This Ocean Bay Park Fire Island rental, a four-bedroom house, is located steps from the ocean and ferry, offering easy access to Ocean Beach and nearby amenities such as grocery stores, restaurants, and bars. The 111.5 square metre property boasts a spacious layout with high ceilings, a fully equipped kitchen, a west-facing deck, and can comfortably accommodate eight guests, featuring a fitness centre and access to Verizon internet, Dish TV, and Netflix.
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$408/nighttotal: A$2856 (7 )
Salems Guest Room
1 2
apartment , Shirley
This one-bedroom flat in Shirley offers convenient access to cultural sites such as the Gateway Playhouse and 89 North Music Venue, as well as the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge for outdoor pursuits. This apartment for two guests includes a queen bed, a well-equipped bathroom with a hairdryer, and climate control, with parking available and a terrace or balcony for your enjoyment.
10 21 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$2273/nighttotal: A$11365 (5 )
Bayfront Retreat 3 Ensuite Br + Hot Tub
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This modern apartment is situated in Sayville, just 0.8 km east of the town centre, offering a peaceful retreat while still being close to shops and nightlife. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers. The apartment spans 94 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests across three bedrooms and three bathrooms. Enjoy a range of amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a jacuzzi, a terrace, a garden, and direct access to the bay for swimming and water activities.
8.8 15 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
A$1100/nighttotal: A$3300 (3 )
Studio In Architectual Prominent 1960's Beachhouse
1 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines apartment is just a minute's walk from the ocean beach, offering a tranquil escape in a renowned modernist architectural setting. The property has received excellent ratings for cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The apartment is a completely rebuilt 1961 Andrew Geller masterpiece, comprising a main house and a separate artist studio. Guests can enjoy a heated pool, a roof deck, central air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and a range of personalized services including a chef, yoga teacher, and massage therapist.
8.7 17 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$895/nighttotal: A$6265 (7 )
Sunny 2 Bedroom Cottage By The Bay
2 2
apartment , Patchogue
This Patchogue holiday home is situated on a private lane, approximately 0.14 km from the bay, and within walking distance of restaurants, the Fire Island Ferry (Davis Park), and the Long Island Rail Road. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom property sleeps two guests and offers free on-site parking, a garden, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and a kitchen with a fridge and microwave; a porch and back deck with grill provide outdoor space.
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$1537/nighttotal: A$10759 (7 )
The Pelican's Nest
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This waterfront beach house offers a quintessential Fire Island experience, situated steps from the ocean and a short distance from car-free villages. Accommodating up to 8 guests across 3 bedrooms and a loft, this holiday let boasts three decks, an outdoor shower, and a well-equipped kitchen with ocean views, perfect for enjoying seaside activities.
9.9 150 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/08 – 18/08
A$514/nighttotal: A$1028 (2 )
Joyful Beach House, Viewing The Great South Bay
2 3
apartment , Patchogue
This charming flat is located directly across the street from Shorefront Park in Patchogue, just a short walk from the Patchogue Beach Club and the vibrant downtown area. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. This spacious apartment features an open-plan design, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. Enjoy stunning views of the Great South Bay from the patio, relax by the pool at the Patchogue Beach Club, and take advantage of amenities such as a modern kitchen, private parking, and storage options.
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$2559/nighttotal: A$17913 (7 )
Fire Island Getaway | Renovated 5br | Sleeps 10
5 2
apartment , Fire Island
This 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom flat in Ocean Bay Park is conveniently located a short walk from the ferry, beach, Flynn's, and Schooner Inn. This accommodation offers air conditioning in every room, a fully equipped kitchen, an on-site laundry shed with beach essentials, and an expansive deck, accommodating up to 10 guests with 10 beds.
9.4 110 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$183/nighttotal: A$915 (5 )
Close-to-all Sunny Sayville Studio
1 2
studio , Sayville
This Sayville studio apartment is situated 1.6km from Sayville's town centre, offering easy access to the Ronkonkoma railway station (6.4km), MacArthur Airport (3.2km), and the Sayville Fire Island ferries (4km), conveniently located near the Sunrise Highway. The 37-square-metre self-contained apartment sleeps two, features a queen-size bed (with a cot available), a kitchenette with a fridge, air conditioning, parking, and Wi-Fi, plus a deli downstairs for added convenience.
9.9 40 reviews
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
A$341/nighttotal: A$1023 (3 )
Over The Moon
1 2
house , Islip
This Islip studio apartment offers convenient street parking and is ideally located, though its precise address within Islip is not provided. The self-contained unit sleeps two guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, high-speed Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a private entrance.
9.4 6 reviews
Fire Island, NY
01/08 – 03/08
A$509/nighttotal: A$1018 (2 )
Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi To The Beach
1 3
apartment , North Bay Shore
This Bay Shore apartment is ideally located just a short walk from Islip Beach, providing easy access to the beautiful coastline and a range of water activities. The property is also within easy reach of Tanger Outlets Deer Park, offering a variety of shopping and entertainment options. The apartment has received very good user ratings, highlighting its popularity amongst previous guests. The apartment is a comfortable one-bedroom property, spanning 84 square metres and accommodating up to four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a shared garden with a fire pit, a spa, and free WiFi, as well as access to a larger 3-bedroom property on-site.
