Cottages in Finger Lakes, NY at the best prices

522 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Finger Lakes, NY cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

522 Best cottages in Finger Lakes, NY

Best family friendly Finger Lakes, NY cottage rentals

Among the 522 accommodations in Finger Lakes, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly cottage rentals

Charming Finger Lakes Cottage With 3 Levels Of Lakefront Views For All Seasons - Finger Lakes, NY
10 6 reviews

Charming Finger Lakes Cottage With 3 Levels Of Lakefront Views For All Seasons

cottage, Hammondsport
This three-bedroom Hammondsport holiday home is situated near Waneta Lake and Lamoka Lake (within 5km), and Keuka Lake (within 10km), offering easy access to watersports and the Ravines Wine Cellars (within 10km).
Sleeping eight guests, the property boasts two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, a terrace, garden, parking, Wi-Fi, and barbecue facilities, perfect for families seeking lakeside relaxation.
Al's Creekside Cottage In The Finger Lakes - Finger Lakes, NY
9.0 28 reviews

Al's Creekside Cottage In The Finger Lakes

cottage, Montour Falls
This charming cottage sits just outside Montour Falls, within 3km of Eagle Cliff Falls, She-Qa-Ga Falls, and the Montour Falls Memorial Library, offering a peaceful escape close to local attractions. It consistently receives very good reviews from guests.
The cottage has two bedrooms, a sofa bed, and can accommodate up to five guests. The kitchen is equipped with a fridge, oven, stovetop, and microwave, while the terrace, garden, and barbecue facilities provide ample space for outdoor enjoyment.
"Longview": Flx Lakefront Cottage W/beachfront, Dock & Complimentary Flx Wine! - Finger Lakes, NY
9.8 83 reviews

"Longview": Flx Lakefront Cottage W/beachfront, Dock & Complimentary Flx Wine!

cottage, Interlaken
This charming cottage is situated on the western shore of Cayuga Lake, just 20 kilometres north of Ithaca and a short drive from several wineries. It has received excellent reviews from previous guests.
The two-bedroom property can accommodate up to four guests and offers a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious terrace, and a private beach with access to a range of water sports equipment. Guests can enjoy stunning lake views, relax by the fire pit, or explore the surrounding area.
Family/dog Friendly Cottage On Seneca Lake @ Long Point Beach With Awesome Views - Finger Lakes, NY
9.4 29 reviews

Family/dog Friendly Cottage On Seneca Lake @ Long Point Beach With Awesome Views

cottage, Dresden
This charming cottage is situated just 10 kilometres from Penn Yan, a charming town on the shores of Seneca Lake, and is within easy reach of both Geneva and Watkins Glen, both within 20 kilometres. It has received excellent reviews from previous guests.
The cottage has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably sleeping up to eight people. It offers a range of modern amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious garden, and a private dock with access to the lake for swimming, kayaking and snorkelling.

Best Finger Lakes, NY cottages with a garden

Rapalee Retreat - Wine And Lake Lovers Take Notice! - Finger Lakes, NY
10 57 reviews

Rapalee Retreat - Wine And Lake Lovers Take Notice!

cottage, Lodi
This waterfront holiday home in Himrod, near Seneca Lake, offers private dock access, kayaks, and is a short drive (approx. 24km) from Watkins Glen and Geneva.
The 116 square metre property boasts two bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps seven, includes a game room with ping pong and foosball, and features a two-acre garden with a fire pit.
Spring Summer Specials On Newly Remodeled Lakefront Home. May Also Book 2664590 - Finger Lakes, NY
10 203 reviews

Spring Summer Specials On Newly Remodeled Lakefront Home. May Also Book 2664590

cottage, Honeoye
This family-friendly cottage is located on the waterfront in Honeoye, just 3.2km from Honeoye Lake and the Honeoye Falls-Mendon Historical Society Museum, offering easy access to both natural beauty and historical exploration. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers.
The cottage has two bedrooms and a sofa bed, accommodating up to six guests, and covers 102 square metres. The property comes with a range of amenities including a swimming pool, tennis court, spa, and a terrace, perfect for enjoying the beautiful surroundings.
Lakeside Cottage On Quiet, Private Road. Walk To Keuka Lake State Park! - Finger Lakes, NY
10 270 reviews

Lakeside Cottage On Quiet, Private Road. Walk To Keuka Lake State Park!

cottage, Keuka Park
This Keuka Park holiday let offers lakeside accommodation in Keuka Park, 7 kilometres from Penn Yan, with 50 feet of lake frontage and within a 1 kilometre walk of Keuka Lake State Park.
This one-bedroom lodge, sleeping up to four guests, features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a garden, parking, a partially covered deck with seating, and access to lake activities including swimming and fishing.
Keuka Waterfront 2-bedroom Cottage With Wi-fi And Ac. Sleeps 6 - Finger Lakes, NY
9.8 15 reviews

Keuka Waterfront 2-bedroom Cottage With Wi-fi And Ac. Sleeps 6

cottage, Keuka Park
This Keuka Lake waterfront property, a two-bedroom holiday home in Pulteney, offers 18 metres of private shoreline and is conveniently located near Hunt Country Vineyards and Heron Hill Winery.
The 104 square metre dwelling boasts a king-size bed in one bedroom, a queen and bunk beds in the other, a full bathroom with laundry facilities, and sleeps up to six guests, enjoying a fridge, microwave, dishwasher, air conditioning, and garden.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Finger Lakes, NY

