The widest selection of unusual accommodations in Ithaca, NY

A cabin, a lighthouse, a glamping, your extraordinary stay awaits you

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Ithaca, NY unique stays
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

12 Unique places to stay in Ithaca, NY

Browse Unique Stays near the Historic Centre in Ithaca, NY

Position yourself steps away from famous independent bistros and transit links with central unique stays in Ithaca, NY.

2-bdrm Lake Cabin In Trees/ithaca - Ithaca, NY
9.5 71 reviews

2-bdrm Lake Cabin In Trees/ithaca

cabin, Ithaca
This charming cottage is situated on a hillside overlooking Lake Cayuga, just a short distance from Cornell University and Ithaca College, offering a peaceful retreat amidst the natural beauty of the area. It has consistently received excellent ratings from guests for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
This cosy two-bedroom cabin can accommodate up to four guests and features a rustic charm with a focus on natural materials. Enjoy the private lakefront setting with direct access to the water, kayaks, a canoe, and a boathouse, perfect for exploring the lake and enjoying the surrounding nature.
A Hut! Just A Zzz Space - Ithaca, NY
9.3 55 reviews

A Hut! Just A Zzz Space

cabin, East Ithaca
This unique cabin is located just 3 kilometres from downtown Ithaca and Cornell University, making it a convenient base for exploring this vibrant area. It has received excellent user ratings for its location and cleanliness, with guests praising its peaceful setting and close proximity to attractions.
The cabin has one bedroom, sleeping up to two guests, and offers a quirky and unconventional accommodation experience. It features basic amenities such as electricity, Wi-Fi, and a private toilet, with access to a BBQ and picnic table in the backyard for outdoor relaxation.
Cayuga Lake Hut - Ithaca, NY
10 8 reviews

Cayuga Lake Hut

cabin, Lansing
This unique floating accommodation offers a tranquil escape on a lake, located a short distance from Lansing's bustling areas, providing proximity to its natural beauty and recreational opportunities.
Ideal for day use, this vessel accommodates two guests and features a comfortable sleeping area, a firepit for evening ambiance, and direct access for swimming, kayaking, and canoeing.
Ithaca Bungalow/tiny Home, Quiet Escape In City - Ithaca, NY
9.9 328 reviews

Ithaca Bungalow/tiny Home, Quiet Escape In City

bungalow, Ithaca
This studio apartment is situated in a peaceful neighbourhood just 0.8 km from Ithaca College and 1.1 km from Cornell University, offering easy access to the city's attractions. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience.
The self-catering accommodation sleeps two guests and features a kitchen with a fridge, freezer, and microwave, as well as a private patio and a sunroom. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including air conditioning, a washing machine and dryer, and a garden, plus they can explore the owner's nearby ceramic studio and gallery.

Our Favourite Unique Stays for Families in Ithaca, NY

Choose a family-friendly unique stay in Ithaca, NY to keep the kids entertained near top city attractions.

Scottland Yard Farm's - Upscale Rustic Garden House - Ithaca, NY
9.7 187 reviews

Scottland Yard Farm's - Upscale Rustic Garden House

cabin, Dryden
This Dryden holiday home is located in Brooktondale, just a short drive from Six Mile Creek Vineyard, Cornell University, and Cayuga Lake. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This one-bedroom property offers a comfortable and convenient stay. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a private pool, a jacuzzi, a terrace, a garden, and a spa, as well as access to barbecue grills, laundry facilities, and free Wi-Fi.
Mountain Queen Log Cabin - Ithaca, NY
9.8 201 reviews

Mountain Queen Log Cabin

cabin, Dryden
The Mountain Queen Cabin is situated in Dryden, New York, just 15 miles from Greek Peak Ski Resort and 12 miles from Ithaca, offering a peaceful woodland setting with stunning views of the surrounding hills and forests. It consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This three-bedroom lodge spans 111 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests. The cabin provides a host of amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a private hot tub, a terrace, and a fire pit, perfect for enjoying the peaceful surroundings and exploring the nearby attractions.

Frequently asked questions about unique stays in Ithaca, NY

  • What attractions is Ithaca, NY famous for?

    Ithaca is known for its stunning natural beauty, especially Buttermilk Falls State Park. It's a popular spot for hiking, swimming, and picnicking. Cayuga Lake is also a must-see. You can take a boat tour, go kayaking, or simply relax on the shore and enjoy the views. Cornell University is another major attraction, drawing visitors from across the globe. It's a beautiful campus with a rich history and a lot to see and do.
  • What clothing or gear is recommended for the climate in Ithaca, NY?

    Ithaca has four distinct seasons, so it's important to pack accordingly. In the summer, you'll need light clothing, but be prepared for some humidity. In the winter, it gets cold and snowy, so pack warm layers, a hat, gloves, and a scarf. Don't forget a raincoat, as Ithaca can be quite rainy throughout the year.
  • Which neigbourhood offers the best unique stays in Ithaca, NY?

    The Collegetown neighbourhood is a great place to find unique stays. It's close to Cornell University and has a vibrant and eclectic atmosphere. You'll find a mix of historic homes, modern apartments, and everything in between.
  • What should you know about unique stays in Ithaca, NY before booking?

    Before booking a unique stay, it's important to consider your needs and preferences. Some unique stays may be located in remote areas, so you'll need to factor in transportation costs. It's also a good idea to read reviews from previous guests to get a sense of the property and the surrounding area.

Popular destinations

Top Unique Stays with a Hot Tub in Ithaca, NY

A private hot tub soak is the perfect restorative end to a busy city day in Ithaca, NY.

Dramatic Lakefront Timberframe Home - Ithaca, NY
10 22 reviews

Dramatic Lakefront Timberframe Home

apartment, Lansing
This charming chalet is situated on a lake with 200 metres of waterfront in the Finger Lakes region, just a short drive from Ithaca and Cornell University. It has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness.
The chalet offers 465 square metres of living space, accommodating up to 12 guests in its five bedrooms. Enjoy amenities like a jacuzzi, a billiards table, a home theatre system, and three fireplaces, as well as a kids' playroom and Sonos sound systems throughout.

Best pet friendly Ithaca, NY unique stays

Among the 1 accommodations in Ithaca, NY, here are the 1 best pet friendly unique accommodations

Spotted Sandpiper - Cabin #3 - Ithaca, NY
9.0 2 reviews

Spotted Sandpiper - Cabin #3

cabin, Trumansburg
This Trumansburg lakeside cottage boasts direct Cayuga Lake frontage with private beach access, kayaks, paddleboards, and canoes, and is a short drive (distance unspecified) from Buttermilk Falls State Park.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps four, offering a fully equipped kitchen, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, laundry facilities, and a covered porch with fire pit; additional accommodation is available on the four-acre property for larger groups.

Search Unique Stays with a Pool in Ithaca, NY

Enjoy an urban dip from a unique stay in Ithaca, NY with a pool, right in the city centre.

Scottland Yard Farm's - Upscale Rustic Garden House - Ithaca, NY
9.7 187 reviews

Scottland Yard Farm's - Upscale Rustic Garden House

cabin, Dryden

Explore 5-Star Unusual Places to Stay in Ithaca, NY

These luxury unique stays in Ithaca, NY offer an upscale urban retreat unlike any other.

Dramatic Lakefront Timberframe Home - Ithaca, NY
10 22 reviews

Dramatic Lakefront Timberframe Home

apartment, Lansing
©2026 cozycozy.com