Find hotels in Kelleys Island, OH at the best prices

34 available hotel offers

2 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Kelleys Island, OH hotels
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

34 Cheap hotels in Kelleys Island, OH

Best Kelleys Island, OH luxury hotels (4 and 5 stars)

Among the 34 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 1 best luxury hotels

Islander Inn - Kelleys Island, OH
8.3 795 reviews
Kelleys Island, OH
24/07 – 26/07
$718/nighttotal: $1436 (2 )

Islander Inn

1 2
hotel , Put-in-Bay
The Islander Inn in Put-in-Bay is conveniently located just a 14-minute walk from Perry’s Cave, a popular attraction on the island.
This hotel offers a range of amenities, including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a hot tub, a bar, and free Wi-Fi, making it an ideal choice for travellers seeking a comfortable and convenient stay in Put-in-Bay.

Best Kelleys Island, OH hotels with a pool

Among the 34 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 1 best hotels with a pool

The Wave At Marblehead - Kelleys Island, OH
8.8 32 reviews
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$1246/nighttotal: $3738 (3 )

The Wave At Marblehead

2 6
hotel , Marblehead
The Wave at Marblehead is a 3-star hotel located in the charming town of Marblehead, just a 5-minute walk from the Marblehead Lighthouse and a short distance from the town centre. The hotel offers a peaceful retreat from the bustling town, allowing guests to enjoy the scenic beauty of the area.
The hotel provides comfortable accommodation with a garden and terrace, offering a relaxing space to enjoy the fresh air. Guests can also take advantage of the outdoor swimming pool, free Wi-Fi throughout the property, and free private parking.

Frequently Asked Questions about hotels in Kelleys Island, OH

  • What are the best landmarks to visit on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island boasts some fantastic landmarks! The Glacial Grooves are a must-see, showcasing impressive ancient geological formations. The Kelleys Island State Park offers beautiful Lake Erie views and hiking trails. You'll also want to check out the historic Kelleys Island Lighthouse, a charming landmark with a rich history. Don't forget to explore the charming village itself, with its historic buildings and shops.
  • What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Kelleys Island, OH?

    Lake Point Motel, Put-in-bay Resort & Conference Center and South Beach Resort Hotel are among the best hotels with a swimming pool in Kelleys Island, OH.

  • What is the best itinerary to experience Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    A great itinerary would involve spending a day exploring the Glacial Grooves, taking a leisurely hike in Kelleys Island State Park, and then visiting the Kelleys Island Lighthouse. In the afternoon, you could explore the village, browse the shops, and enjoy a meal at one of the local restaurants. If time allows, consider renting a bike and exploring the island's quieter backroads. A boat tour of the surrounding waters is another excellent option.
  • What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Kelleys Island, OH?

    Among 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Kelleys Island, OH, Commodore Resort, Edgewater Hotel And Suites and Put In Bay Victory Station Hotel are the most popular ones.

  • What is the recommended daily budget for Kelleys Island, Ohio (accommodation, dining, transportation, and activities)?

    A daily budget will vary greatly depending on your preferences. Accommodation can range from budget-friendly camping to more upscale options. Dining can range from casual eateries to finer restaurants. Transportation to the island via ferry is a fixed cost, and activities like boat tours and rentals will add to the expense. A conservative estimate for a modest daily budget would be around $150-$300 per person, but it could easily be higher or lower depending on your choices.
  • What are the best luxury hotels in Kelleys Island, OH?

    Kelleys Island Venture Resort & Conference Center is among the best luxury hotels in Kelleys Island, OH.

  • What is the best time to visit Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    The best time to visit Kelleys Island is during the summer months (June-August) for warm weather and access to all activities. However, shoulder seasons (May and September) offer pleasant weather with fewer crowds. The island's beauty is still present during these times.
  • What are the best family friendly hotels in Kelleys Island, OH?

    The best family friendly hotels in Kelleys Island, OH are Put-in-bay Resort & Conference Center, South Beach Resort Hotel and Edgewater Hotel And Suites.

  • What popular festivals are there on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island doesn't have large-scale, widely known festivals. However, the island community often hosts smaller, local events throughout the summer. It's best to check local event listings closer to your travel dates to see what might be happening during your visit.
  • What are the best pet friendly hotels in Kelleys Island, OH?

    The best pet friendly hotels in Kelleys Island, OH are Lake Point Motel, Commodore Resort and The Mayfly Inn In The Heart Of Lakeside.

  • What traditional local food should you try on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    While Kelleys Island doesn't have unique, signature dishes, many restaurants offer fresh seafood dishes featuring Lake Erie perch or walleye. Many establishments also offer classic American fare with a focus on locally sourced ingredients when available.
  • What are the best hotels with jacuzzi in Kelleys Island, OH?

    Put-in-bay Resort & Conference Center, South Beach Resort Hotel and Islander Inn are the best hotels with a jacuzzi in Kelleys Island, OH.