9.7 91 reviews
Fire Island, NY
19/07 – 20/07
A$286/nightfor 1 night
Cozy Apartment With Private Entrance
1 2
apartment , Central Islip
This ground-floor Central Islip studio apartment, offering a private entrance, is conveniently located in a quiet residential area; further details regarding proximity to the Long Island Rail Road and Tanger Outlets Riverhead, are needed to specify distances in kilometres. The self-contained apartment sleeps three, features a kitchen, air conditioning, parking, and excellent guest reviews, providing a comfortable base for exploring Central Islip and beyond.
Best family friendly Fire Island, NY holiday rentals
Among the 741 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals
9.7 53 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$972/nighttotal: A$4860 (5 )
Bay Front Upper Level Cottage 47e
2 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island apartment is located on the bay side, just a short walk from the Ocean Bay Park ferry and close to restaurants, shops, and other attractions. It has consistently received excellent reviews for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The property is a two-bedroom, one-bathroom dwelling that can comfortably accommodate up to five guests. It offers a range of amenities, including a private beach and swim area, stunning bay and beach views, an outdoor shower, and a kitchen equipped with a fridge, freezer, and microwave.
9.8 25 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$2830/nighttotal: A$19810 (7 )
Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines
2 2
apartment , Fire Island
This beach house is located in the Fire Island Pines community, just a short distance from the ferry terminal and the nearby Cherry Grove. The property has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers. The house is a two-bedroom property that can comfortably sleep up to four people. It features a kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave oven and dishwasher, as well as air conditioning, a jacuzzi, a terrace, a garden, and internet access.
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
25/06 – 28/06
A$1555/nighttotal: A$4665 (3 )
Charming 2-bedroom Beach Cottage In Ocean Bay Park
2 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Ocean Bay Park holiday home is a five-minute walk from the Ocean Beach ferry and local restaurants, offering easy access to Fire Island's attractions. Sleeping four guests, this two-bedroom, two-bathroom property boasts a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a washing machine, outdoor shower, BBQ, bikes, beach equipment, and a comfortable enclosed porch; it is located on the ground floor for convenient beach access.
8.0 10 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$802/nighttotal: A$4010 (5 )
Tranquil Stay
3 2
apartment , Shirley
This three-bedroom house is located in Shirley, just a short drive from the beaches and golf courses of Mastic Beach. The property has received excellent reviews from previous guests. This spacious home spans 149 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests. The house includes a fully equipped kitchen, a private patio with a barbecue, a jacuzzi, and a range of other amenities, making it ideal for families or groups of friends looking for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with a pool
Among the 741 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best rentals with a pool
9.9 49 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$3216/nighttotal: A$22512 (7 )
Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach
4 2
apartment , Ocean Beach
This house is located in Ocean Beach, just 1 kilometre from the beautiful beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the oceanfront. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. This four-bedroom house spans 232 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Enjoy a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining.
10 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
A$2334/nighttotal: A$9336 (4 )
Modern All-suite Home • Rooftop • Bay Views • Pool
1 2
apartment , Fire Island
This brand-new three-bedroom Fire Island Pines residence, situated on Fire Island Boulevard, is just a short stroll (less than 0.2 km) from the beach. The 3-bathroom property boasts an open-plan design, a private pool, three levels of decking including a rooftop terrace with bay views, and comfortably accommodates eight guests with amenities including a chef's kitchen and fast Wi-Fi.
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
27/06 – 04/07
A$4333/nighttotal: A$30331 (7 )
Fire Island Pines H. Gifford's Famous Tree House
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This apartment is located in Fire Island Pines, just a short walk from the Great South Bay and a stunning beach on the Atlantic Ocean. The property has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness. The home has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private pool and hot tub, a rooftop deck with stunning views, and a garden with an outdoor dining area.
9.0 16 reviews
Fire Island, NY
19/07 – 20/07
A$486/nightfor 1 night
A 1 Br Luxury Apt To Relax W/hot Tube
1 2
apartment , Mastic Beach
This spacious lower-level flat in Mastic Beach offers guests a comfortable and private retreat with full access to all amenities. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment accommodates up to two guests and features a fridge, microwave oven, garden, and parking, providing a convenient base for exploring local attractions.
Frequently asked questions about holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY
What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?
First-timers should definitely check out the Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a must-see. The views from the top are incredible and you can learn about the history of the lighthouse. Another must-do is a walk along the beach, especially at sunset. The sunsets are stunning and the beach is beautiful.
What are the best Airbnb and holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY?
Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?
It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be in the heart of the action, Ocean Beach is a good choice. It's known for its lively nightlife and restaurants. If you prefer something quieter, consider a rental in Cherry Grove. It's known for its laid-back atmosphere and beautiful beaches.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?
