals, live music venues, and hiking trails ensures plenty of entertainment options.
9.9 31 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
07/08 – 07/10
$419/nighttotal: $838 (2 )
New Build | Spacious | Hot Tub | 2 Blocks To Lake
1 2
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This brand-new Buckeye Lake Village house rental is steps from Buckeye Lake and a short walk to Buckeye Lake State Park's boat ramp and beach. The three-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps ten guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, dedicated laundry room, and open-concept living area perfect for entertaining, offering easy access to local restaurants and attractions.
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$695/nighttotal: $4170 (6 )
Colonial On Crane
4 10
house , Buckeye Lake
This Colonial home in Buckeye Lake is an 8-minute walk to Crystal Beach and 19 miles from the Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum. This 2690 square foot vacation rental sleeps 31 guests and features 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a hot tub, a pool table, and a garden, with local activities like golfing and fishing nearby.
9.8 39 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/23 – 06/24
$297/nightfor 1 night
Perfect Location! Lilypad B.
1 2
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This three-bedroom, one-bathroom Buckeye Lake apartment is located directly on the Buckeye Lake bike path, a short walk from restaurants, bars, and the lake itself. Sleeping nine, this triplex unit features a dishwasher, air conditioning, parking, and internet access; additional units are available for larger groups.
Best family friendly Buckeye Lake, OH vacation rentals
Among the 76 accommodations in Buckeye Lake, OH, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals
10 5 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
07/08 – 07/10
$226/nighttotal: $452 (2 )
Cruise Buckeye Lake In A 6-seater Golf Cart & Unwind By The Fire Pit
4 2
cottage , Buckeye Lake
This Buckeye Lake cottage, near Crane Island and Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, offers easy access to Watkins Island and Evans Park within a 3-mile radius and Buckeye Lake Brewery within a 15-minute walk. This 1,330-square-foot lakeside home features four bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six, includes a fully equipped kitchen, and boasts an on-site arcade/game room.
9.8 42 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/17 – 10/19
$426/nighttotal: $852 (2 )
Island Vibes| Hot Tub|short Walk To Buckeye Lake
3 5
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This lakefront Buckeye Lake vacation home is a 10-minute walk from Crane Island and the Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, and within 3 miles of Watkins Island and Evans Park. This 1,100-square-foot house features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps eight, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, and in-house laundry facilities.
9.9 37 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/17 – 10/19
$293/nighttotal: $586 (2 )
Cozy Lake Cottage W/ Golf Cart Near North Shore
1 5
apartment , Buckeye Lake
The Buckeye Cottage is located in Buckeye Lake, Ohio, offering easy access to the lake and nearby attractions. This three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps seven guests comfortably, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, a six-person golf cart, outdoor amenities like a fire pit and cornhole, and smart TVs in the master and guest bedrooms.
9.6 9 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$406/nighttotal: $2436 (6 )
Buckeye Lake: Chicks On Canal
5 10
apartment , Millersport
This apartment is situated directly across from Buckeye Lake Marina in Millersport, offering easy access to the lake's activities and within a short drive to Buckeye Lake Winery and Harbor Hills Country Club. It has received "very good" user ratings for its comfortable accommodations and convenient location. This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 16 guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious living room, and a cozy backyard. Enjoy the lakefront views, relax in the hot tub, play a game of pool or air hockey, and take advantage of the outdoor space with a garden, tennis court, and parking.
Best Buckeye Lake, OH vacation rentals with a pool
Among the 76 accommodations in Buckeye Lake, OH, here are the 3 best rentals with a pool
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/26 – 06/28
$2048/nighttotal: $4096 (2 )
Lakeside Pool Retreat
1 4
apartment , Thornport
This lakefront condo in Thornport's Lakeside district offers direct water access and is near local boating facilities. This vacation rental sleeps 10 guests with 3 king bedrooms, a bunk room, and a queen sofa sleeper, featuring a heated inground pool, hot tub, private boathouse, and paddle boards/kayaks.