Popular destinations

Best Finger Lakes, NY cottage rentals with jacuzzi

Among the 522 accommodations in Finger Lakes, NY, here are the 4 best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi

Sweet Water: Cayuga Lakefront Charm & Hot Tub! - Finger Lakes, NY
9.2 17 reviews

Sweet Water: Cayuga Lakefront Charm & Hot Tub!

cottage, Union Springs
This Union Springs waterfront property, a 161-square-metre (1736 sq ft) cottage, is situated near Cayuga Lake, less than 10 kilometres from Cayuga Lake State Park, Varick Winery, and Lakeshore Winery.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home sleeps eight guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, private patio, and direct lake access with stunning Cayuga Lake views; on-site hot tub and barbecue facilities are also available.
At The Lake - 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath Contemporary - Finger Lakes, NY
9.6 20 reviews

At The Lake - 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath Contemporary

cottage, Penn Yan
This lakeside property near Penn Yan, New York, boasts stunning Keuka Lake views and is within 3.2km of the Arts Centre of Yates County, the Oliver House Museum, and Keuka College.
This four-bedroom, four-bathroom holiday home offers 207 square metres of space, sleeping up to ten guests and featuring a jacuzzi, terrace, garden, and fully equipped kitchen; on-site hot tub and barbecue grills are also available.
Clairmonte Cottage-steps To Honeoye Lake/hot Tub/firepit/dog &Kid Friendly/kayak - Finger Lakes, NY
10 1 review

Clairmonte Cottage-steps To Honeoye Lake/hot Tub/firepit/dog &Kid Friendly/kayak

cottage, Honeoye
This two-bedroom lodge in Honeoye is a short walk from the community beach and a private dock on Honeoye Lake, offering direct access to lakeside activities and within 1 kilometre of the boat launch and basketball courts.
This property accommodates up to eight guests and includes a six-person hot tub, a natural gas fire pit, Smart TVs in every room, complimentary Wi-Fi, and two kayaks, with a golf cart available for hire.
La Bella Vita: Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets! - Finger Lakes, NY
9.2 19 reviews

La Bella Vita: Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets!

cottage, Union Springs
This Union Springs waterfront holiday home is situated a short distance from Cayuga Lake, 3.4km from Heart & Hands Wine Company, and within 14.5km of Izzo's White Barn Winery and Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge.
The 437 square metre property boasts five bedrooms, four bathrooms, sleeping up to twelve guests, and features a jacuzzi, terrace, garden, bar, parking, and a fully equipped kitchen; guests can enjoy free Wi-Fi and explore the nearby wineries and wildlife refuge.

Best Finger Lakes, NY cottages with a fireplace

Cottage With Lake View At The Heart Of Seneca Lake - Finger Lakes, NY
9.0 16 reviews

Cottage With Lake View At The Heart Of Seneca Lake

cottage, Geneva
This three-bedroom Geneva cottage, sleeping six, is conveniently located near the Smith Center for the Arts and Rose Hill Mansion, offering easy access to local wineries such as Lacey Magruder Winery and Billsboro Winery.
The self-catering property boasts a fully equipped kitchen with fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, two bathrooms with hair dryers and bidets, and air conditioning; guests can also enjoy nearby attractions including Seneca Lake Sprayground and Muranda Cheese Company.
Quiet/charming 2-bedroom Sunset-lake View Cottage Lovely Seneca Lake, Wine Trail - Finger Lakes, NY
9.8 19 reviews

Quiet/charming 2-bedroom Sunset-lake View Cottage Lovely Seneca Lake, Wine Trail

cottage, Geneva
This Geneva lakeside holiday home boasts a private waterfront location with 11km of private lake access and a removable dock, situated a short walk from local breweries and Ventosa Winery, and 11km from Geneva city centre.
The 102 square metre property offers two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeping up to five guests, and features a full kitchen, spacious open-plan living area, outdoor fire pit, Weber barbecue, and access to kayaking, canoeing, and paddleboarding (equipment not provided).
The Trottage: Modern 2 Bedroom Seneca Lake Home - Finger Lakes, NY
9.8 47 reviews

The Trottage: Modern 2 Bedroom Seneca Lake Home

cottage, Dundee
This lakeside self-catering property in Dundee is situated within 3.2km of Hermann J. Wiemer, Shaw, and Villa Bellangelo wineries, and 9.6km from Fruit Yard and Torrey Ridge.
The 37 square metre cottage sleeps four guests in two bedrooms, one bathroom, and boasts a jacuzzi, terrace, garden, parking, and Wi-Fi, plus on-site barbecue facilities.
Lakefront  Rare 2+ Acre Lot  100ft+ Of Lakefront - Finger Lakes, NY
9.8 32 reviews

Lakefront Rare 2+ Acre Lot 100ft+ Of Lakefront

cottage, Melrose Park
This Auburn waterfront property, near the Highland Park Golf Club and White Birch Vineyards, offers 2.5 acres of grounds and 34 metres of private Owasco Lake frontage, conveniently located for exploring Cayuga Lake, Frozen Ocean State Forest, and the Merry-Go-Round Playhouse.
The 115 square metre holiday home sleeps eight, boasting three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, a spa, and ample parking, with panoramic lake views from its extensive windows.
©2026 cozycozy.com