Accommodations at the best price near Highland Lake, NY

88 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Highland Lake, NY accommodations
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Highland Lake, NY: Compare Airbnb, Hotels and vacation rentals

Best family friendly Highland Lake, NY lodging

Among the 88 accommodations in Highland Lake, NY, here are the 4 best for families

Secluded Catskills Treehouse | Hot Tub + Roof Deck - Highland Lake, NY
10 61 reviews

Secluded Catskills Treehouse | Hot Tub + Roof Deck

cabin, Port Jervis
This Catskills retreat, located on nine wooded acres near the Delaware River, is five minutes from Barryville and twenty minutes from both Narrowsburg and Port Jervis, offering easy access to local attractions.
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a 65-inch smart TV, high-speed Wi-Fi, a fitness center with a Peloton, and extensive outdoor space including a large deck, rooftop deck, and fire pit; nearby activities include canoeing, rafting, hiking, and skiing.
Secluded Luxury Cabin Surrounded By Nature - Fernwood Lodge - Highland Lake, NY
10 1 review

Secluded Luxury Cabin Surrounded By Nature - Fernwood Lodge

cabin, Port Jervis
Fernwood Lodge is a secluded standalone cabin in Glen Spey, New York, offering privacy among trees and ferns, a short drive from Huckleberry Ridge State Park and Dryden Kuser Natural Area.
This family-friendly lodge accommodates up to 6 guests in 3 bedrooms, features a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a garden with a fire pit for stargazing, and parking.
Lakefront Luxury Escape  Pool, Sauna, Kayak, 6br - Highland Lake, NY
9.7 27 reviews

Lakefront Luxury Escape Pool, Sauna, Kayak, 6br

apartment, Narrowsburg
This 6-bedroom, 5-bathroom estate in Eldred, NY, offers sweeping lake views on 2 private acres, located 10 minutes from the Delaware River and 15 minutes from Big Bear Mountain ski resort.
This family-friendly rental features a seasonal saltwater pool, private home theater, game room with a pool table and Xbox, a chef's kitchen, and covered deck dining, accommodating up to 14 guests with parking for 4 vehicles.
Spacious Delaware Riverfront Suite - Highland Lake, NY
9.8 144 reviews

Spacious Delaware Riverfront Suite

farm, Port Jervis
This farm is located in Port Jervis, directly on the Delaware River and the historic D&H Canal, offering easy access to swimming, boating, and fishing. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The farm offers two bedrooms and two bathrooms, accommodating up to six guests. Amenities include a private deck, barbecue area, a spacious kitchen, and a unique bar room, plus access to an apple orchard, all creating a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Best Highland Lake, NY lodging with a pool

Among the 88 accommodations in Highland Lake, NY, here are the 4 best ones with a pool

2 Lake Cabins | Pool+hottub | Game Room & Courts - Highland Lake, NY
10 5 reviews

2 Lake Cabins | Pool+hottub | Game Room & Courts

cottage, Smallwood
This Highland Lake beach house near Smallwood, New York, is 2.5 miles from Sidwell Lake, and within 6 miles of Mohican Lake and the Upper Delaware River.
This 2,500-square-foot vacation rental boasts eight bedrooms, four bathrooms, sleeps sixteen guests, and features a private pool, hot tub, fitness center, and fully equipped kitchen.
Beautiful 4 Bedroom House In A Quiet Area - Highland Lake, NY
9.9 71 reviews

Beautiful 4 Bedroom House In A Quiet Area

house, Port Jervis
This vacation home is located on a river, just a short drive from Mohican Lake and the Kadampa Meditation Center. The surrounding area offers stunning river views, peaceful surroundings, and opportunities for outdoor recreation. This property boasts excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness.
The home features 4 bedrooms, making it suitable for families or groups of friends. Enjoy a private pool, a spacious garden, a terrace, and modern amenities like free Wi-Fi, a fully equipped kitchen, and a fireplace.
Lake House Heated Pool Hot Tub Kayaks Firepit Screened Patio Foosball Fireplace - Highland Lake, NY
10 1 review