10 5 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
09/12 – 09/13
$2670/nightfor 1 night
Buckeye Lake Hill House
1 10
apartment , Harbor Hills
This Buckeye Lake Hill House rental is located in the Harbor Hills area on the shores of Buckeye Lake, offering direct access to lake activities. The 6-bedroom, 4-bathroom house sleeps 15 guests and features a pool, hot tub, shuffleboard, ping pong, and firepit, perfect for family reunions or corporate retreats.
9.9 58 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/23 – 06/24
$656/nightfor 1 night
The Shome 2 | Country Family Stay • Sleeps 16
1 2
apartment , Thornville
This spacious Thornville barndominium, opening June 1st, 2025, offers a five-acre private setting a short drive from unspecified local attractions; consider referencing the similar "Shome One" design. The 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house comfortably sleeps 16 guests and features an inground heated pool, hot tub, outdoor grilling area, and two master suites with private decks and pool views.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Buckeye Lake, OH
What essentials should you bring along for a trip to Buckeye Lake, Ohio?
Sunscreen is a must, especially in the summer. Comfortable walking shoes are good for exploring the area. Swimsuits are essential if you plan on enjoying the lake. Don't forget insect repellent, especially near the water's edge.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Buckeye Lake, OH?
What famous events or festivals are happening in Buckeye Lake, Ohio?
The Buckeye Lake Region Chamber of Commerce often hosts events throughout the year. Check their website for specific dates and details. There are often smaller, local festivals and events, but large, nationally known events are less common.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Buckeye Lake, OH?
What is the average daily budget you should plan for (accommodation, food, transportation, activities) in Buckeye Lake, Ohio?
A daily budget of $150-$300 per person should cover most expenses, depending on your accommodation choices and dining preferences. Gas prices for transportation should be factored in if you're driving. Activities range in price.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Buckeye Lake, OH?
Where can you find the best restaurants serving local dishes in Buckeye Lake, Ohio, and what are the must-try specialties?
There are several restaurants around Buckeye Lake. The local favorites tend to be seafood restaurants, offering dishes featuring fish from the lake. It's always best to check recent reviews to find places that are currently open and well-regarded.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Buckeye Lake, OH?
What are some less-famous attractions in Buckeye Lake, Ohio that are worth the visit?
The smaller marinas around the lake offer a glimpse into local life. Exploring the backroads and finding hidden coves on the lake can be rewarding. Many of the older homes around the lake have interesting architectural details.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Buckeye Lake, OH?
What are the best activities for engaging with locals and understanding their culture in the Buckeye Lake, Ohio area?
Visiting the local shops and restaurants is a good way to meet people. Attending any local events or festivals will also give you a chance to interact with residents. Striking up conversations with people at the marinas or on the lake is another option.
What unique natural landscapes and terrain features can travelers explore in and around Buckeye Lake, Ohio?
Buckeye Lake itself is a significant feature, with its shoreline and surrounding hills. The area is relatively flat, but there are some wooded areas and small hills offering hiking opportunities.
How many days are ideal for a trip to Buckeye Lake, Ohio, and what are some itinerary suggestions?
A long weekend (3 days/2 nights) is a good amount of time to explore the lake and its surroundings. A possible itinerary could include a boat tour, visiting the Buckeye Lake Museum, exploring local restaurants, and relaxing by the lake.
How is the weather in Buckeye Lake, Ohio in high season?
High season is summer, with hot and humid weather. Expect temperatures in the 80s and 90s Fahrenheit (high 20s to low 30s Celsius). There's also a chance of thunderstorms, so it's good to check the forecast.