  • Are there any unknown or hidden places that should be on your list for Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Some of the quieter, less-visited areas of the island are worth exploring. Take a walk along the less-trafficked trails in Kelleys Island State Park. Exploring the island's eastern shoreline offers beautiful views and a peaceful escape from the more crowded areas.
  • What are some authentic ways to meet locals and discover their traditions on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    The best way to meet locals is by striking up conversations at local restaurants, shops, or the marina. Many residents are friendly and happy to share information about the island. Attending any local events or festivals will also provide opportunities to interact with the community.
  • What should visitors know about the weather and natural risks on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island experiences typical Lake Erie weather. Summers are warm and humid, while winters are cold and can be windy. Lake effect snow is possible in the winter. Be prepared for changing weather conditions and pack accordingly. The primary natural risk is the lake itself; always exercise caution near the water.
  • Are there any special items you'll need when traveling to Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Comfortable walking shoes are essential for exploring the island's trails and landmarks. Sunscreen, insect repellent, and a hat are recommended during warmer months. If you plan on hiking, bring water and snacks. Remember, you'll need to take a ferry to reach the island, so plan your travel accordingly.

Nearby regions

Best Kelleys Island, OH hotels with air conditioning

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse - Kelleys Island, OH
9.2 345 reviews
Kelleys Island, OH
24/07 – 26/07
$458/nighttotal: $916 (2 )

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

1 2
hotel , Put-in-Bay
Ahoy Inn Guest House is located in Put-in-Bay, a short drive from Sandusky and Leamington, Ontario, making it a convenient base for exploring the island's attractions. The guesthouse has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall guest experience.
The guest house offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and private balconies or terraces. Guests can enjoy the convenience of room service, parking, and access to a garden, as well as the opportunity to rent golf carts or borrow bicycles for exploring the island.
Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island, OH
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$746/nighttotal: $2238 (3 )

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort

2 6
hotel , Kelleys Island
The Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort boasts a lakeside location on Kelley's Island, Ohio, a 15-minute walk from Caddy Shack Square and less than 1.6km from Inscription Rock and Seaway Marina.
This 77-square-metre self-catering apartment offers two bedrooms, one bathroom, and sleeps six, featuring a private balcony, fireplace, spa tub, and free Wi-Fi.
2 Queen Room With Lakeview Balcony - Kelleys Island, OH
Kelleys Island, OH
24/07 – 26/07
$839/nighttotal: $1678 (2 )

2 Queen Room With Lakeview Balcony

1 2
hotel , Put-in-Bay
The Bayshore Resort offers a "2 Queen Room With Lakeview Balcony" situated directly on the shores of Lake Erie in Put-in-Bay, within 500 meters of local restaurants and attractions, including the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society and Perry's Cave.
This 38 square meter accommodation is ideal for up to four guests, featuring air conditioning, internet access, and a private balcony, with the resort also providing two heated swimming pools, a jacuzzi, and onsite golf cart and kayak rentals for exploring the island.
Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island, OH
8.0 1 review
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$746/nighttotal: $2238 (3 )

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort

2 6
hotel , Kelleys Island
The Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort is a lakeside holiday home on Kelley's Island, Ohio, less than 1.6km from Caddy Shack Square, Inscription Rock, and Seaway Marina.
This 77 square metre self-catering property features two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six guests, and includes a private patio, fireplace, and amenities such as Wi-Fi, a refrigerator, microwave, and TV.

Best Kelleys Island, OH hotels with a balcony

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island, OH
8.0 11 reviews
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$746/nighttotal: $2238 (3 )

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort

2 6
hotel , Kelleys Island
The Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort is Kelleys Island's sole resort, situated within easy walking distance of the town centre and island transport links, offering direct access to the lake. This two-level, 77 square metre apartment accommodates up to six guests, featuring two bedrooms, one bathroom, a loft bedroom, a private patio, access to a common balcony with lake views, and use of a heated outdoor swimming pool and hot tub seasonally, with free on-site parking available.
Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island, OH
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$746/nighttotal: $2238 (3 )

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort

2 6
hotel , Kelleys Island
The Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort is a lakeside property on Kelley's Island, Ohio, a 15-minute walk from Lake Erie and Caddy Shack Square, and under 1.6km from Inscription Rock and Seaway Marina.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday home offers 77 square metres of space, sleeping up to six guests and boasting a private patio, swimming pool, jacuzzi, and free WiFi.
Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island, OH
8.0 1 review
Kelleys Island, OH
04/09 – 07/09
$746/nighttotal: $2238 (3 )

Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort

2 6
hotel , Kelleys Island
The Iroquois Suite At Kelley's Island Venture Resort is a lakefront property on Kelley's Island, Ohio, less than 1.6km from Inscription Rock and Seaway Marina and a 15-minute walk from Caddy Shack Square.
This 77 square metre holiday home features two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six, and includes a private balcony, fireplace, free Wi-Fi, and a spa tub.
Ahoy Inn Guesthouse - Kelleys Island, OH
Kelleys Island, OH
24/07 – 26/07
$510/nighttotal: $1020 (2 )

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

1 2
hotel , Put-in-Bay
The Ahoy Inn Guesthouse is conveniently located in Put-in-Bay, within walking distance of Oak Point State Park, Lake Erie Islands Historical Society, and DeRivera Park, making it easy to explore the island's attractions. It's situated in a quiet residential area, offering a peaceful retreat from the bustling tourist zones.
The guesthouse provides comfortable accommodation for up to two guests in each room, all equipped with a bathroom, air conditioning, and a garden. Guests can enjoy amenities such as free Wi-Fi, room service, and parking, ensuring a comfortable and convenient stay.
©2026 cozycozy.com