What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?
The Fire Island Lighthouse is a popular attraction for families, as is the Fire Island National Seashore. The National Seashore has plenty of space for kids to run around and explore, and there are also ranger-led programmes and activities during the summer months.
What are the best holiday rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?
When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
The best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island is as early as possible, especially if you're travelling during the peak season from June to August. You can often find good deals if you book outside of these months, but availability might be limited.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?
Walking or cycling along the beach is a great way to spend a day in Fire Island without spending a lot of money. You can also pack a picnic and enjoy a meal on the beach. The Fire Island National Seashore offers free ranger-led programmes and activities, which are a great way to learn about the local wildlife and history.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?
The Clamman is a popular spot for fresh seafood, and they've been serving up delicious dishes for years. The Lobster Roll is a classic Fire Island dish, and you can find it at many restaurants on the island. The Fire Island Pines has some great options for a more upscale dining experience.
What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?
The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place for a walk or cycle. There are miles of trails to explore, and you can see a variety of wildlife along the way. You can also walk or cycle along the beach, but be sure to check the tide times before you go.
Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?
Most of the beaches on Fire Island are not pet-friendly, but there are some exceptions. The westernmost part of the island, near the Robert Moses State Park, is generally more dog-friendly. You can also find pet-friendly restaurants and shops on the island.
What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel room, and they're often a more affordable option for families or groups. You can find a wide variety of rentals on Fire Island, from cozy cottages to spacious houses. Many rentals also offer amenities that you won't find in a hotel, like a private deck or outdoor shower.
Destinations nearby
Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with a balcony
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
A$1615/nighttotal: A$6460 (4 )
Ocean Front, Cherry Grove Fire Island, Upper Level
2 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Sayville flat offers proximity to Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, situated just 100 metres away, and Carrington House is a 14-minute walk. This two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment accommodates up to five guests, featuring air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a television, and on-site laundry facilities, with heating and linens provided for your comfort.
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
01/08 – 03/08
A$2478/nighttotal: A$4956 (2 )
Stylish Entire Home W/ Pool & Relaxing Patio
4 3
apartment , Patchogue
This Patchogue flat offers a central location, situated 2 kilometres from Fire Island National Seashore and Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, with the Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts and Bowl Long Island at Patchogue within walking distance. This property accommodates up to eight guests in four bedrooms and features air conditioning, a kitchen with a microwave oven and dishwasher, a swimming pool, and a balcony, with parking also available.
9.6 28 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$674/nighttotal: A$3370 (5 )
Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc
3 2
apartment , Islip
This Islip holiday home is situated within 3.2km of Cohalan Court Complex, the Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Bethpage Ballpark, and within 4.8km of Bay Shore Mini Golf and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park. This 151 square metre property offers four bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six guests, and boasts a swimming pool, terrace, garden, free Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen; nearby attractions include a water park and family-friendly activities.
9.9 275 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$374/nighttotal: A$1870 (5 )
Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit!
1 2
apartment , Islip Terrace
This apartment is located in Islip Terrace, within 3 kilometres of the Cohalan Court Complex, Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Gallery of Shorthand, and within 5 kilometres of SUSA Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex and Bethpage Ballpark. This property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience. The apartment is a 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom flat with a 37 square metre floor area and a maximum capacity of 3 guests. This property features a garden, a terrace, a spa, parking, and free Wi-Fi, as well as a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave oven, and a stovetop.
Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with parking
9.7 69 reviews
Fire Island, NY
30/08 – 04/09
A$617/nighttotal: A$3085 (5 )
Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay
3 2
house , Mastic Beach
This waterfront property is located in Mastic Beach, just 38km from the Long Island Railroad and 32km from Splish Splash waterpark, offering a peaceful escape from the bustling city life. The property boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. This spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home can accommodate up to 6 guests and spans 167 square metres. The house offers direct waterfront access with a large deck and dock, perfect for enjoying the bay, along with a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, a garden, parking, and a peaceful atmosphere.
Fire Island, NY
28/06 – 02/07
A$952/nighttotal: A$3808 (4 )
Fire Island Pines Paradise
2 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Sayville holiday let offers direct access to Fire Island, situated a mere 200 metres from the beach and 500 metres from the Pines ferry dock, dining, and shops. This two-bedroom flat accommodates up to five guests, featuring a newly installed Jacuzzi hot tub, a private deck with ocean views, an outdoor shower, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Fire Island, NY
16/07 – 19/07
A$1075/nighttotal: A$3225 (3 )
Bayfront Home In Patchogue With Deck And Fishing Dock
3 2
house , East Patchogue
This bayfront property in Patchogue, New York, boasts direct water access, a private fishing dock, and is conveniently located 12 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport. The 167-square-metre house features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps eleven guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, Wi-Fi, and parking (at an extra charge); nearby attractions include Splish Splash (35km) and Bergen Point County Golf Course (37km).