Lake House Heated Pool Hot Tub Kayaks Firepit Screened Patio Foosball Fireplace

apartment, Narrowsburg
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom vacation home is located on 2 acres on Washington Lake in the Catskills, about 15-20 minutes from Narrowsburg, and is close to the Roebling Aqueduct Suspension Bridge and Bethel Woods Center For The Arts.
This pet-friendly apartment accommodates up to 10 guests and features a private swimming pool, hot tub, garden, terrace, parking, air conditioning, internet, and recreational activities such as kayaking and rowboats.
Bella Cottage W/pool, Bbq - Catskill Getaway - Highland Lake, NY
10 138 reviews

Bella Cottage W/pool, Bbq - Catskill Getaway

apartment, Narrowsburg
This Catskills cottage rental near Narrowsburg, NY offers a secluded 2-acre setting on a private drive, close to local grocery stores and restaurants, and within a 30-minute drive of Catskills attractions like rafting and skiing.
This two-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps four guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a private seasonal pool (closing October 11th), a wood-burning fireplace, and an upper deck overlooking the wooded property.

Top-rated Highland Lake, NY accommodation

Walk To Mohican Lake: Catskills Getaway W/ Dock! - Highland Lake, NY
9.2 10 reviews

Walk To Mohican Lake: Catskills Getaway W/ Dock!

apartment, Smallwood
This Glen Spey vacation home, near Smallwood, New York, is 0.2 miles from Mohican Lake and within 6 miles of attractions like the Kadampa Meditation Center and Cliff Lake.
This 2,270-square-foot house features six bedrooms, three bathrooms, and sleeps nine guests, offering a fully equipped kitchen, private patio, and outdoor amenities including barbecue grills.

Highland Lake, NY: Other neighborhoods and points of interest

Best Highland Lake, NY accommodation with a balcony

Secluded Catskills Treehouse Hot Tub Roof Deck - Highland Lake, NY
No reviews

Secluded Catskills Treehouse Hot Tub Roof Deck

house, Port Jervis
This secluded Catskills treehouse in Pond Eddy is 9.3 miles from Kadampa Meditation Center New York and 51 miles from Stewart International Airport.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house offers 2000 square feet of living space, accommodates up to 17 guests, and features a hot tub, roof deck, fully equipped kitchen, and is pet-friendly.
Modern Forest Retreat On A Tranquil Hilltop With Sauna - Highland Lake, NY
8.8 3 reviews

Modern Forest Retreat On A Tranquil Hilltop With Sauna

cottage, Masthope
The Shohola Cottage is located in the Shohola district, just a short drive from the Zane Grey Museum, Fort Delaware Museum, Minisink Battlefield County Park, and Roebling Aqueduct Suspension Bridge. This charming cottage has earned excellent user ratings for its comfortable and inviting atmosphere.
This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom cabin comfortably sleeps 7 guests. Enjoy the wrap-around porch with stunning views of the forest, relax by the fireplace or fire pit, and take advantage of the nearby nature trails, skiing, archery, local farms and antique shops, restaurants, and wineries.
Rivers Ledge Cabin With Sauna And Hot Tub - Highland Lake, NY
8.8 8 reviews

Rivers Ledge Cabin With Sauna And Hot Tub

cabin, Port Jervis
This waterfront Port Jervis cottage offers direct access to the Upper Delaware Scenic and Recreational Area and is within three miles of the Upper Delaware River, near Minisink Battleground Park and Minisink Battlefield County Park (nine miles away).
The 1100-square-foot home features four bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps eight, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, fireplace, Wi-Fi, and a terrace; barbecue grills and a hot tub are available for outdoor enjoyment.
Luxury Streamfront Cabin W/ Hot Tub - Pet Friendly - Highland Lake, NY
10 95 reviews

Luxury Streamfront Cabin W/ Hot Tub - Pet Friendly

apartment, Port Jervis
This charming 3-bedroom cabin is located just two hours from New York City, in a peaceful rural setting near Port Jervis, bordering a 19-acre wildlife preserve. The cabin boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
The 1,540 square foot cabin comfortably accommodates up to 6 guests, offering a spacious and relaxing retreat. You'll enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a hot tub, a large wrap-around porch, a propane BBQ grill, and hiking trails, providing ample opportunities for relaxation and entertainment.
©2026 cozycozy.com