Places to stay in Fire Island, NY

1296 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • hotelscom
  • vrbo
  • tripadvisor
  • expedia
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Fire Island, NY place to stay
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

1296 Best places to stay in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY lodgings with a pool

Among the 1296 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 2 best ones with a pool

Beachside Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.4 35 reviews

Beachside Retreat

apartment, Shirley
This two-bedroom Shirley beach cottage is a short walk from Shirley Beach and a short drive from Smith Point Beach and Fire Island National Seashore.
The property sleeps five guests and offers amenities including Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a swimming pool, parking, and a kitchen; enjoy nearby beach activities and explore the natural beauty of Fire Island National Seashore.
Renovated House With An Entertainment Backyard - Fire Island, NY
9.9 16 reviews

Renovated House With An Entertainment Backyard

apartment, North Great River
This spacious apartment is located in North Great River, just 10km from Connetquot River State Park Preserve, 8.4km from Heckscher State Park, and 7.7km from East Islip Marina. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment can accommodate up to six guests. It offers a range of amenities, including a private heated swimming pool, a sauna, and a spacious family-friendly backyard with a trampoline and playground.

Best family friendly Fire Island, NY lodging

Among the 1296 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best for families

Tranquil Stay. - Fire Island, NY
9.7 98 reviews

Tranquil Stay.

apartment, Mastic Beach
This charming bungalow is situated in a peaceful neighbourhood in Mastic Beach, just a short drive from the beach and local amenities. It consistently receives excellent ratings for cleanliness, location, and overall user experience.
The bungalow features three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. It boasts a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious living area with a flat-screen TV, a private patio with outdoor seating, and modern amenities such as Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a washer and dryer.
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

house, Fire Island
This spacious air-conditioned holiday home is located in a quiet district of Fire Island, offering garden views from its terrace and easy access to the beach, just 100 meters away.
This 158 square meter property accommodates up to 19 guests with 2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, a private terrace, and a balcony.
Stay Downtown & Walk To Fire Island Ferries - Fire Island, NY
9.9 127 reviews

Stay Downtown & Walk To Fire Island Ferries

apartment, Bay Shore
This ground-floor flat is situated in Bay Shore's historic Bay District, a short walk from restaurants, a spray park, the beach, the Bay Shore Ferry, and approximately 1.6km from the Long Island Rail Road station.
The self-catering apartment, sleeping two guests, offers a living room, bedroom, bathroom with bath/shower, and kitchen with fridge, freezer, and microwave; private parking, garden access, and air conditioning are also included.
Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr-str - Fire Island, NY
9.7 407 reviews

Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr-str

apartment, North Bay Shore
This apartment is conveniently located in North Bay Shore, just a short distance from Brentwood State Park and within easy reach of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a comfortable living space with a dining area and a TV for entertainment. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and a fireplace, as well as a fully equipped kitchenette, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the most convenient modes of transportation within Fire Island, NY?

    The easiest way to get around is by foot or by bike. You can also take the ferry to different communities along the island. The Fire Island Ferry is the main mode of transport and runs regularly between the mainland and the island. You can also find taxis and golf carts in some areas, but they are not as common as other modes of transport.
  • What are the best accommodations in Fire Island, NY?

    Among the accommodations in Fire Island, NY, Cozy And Clean Private Bedroom, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the most popular ones.

  • What outdoor activities and adventures are popular in and around Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a great place for swimming, sunbathing, and surfing. You can also go kayaking, paddleboarding, or fishing. The island is also home to many hiking trails, including the Fire Island National Seashore Trail, which runs for 32 km.
  • What are the best accommodations with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

    My Happy Place, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg and Hampton Inn Long Island/commack are the best accommodations with a pool in Fire Island, NY.

  • What types of accommodations are available in Fire Island, NY?

    You can find a variety of accommodation options on Fire Island, including hotels, motels, guesthouses, and private rentals. There are also many campgrounds available for those who prefer to stay in the great outdoors. The majority of accommodation is in the form of private homes and rentals.
  • What are the best accommodations with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to visit Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to visit Fire Island is during the summer months, from June to August. The weather is warm and sunny, and the beaches are packed with people. If you prefer a quieter experience, you can visit in the spring or fall.
  • What are the best accommodations for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

    The best accommodations for families and kids in Fire Island, NY are Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville, Hampton Inn Long Island-brookhaven and Hilton Garden Inn Islip/macarthur Airport.

  • What local dishes and culinary experiences are a must-try in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its fresh seafood. The local restaurants serve up delicious dishes like lobster rolls, clam chowder, and grilled fish. You can also find plenty of casual eateries serving up burgers, pizza, and ice cream.
  • What are the best pet friendly accommodations in Fire Island, NY?

  • In which part of Fire Island, NY should you consider renting accommodation?

    The best place to stay depends on your preferences. The Pines is a popular destination for its lively nightlife and gay-friendly atmosphere. Ocean Beach is a more family-friendly option, with a quieter atmosphere and a wide beach. You can also find accommodation in other communities, such as Cherry Grove, Kismet, and Seaview.
  • What are the best accommodations with parking in Fire Island, NY?

    Cozy And Clean Private Bedroom, My Happy Place and Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg are the best accommodations with parking in Fire Island, NY.

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a balcony

Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr-str - Fire Island, NY
9.7 407 reviews

Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr-str

apartment, North Bay Shore
This apartment is conveniently located in North Bay Shore, just a short distance from Brentwood State Park and within easy reach of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a comfortable living space with a dining area and a TV for entertainment. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and a fireplace, as well as a fully equipped kitchenette, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

house, Fire Island
This spacious air-conditioned holiday home is located in a quiet district of Fire Island, offering garden views from its terrace and easy access to the beach, just 100 meters away.
This 158 square meter property accommodates up to 19 guests with 2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, a private terrace, and a balcony.

Best Fire Island, NY accommodations with a kitchen

Sleepy Hollow - Fire Island, NY
10 24 reviews

Sleepy Hollow

resort, Blue Point
This Blue Point apartment, perfect for a peaceful getaway, is conveniently located within the town – precise distances to local landmarks are unavailable.
The self-contained flat offers one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeps three guests, and includes parking, internet, and air conditioning.
Waterfront Cottage With Access To The Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 88 reviews

Waterfront Cottage With Access To The Bay

apartment, Mastic Beach
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home is situated near Mastic Beach, New York, approximately 16km from Smith Point County Park and Fire Island.
The self-catering property sleeps four guests and boasts a private deck, kayak access to the South Bay, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, air conditioning, and a fitness centre, making it ideal for a relaxing getaway.
Large 1 Bedroom Apartment - Fire Island, NY
9.7 165 reviews

Large 1 Bedroom Apartment

apartment, North Great River
This ground-floor flat in North Great River offers convenient access to local attractions; precise distances require further information.
The self-contained apartment features a queen-size bed, full kitchen, two TVs, private parking, and accommodates up to four guests, with access to a backyard (excluding the pool).
Private Garden Suite In Bayshore - Fire Island, NY
9.8 7 reviews

Private Garden Suite In Bayshore

apartment, West Islip
This West Islip flat is situated in a convenient district, offering straightforward access to local amenities and attractions.
This one-bedroom flat accommodates up to three guests and features complimentary high-speed WiFi, private parking, and a fully equipped kitchenette.
©2026 cozycozy.com