Nearby regions
Best Buckeye Lake, OH vacation rentals with a balcony
10 12 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/17 – 10/19
$501/nighttotal: $1002 (2 )
The Beacon|water Views|hot Tub|free Bikes
3 5
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This Cranberry Bay apartment rental offers a prime Buckeye Lake location, steps from the Boat Yard, bike path, and restaurants like Chef Shack & Brewery and Boatyard. The 1800-square-foot, four-bedroom, three-bathroom dwelling comfortably sleeps eight guests and boasts a wrap-around deck with a grill and fire pit, a new garage, and first-floor laundry.
10 13 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/17 – 10/19
$591/nighttotal: $1182 (2 )
New Build 2024 | Spacious | Hot Tub | Pet-friendly
3 5
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This brand-new Buckeye Lake Village apartment is steps from Buckeye Lake's boat ramp, beach, and Buckeye Lake State Park. The 2100-square-foot rental boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps ten, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, and a terrace.
9.6 219 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
06/23 – 06/24
$199/nightfor 1 night
House With Fenced Yard And Easy Access To I-70
2 2
apartment , Heath
This charming 2-bedroom house is located just 1.1 miles from Heath City Water Park and within a 6-mile radius of several historical landmarks, including Newark Earthworks. It offers a peaceful lakeside setting, perfect for families or groups of friends seeking a relaxing getaway. The house consistently receives excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The 1100-square-foot vacation home comfortably accommodates up to 4 guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private fenced yard, a terrace or balcony, and free Wi-Fi, along with convenient amenities like air conditioning, parking, and an outdoor grill.
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$822/nighttotal: $4932 (6 )
Simple & Spacious | Sleeps 18 | King | Ev | Lake
3 10
apartment , Fairfield Beach
This waterfront vacation home in Thornville offers direct Buckeye Lake access, situated near Buckeye Lake State Park and Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve. This 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom apartment accommodates up to 18 guests and features a fully stocked kitchen, 10 Smart TVs with Roku, and multiple bunk bed configurations, ideal for large families and groups seeking water activities and entertainment.
Best Buckeye Lake, OH vacation rentals with parking
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$805/nighttotal: $4830 (6 )
Family Home On 9 Acres! Climbing Wall & Gym
5 10
house , Thornville
This secluded 9-acre family home is situated 20 miles from the Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum in Thornville and 28 miles from Rickenbacker International Airport. This expansive 4900 square foot estate accommodates up to 23 guests with 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, on-site climbing wall, and a dedicated fitness center.
Buckeye Lake, OH
07/24 – 07/26
$695/nighttotal: $1390 (2 )
Modern Lake House 3 Blocks From The Lake!
4 4
house , Buckeye Lake
The Lakeshore Haus, a Buckeye Lake house rental near Crystal Beach, is an 11-minute walk from the beach and approximately 19 miles from the Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum. This recently renovated 1,500-square-foot home features one bedroom, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a jacuzzi, complimentary Wi-Fi, on-site parking, and accommodates up to 27 guests.
10 77 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$823/nighttotal: $4938 (6 )
Amazing Buckeye Lake Getaway! Premium Location!
4 10
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This family-friendly vacation home is located in Millersport, just a short drive from Buckeye Lake Brewery, Licking Memorial Family, and Buckeye Lake State Park. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house comfortably accommodates up to 12 guests in its 3600 square feet of space. Enjoy direct lake access, a spa tub, a game room, a barbecue grill, and a fully equipped kitchen with modern appliances.
10 2 reviews
Buckeye Lake, OH
10/03 – 10/09
$750/nighttotal: $4500 (6 )
Waterfront In Buckeye Lake: The Lakehouse
5 10
apartment , Buckeye Lake
This waterfront vacation rental in Buckeye Lake is located less than a mile from Crystal Beach and the Boat Launch, and within walking distance of local restaurants and bars. This spacious house accommodates up to 16 guests across three floors and features a lakefront location with two boat docks, three decks, a hot tub, a wood-burning fire pit, a third-floor party space with a bar and pool table, and is near Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve and Buckeye Lake State Park.