Places to stay in Fire Island, NY

This 5-bedroom house in Bay Shore is located near cultural attractions such as the YMCA Boulton Centre for the Performing Arts and the Bay Shore Historical Society, offering convenient access to local activities including Bay Shore Mini Golf and Fair Harbour Ferry Terminal.
This spacious property accommodates up to 12 guests with three bathrooms, air conditioning, heating, and an on-site fitness room, while nearby attractions like Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park provide further recreational opportunities.

This Shirley, Long Island property boasts a stunning waterfront location on Bellport Bay, a short 8km drive from Smith Point County Park and within 16km of the Mastic–Shirley train station, offering easy access to New York City and Montauk.
The three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps five guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, parking, and direct water access for boating and other water sports; nearby attractions include the William Floyd Estate and Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge.

This brand-new three-bedroom Fire Island Pines residence, situated on Fire Island Boulevard, is just a short stroll (less than 0.2 km) from the beach.
The 3-bathroom property boasts an open-plan design, a private pool, three levels of decking including a rooftop terrace with bay views, and comfortably accommodates eight guests with amenities including a chef's kitchen and fast Wi-Fi.

Enjoy the '24-d Glamping - Fire Island - Watch Hill' experience, situated behind the primary dune at Fire Island National Seashore, a short walk from the lifeguarded ocean beach and approximately 0.14 km from Dune Station, providing access to the Otis High Dune Wilderness.
This safari-style glamping tent, sleeping up to six guests in one bedroom and one bathroom, features memory foam mattresses, sateen sheets, a covered porch with mosquito netting, and access to on-site amenities including an outdoor restaurant, picnic tables, and BBQ grills; additional cots are available.

This Fire Island Pines villa, located in Sayville, offers convenient access to the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, approximately 3.8 kilometres away, and is also within 4.7 kilometres of Bowlero Sayville.
This one-bedroom property provides essential amenities including WiFi, heating, air conditioning, and a washing machine, with a queen bed ensuring a comfortable stay for guests exploring the local recreational activities.

This Bay Shore apartment is ideally located just a short walk from Islip Beach, providing easy access to the beautiful coastline and a range of water activities. The property is also within easy reach of Tanger Outlets Deer Park, offering a variety of shopping and entertainment options. The apartment has received very good user ratings, highlighting its popularity amongst previous guests.
The apartment is a comfortable one-bedroom property, spanning 84 square metres and accommodating up to four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a shared garden with a fire pit, a spa, and free WiFi, as well as access to a larger 3-bedroom property on-site.

This four-bedroom flat in Patchogue offers convenient access to Fire Island National Seashore and Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, with the 89 North Music Venue and Gateway Playhouse also nearby.
Accommodating up to 10 guests, this property features air conditioning, three bathrooms, and comfortable sleeping arrangements including one king and three queen beds, ideal for families or groups exploring local attractions such as Bowl Long Island at Patchogue and the Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts.

This three-bedroom apartment in West Bay Shore is situated near the South Shore golf course, approximately 24 kilometres from Bethpage State Park, host of the 2025 Ryder Cup.
The property offers air conditioning, parking, a kitchen, internet access, and sleeps three guests, providing a comfortable base for exploring West Bay Shore and its surrounding attractions.

This Shirley property, near Smith Point Beach and a short drive (approximately 16km) from Patchogue, offers easy access to Long Island's south shore attractions.
Sleeping up to eight guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom house boasts a hidden speakeasy, hot tub, pool table, and multiple Smart TVs with streaming services, alongside a well-equipped kitchen and a private balcony from the master suite overlooking a nature reserve.

This two-bedroom flat in Brentwood offers private ground-floor access and parking for two vehicles, situated centrally on Long Island for easy access to shops, restaurants, parks, and major roads, with the beaches of Long Island and attractions of New York City within a short drive.
This apartment accommodates up to four guests and includes essential amenities such as air conditioning and a kitchen, making it a practical base for exploring the local area and beyond.

This newly remodelled 1950s retro cottage in North Bay Shore offers a private studio with ground-level access and free public parking directly outside.
The self-contained property sleeps two guests, featuring a queen-size bed, pull-out sofa bed, fully equipped kitchen (fridge, freezer, microwave, toaster, Keurig), private bathroom, 55-inch HD TV with Netflix, and dedicated workspace with Wi-Fi.

This spacious lower-level flat in Mastic Beach offers guests a comfortable and private retreat with full access to all amenities.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment accommodates up to two guests and features a fridge, microwave oven, garden, and parking, providing a convenient base for exploring local attractions.